Archive:Mongrel complex: Difference between revisions

m 159 revisions imported: Import with full history
 
(62 intermediate revisions by 41 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{short description|Inferiority complex among Brazilians regarding their nation and culture}}
{{Short description|Inferiority complex among Brazilians regarding their nation}}
{{Expand Portuguese|Complexo de vira-lata|date=June 2017}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=April 2016}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=April 2016}}
[[File:Redenção.jpg|thumb|''[[Ham's Redemption]]'' (1895), by [[Modesto Brocos y Gomes]]. A Black grandmother, mixed-race daughter, white son-in-law and grandson: for the Brazilian government of the time, with each generation, Brazilians would become whiter and thus more developed, a theory known as ''[[Blanqueamiento|branqueamento]]'']]
{{Expand Portuguese|Entreguismo|date=June 2017}}
"'''Mongrel complex'''", or alternatively "'''mutt complex'''" ({{lang-pt|complexo de vira-lata|lit=[[street dog]] complex, mutt complex}}), is an expression used to refer to a [[Collective behavior|collective]] [[inferiority complex]] reportedly felt by many [[Brazilians]] when comparing Brazil and its [[Brazilian culture|culture]] to other parts of the world, primarily the [[developed world]] (such as Europe or North America), as the reference to a "[[mongrel]]" carries negative connotations attributed by Brazilians to the racist perception of [[Race in Brazil|most Brazilians being racially mixed]] as well as lacking in desirable [[Sophistication|cultural refinement]].
 
"'''Mongrel complex'''", or alternatively "'''mutt complex'''" ({{langx|pt|complexo de vira-lata|lit=[[street dog]] complex, mutt complex, stray dog complex}}), is an expression that refers to a feeling of "[[Collective behavior|collective]] [[inferiority complex]]" reportedly felt by many [[Brazilians]] when comparing Brazil and its [[Brazilian culture|culture]] to other parts of the world.


==Background==
==Background==
The term was originally coined by novelist and writer [[Nelson Rodrigues]], initially referring to the [[Psychological trauma|trauma]] suffered by Brazilians in 1950 when the [[Brazil national football team|national football team]] was defeated by [[Uruguay national football team|Uruguay's national team]] in [[Uruguay v Brazil (1950 FIFA World Cup)|the final match]] of the [[1950 World Cup]], which was held at the [[Maracanã Stadium|Maracanã]] in Rio de Janeiro. The estimated 200,000 spectators at the stadium that day were stunned into an eerie silence after the match concluded, some so distraught they committed suicide inside the stadium.<ref>{{Cite web|title=A Look Back: When Uruguay Shocked Brazil in the 1950 World Cup – World Soccer Talk|date=13 May 2014|url=https://worldsoccertalk.com/2014/05/13/a-look-back-when-uruguay-shocked-brazil-in-the-1950-world-cup/}}</ref> Brazil would recover, at least when it comes to football, in 1958, winning the World Cup for the first of five times,<ref>[http://www.comciencia.br/comciencia/handler.php?section=8&edicao=16&id=152 A pátria em chuteiras de Nélson Rodrigues] por Fernando Bandini. Em [http://www.comciencia.br/ Com Ciência – SBPC/Labjor]. Visited in 16 November 2007.</ref> but the idea persisted, cropping up again the next time Brazil hosted the World Cup in [[2014 FIFA World Cup|2014]] when it was defeated in [[Brazil v Germany (2014 FIFA World Cup)|the semi-final match]] against [[Germany national football team|Germany]] by a score of 7–1.
[[File:(2015-10-28) Visita às terras Kaiowás 47 Romerito Pontes (22134072983).jpg|thumb|A street mutt in Brazil]]
The term was originally coined by novelist and writer [[Nelson Rodrigues]], initially referring to the [[Psychological trauma|trauma]] suffered by Brazilians in 1950 when the [[Brazil national football team|national football team]] was defeated by [[Uruguay national football team|Uruguay's national team]] in [[Uruguay v Brazil (1950 FIFA World Cup)|the final match]] of the [[1950 World Cup]], which was held at the [[Maracanã Stadium|Maracanã]] in Rio de Janeiro. The estimated 200,000 spectators at the stadium that day were stunned into an eerie silence after the match concluded.<ref>{{Cite web|title=A Look Back: When Uruguay Shocked Brazil in the 1950 World Cup – World Soccer Talk|date=13 May 2014|url=https://worldsoccertalk.com/2014/05/13/a-look-back-when-uruguay-shocked-brazil-in-the-1950-world-cup/|url-status=dead|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20230112162325/https://worldsoccertalk.com/2014/05/13/a-look-back-when-uruguay-shocked-brazil-in-the-1950-world-cup/|archive-date=2023-01-12}}</ref> Brazil would recover, at least when it comes to football, [[1958 World Cup|in 1958]], winning the [[FIFA World Cup|World Cup]] for the [[Brazil at the FIFA World Cup|first of five times]].<ref>[http://www.comciencia.br/comciencia/handler.php?section=8&edicao=16&id=152 A pátria em chuteiras de Nélson Rodrigues] por Fernando Bandini. Em [http://www.comciencia.br/ Com Ciência – SBPC/Labjor]. Visited in 16 November 2007.</ref>


