Nerd Project: Difference between revisions
→Why is this research required?: addition |
wikademia>Eme m moved Nerd project to Nerd Project |
||
| (36 intermediate revisions by 18 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<center><big><big> Nerds & Geeks: An Etiological History and its Psychosocial Implications</big></big> </center> | |||
== Why is this research required? == | == Why is this research required? == | ||
The way people construct or know their own and | {{ntnes}} | ||
The way people construct or know their own and other's social identities affects the way people relate to each other and to their reality. By attaining a better understanding of what a nerd is, and where the spectrum of nerd identities/stereotypes came from, we may reach a better understanding of how this identity has shaped the way individuals experience and interact with society. | |||
It is also useful, for the purpose of establishing the historical record, to examine "the nerd" at a moment in history when the work of computer nerds in particular appears to be profoundly re-shaping advanced societies. This is causing a profound shift in the social acceptance and media portrayal of nerds, yet an extensive literature search shows that there appears to be almost no current activity in academic research on nerds. | |||
== Questions involved == | == Questions involved == | ||
| Line 34: | Line 36: | ||
* Conduct an initial literature search and review | * Conduct an initial literature search and review | ||
* Obtain and read through all the research books and papers | |||
* Structure the project | * Structure the project | ||
* Conduct additional research | * Conduct additional research | ||
| Line 83: | Line 86: | ||
Non-nerds often think of nerds as intelligent yet socially awkward people. Nerds generally express an above-normal interest in a particular complex subject and often function as polymaths. Topics dealing with science, technology, comic books, complex board games (particularly chess, role-playing games, and wargames), classical music, artificial intelligence, video games and science fiction, horror and fantasy literature books, TV shows and movies have all become heavily associated with nerds, as have conventions relating to these various topics. | Non-nerds often think of nerds as intelligent yet socially awkward people. Nerds generally express an above-normal interest in a particular complex subject and often function as polymaths. Topics dealing with science, technology, comic books, complex board games (particularly chess, role-playing games, and wargames), classical music, artificial intelligence, video games and science fiction, horror and fantasy literature books, TV shows and movies have all become heavily associated with nerds, as have conventions relating to these various topics. | ||
Despite their crucial function as a class within modern society, there has been almost no serious and methodologically-reliable academic research published on geeks/nerds, apart from a handful of studies of their consumption-based fan cultures. Some commentators have noticed similarities between pronounced nerdy behavior and the neurological disorder known as high-functioning [[Asperger's Syndrome]]. The lack of serious studies of nerds means that we have no basis for proving such a correlation, causal or other relationship between the two types. | Despite their crucial function as a class within modern society, there has been almost no serious and methodologically-reliable academic research published on geeks/nerds, apart from a handful of studies of their consumption-based fan cultures. Some commentators have noticed similarities between pronounced nerdy behavior and the neurological disorder known as high-functioning [[Asperger's Syndrome]]. The lack of serious studies of nerds means that we have no basis in research for proving such a correlation, causal or other relationship between the two types. | ||
In the practice of psychology, geeks and nerds can be said to be Myers-Briggs Type Indicator INTP, ENTP or INTJ, and, in various cases, ENTJ. However, due to speculation over the difference of nerds and geeks, the types cannot be sorted into their subsequent classifications. Also, all types have the ability to be nerds, whereas the INTJ, INTP, ENTP, and ENTJ are near definites for being nerds. The INTP is the classic programmer type, INTJ the classic scientist type. However, due to the sterotypical shyness and social ineptitude associated with nerds, the INTP and INTJ are more likely to be classified into that group than their Extroverted counterparts. These two types are the Introverted iNtuitive Thinkers. As Introverts they are stimulated by thoughts and ideas, rather than people and things. They are often quite happy spending hours absorbed in solitary activities. As iNtuitives, they are more inclined toward abstract concepts and subtle connections than in concrete examples or direct experience. As Thinkers, they are more adept in logic and reason than feelings or emotions. This combination makes INT's masters of mathematics, logic, and science, but rather oblivious to social graces. Both INTJs and INTPs tend to be outwardly nerdy and actively rebel against social rules they view as irrational and meaningless. However, INTJs tend to learn to put on a facade of surface conformism to draw less attention to themselves. For example long hair is, not surprisingly, common with INTP men, whereas INTJ men would keep their hair cut low, and dress conservatively. | In the practice of psychology, geeks and nerds can be said to be Myers-Briggs Type Indicator INTP, ENTP or INTJ, and, in various cases, ENTJ. However, due to speculation over the difference of nerds and geeks, the types cannot be sorted into their subsequent classifications. Also, all types have the ability to be nerds, whereas the INTJ, INTP, ENTP, and ENTJ are near definites for being nerds. The INTP is the classic programmer type, INTJ the classic scientist type. However, due to the sterotypical shyness and social ineptitude associated with nerds, the INTP and INTJ are more likely to be classified into that group than their Extroverted counterparts. These two types are the Introverted iNtuitive Thinkers. As Introverts they are stimulated by thoughts and ideas, rather than people and things. They are often quite happy spending hours absorbed in solitary activities. As iNtuitives, they are more inclined toward abstract concepts and subtle connections than in concrete examples or direct experience. As Thinkers, they are more adept in logic and reason than feelings or emotions. This combination makes INT's masters of mathematics, logic, and science, but rather oblivious to social graces. Both INTJs and INTPs tend to be outwardly nerdy and actively rebel against social rules they view as irrational and meaningless. However, INTJs tend to learn to put on a facade of surface conformism to draw less attention to themselves. For example long hair is, not surprisingly, common with INTP men, whereas INTJ men would keep their hair cut low, and dress conservatively. | ||
| Line 92: | Line 95: | ||
Pundits and observers dispute the relationship of the terms "nerd" and "geek" to one another, as many use the words synonymously. The two terms are commonly used incorrectly, or are misapplied, particularly by journalists. | Pundits and observers dispute the relationship of the terms "nerd" and "geek" to one another, as many use the words synonymously. The two terms are commonly used incorrectly, or are misapplied, particularly by journalists. | ||
Some view the geek as a less technically skilled nerd. Others view the exact opposite. The lines between geek and nerd are often thin and ill-defined, however a general consensus is that a "geek" is a person who obsesses in one area or another, whereas a "nerd" is a highly intelligent person who is very scholarly and does well in many domains such as math, science, computing, etc. Geeks are more associated with obsessive knowledge. For example a ''[[:wikipedia:Star Trek|Star Trek]] ''geek (or Trekkie) is someone who could tell you extremely trivial details about ''Star Trek ''and may be likely to watch the show on a daily basis or go to ''Star Trek'' conventions. A person can be a nerd in almost any subject, but is usually associated with things that most people don't do or things that require an intellect, for example a person who plays a lot of video games could be called a gaming nerd, but it would be inappropriate to call an obsessive chef a cooking nerd because many people cook and it is a daily activity, whereas video games are more of a | Some view the geek as a less technically skilled nerd. Others view the exact opposite. The lines between geek and nerd are often thin and ill-defined, however a general consensus is that a "geek" is a person who obsesses in one area or another, whereas a "nerd" is a highly intelligent person who is very scholarly and does well in many domains such as math, science, computing, etc. Geeks are more associated with obsessive knowledge. For example a ''[[:wikipedia:Star Trek|Star Trek]] ''geek (or Trekkie) is someone who could tell you extremely trivial details about ''Star Trek ''and may be likely to watch the show on a daily basis or go to ''Star Trek'' conventions. A person can be a nerd in almost any subject, but is usually associated with things that most people don't do or things that require an intellect, for example a person who plays a lot of video games could be called a gaming nerd, but it would be inappropriate to call an obsessive chef a cooking nerd because many people cook and it is a daily activity, whereas video games are more of a subculture. Another difference some people make between nerds and geeks are that nerds are more "bookworms" whose interests are in the fields of academia, such as mathematics and science. Geeks are interested in computers and video gaming, or movies with large fan-bases such as ''Star Wars''. Also, many wish to differentiate between nerds who are deeply engrossed in purely entertainment oriented genres and nerds who are deeply engrossed in subjects that require serious study and committment and have real-life career potential or applications. The fanboy type nerd, while able to absorb and recall trivia about film, television, and fictional subjects in general is not the same as an independent computer hobbyist who submits original contributions (such as freeware applications) on the internet or a person who regularly uses his intellect to solve his own computer problems without outside assistance. While both are considered highly intelligent, "nerd" has become more of a term of endearment, while "geek" still carries a more negative connotation. Nerds will often refer to themselves as nerds without shame and seek friendship with other nerds. The use of the word "geek" is slowly becoming less and less. The interchangeable use of the terms "geek" and "nerd" is a main cause of the lack of distinction between the two. A good example of this is found in an episode of the television show, ''Married... with Children''. The protagonist, Al Bundy, complains about wearing glasses, saying he will look like a nerd. His friend, Jefferson Darcy, responds, "No, Al, you won't be a nerd. You're too dumb to be a nerd." | ||
Some regional differences may exist in the use of the words nerd and geek. Some claim that on the North American west coast the population prefers the term geek to nerd, while the North American east coast prefers the word nerd to geek, (see Ellen Spertus's web page on [http://people.mills.edu/spertus/Geek/ The Sexiest Geek Alive]). | Some regional differences may exist in the use of the words nerd and geek. Some claim that on the North American west coast the population prefers the term geek to nerd, while the North American east coast prefers the word nerd to geek, (see Ellen Spertus's web page on [http://people.mills.edu/spertus/Geek/ The Sexiest Geek Alive]). | ||
== Bibliography == | == Bibliography == | ||
* Tocci, Jason. "[http://geekstudies.org/papers/mit5-presentation-notes.pdf The Well-Dressed Geek: Media Appropriation and Subcultural Style]" (Paper given at the [http://web.mit.edu/comm-forum/mit5/index.html MIT5 conference]. PDF, 180kb). | |||
* Kendall, Lori. "'The Nerd Within': Mass Media and the Negotiation of Identity Among Computer-Using Men." ''Journal of Men's Studies'', 7(3) (1999): 353-69. | |||
* Kendall, Lori. "Nerd Nation: Images of Nerds in U.S. Popular Culture." ''International Journal of Cultural Studies'', Vol. 2, No. 2, 260-283 (1999) | |||
* Kendall, Lori. "'Oh No! I'm a Nerd!': Hegemonic Masculinity on an Online Forum." ''Gender & Society'', 14 (2) (2000): 256-274. | |||
===Girl nerds=== | |||
* Bucholtz, Mary. ""Why be normal?": Language and identity practices in a community of nerd girls." ''Language in Society'' (1999), 28: 203-223. Cambridge University Press. | |||
Newitz, A. & Anders, C. (Eds) ''She's Such a Geek: Women Write About Science, Technology, and Other Nerdy Stuff''. Seal Press, 2006 | * Newitz, A. & Anders, C. (Eds) ''She's Such a Geek: Women Write About Science, Technology, and Other Nerdy Stuff''. Seal Press, 2006. | ||
''' | ===In Japan=== | ||
* ''[http://www.nri.co.jp/english/opinion/papers/2004/pdf/np200484.pdf The Otaku Group From A Business Perspective]'' (PDF, 366kb). Japan, 2004. | |||
* Okada, Toshio. ''Otaku Gaku Nyumon'' (Translated: 'Introduction to [[Wikipedia:Otaku|Otaku]]ology'). Ohta Verlag. Tokyo, 1996. | |||
* Eng, L. [http://www.cjas.org/~leng/otaku.pdf "Otak-who? Technoculture, youth, consumption, and resistance. American representations of a Japanese youth subculture"]. 2002. | |||
===Substantial cinema-released documentaries=== | |||
* ''[http://www.microcosmpublishing.com/catalog/title/1011/ $100 & a T-Shirt]'' (2004) (A feature-length documentary on U.S. fanzine editors). | |||
* ''[http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0820887/ Genuine Nerd]'' (2006) (Feature-length documentary on Toby Radloff). | |||
Frayling, Christopher. ''Mad, Bad And Dangerous?: The Scientist and the Cinema''. Reaktion Books, 2005. | ===Background material=== | ||
* Dinh, Diana. [http://www.sjsu.edu/depts/anthropology/svcp/SVCPgeek.html "The Gaming Geek Culture"] (2001). Part of the Silicon Valley Cultures Project. | |||
* Messner, M.A. & de Oca J.M. (2005) "The Male consumer as loser: Beer and liquor ads in mega sports media events." ''Journal of Women in Culture and Society'', 30, 1879–1909. | |||
* Frayling, Christopher. ''Mad, Bad And Dangerous?: The Scientist and the Cinema''. Reaktion Books, 2005. | |||
* Weeks, David. ''Eccentrics: A Study of Sanity and Strangeness.'' 2nd edition. Kodansha, 1997. (A sympathetic 200-sample study of English eccentrics, by a doctor in Edinburgh. He concludes that eccentrics are not mentally ill, and that many are saner than the general population) | |||
== Related Wikipedia Articles== | == Related Wikipedia Articles== | ||
| Line 120: | Line 128: | ||
'''Main:''' | '''Main:''' | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Nerd|Nerds]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Geek|Geeks]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Otaku|Otaku]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Boffin|Boffins]] and [[Wikipedia:Mad scientist|Mad scientists]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Asperger syndrome|Asperger's syndrome]] | ||
'''Theories from psychology and sociology:''' | '''Theories from psychology and sociology:''' | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Stereotype|Stereotypes]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Enneagram#The_Nine_Enneatypes|Enneatypes]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Social_fact|Social Fact]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Gender_Construction|Gender Construction]] | ||
'''Gaming and RPG fan cultures:''' | '''Gaming and RPG fan cultures:''' | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:GURPS|GURPS (a role-playing system)]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Roleplaying|Roleplaying]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Henry_Jenkins|Henry Jenkins]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Discworld_%28world%29|Discworld-World]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Wikipedia:Historical_re-enactment|Historical Re-Enactment]] | ||
'''Nerds in the media:''' | '''Nerds in the media:''' | ||
See: Wikipedia's [[ | See: Wikipedia's [[Wikipedia:List of nerds in media|list of nerds in the media]] | ||
== Possibly Informative Material == | == Possibly Informative Material == | ||
* [http://www.geekstudies.org/ Geek Studies weblog] | |||
* [http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/9.12/aspergers.html "The geek syndrome"] | |||
* [http://www.d-log.info/?cat=26 Dlog on nerds] | |||
* [http://www.rpgstudies.net/ Studies about fantasy role-playing games] | * [http://www.rpgstudies.net/ Studies about fantasy role-playing games] | ||
* [http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3052074,00.html "Army frowns on Dungeons and Dragons"] | * [http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3052074,00.html "Army frowns on Dungeons and Dragons"] | ||
* [http://www. | * [http://www.nerdsgonewildmagazine.com/ "Nerds Gone Wild"] magazine. | ||
[[Category:Social | [[Category:Social research]] | ||