For Rodrigues, the phenomenon was not exclusively related to sport. According to him:<ref name="Mariotti">{{cite web|url=http://www.revistabsp.com.br/0608/ensaio1.htm |title=O Complexo de Inferioridade do Brasileiro |author=Humberto Mariotti |work=Instituto de Pesquisa BSP |access-date=4 January 2014 |url-status=unfit |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20071225092632/http://www.revistabsp.com.br/0608/ensaio1.htm |archivedate=25 December 2007 }}</ref>
For Rodrigues, the phenomenon was not exclusively related to sport. According to him:<ref name="Mariotti">{{cite web|url=http://www.revistabsp.com.br/0608/ensaio1.htm |title=O Complexo de Inferioridade do Brasileiro |author=Humberto Mariotti |work=Instituto de Pesquisa BSP |access-date=4 January 2014 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20071225092632/http://www.revistabsp.com.br/0608/ensaio1.htm |archive-date=25 December 2007 }}</ref>


{{Cquote
{{Cquote
| text = By "Mongrel Complex" I mean the inferiority in which Brazilians put themselves, voluntarily, in comparison to the rest of the world. Brazilians are the backward [[:wikt:narcissus|Narcissus]], who spit in their own image. Here is the truth: we can't find personal or historical pretexts for self-esteem.
| text = By "Mongrel Complex" I mean the inferiority in which Brazilians place themselves, voluntarily, when they compare themselves to the rest of the world. Brazilians are the backward [[:wikt:narcissus|Narcissus]], who spits in his own image. Here is the truth: we cannot find any personal or historical pretexts for self-esteem.
| author = [[Nelson Rodrigues]]
| author = [[Nelson Rodrigues]]
| source =  
| source =  
}}
}}


The expression "mongrel complex" was rediscovered in 2004 by American journalist [[Larry Rohter]]. In an article for ''[[The New York Times]]'' about the Brazilian nuclear program, he wrote:
The expression "mongrel complex" was cited in 2004 by American journalist [[Larry Rohter]]. In an article for ''[[The New York Times]]'' about the Brazilian nuclear program, he wrote:<ref>{{Cite news |last=Rohter |first=Larry |date=2004-10-31 |title=If Brazil Wants to Scare the World, It's Succeeding |url=https://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/31/weekinreview/if-brazil-wants-to-scare-the-world-its-succeeding.html |access-date=2026-07-06 |work=The New York Times |language=en-US |issn=0362-4331}}</ref>


{{Cquote|text=Writing in the 1950s, the playwright Nelson Rodrigues saw his countrymen as afflicted with a sense of inferiority, and he coined a phrase that Brazilians now use to describe it: "the mongrel complex". Brazil has always aspired to be taken seriously as a world power by the heavyweights, and so it pains Brazilians that world leaders could confuse their country with Bolivia, as [[Ronald Reagan]] once did, or dismiss a nation so large – it has 180 million people – as "not a serious country", as [[Charles de Gaulle]] did.<ref>[https://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/31/weekinreview/31roht.html?ex=1256965200&en=37262794038df2bd&ei=5088&partner=rssnyt If Brazil Wants to Scare the World, It's Succeeding]". ''[[The New York Times]]''. Visited in 16-11-2007.</ref>|author=Larry Rohter|source=}}
{{Cquote
| text = Writing in the 1950s, the playwright Nelson Rodrigues saw his countrymen as afflicted with a sense of inferiority, and he coined a phrase that Brazilians now use to describe it: "the mongrel complex". Brazil has always aspired to be taken seriously as a world power by the heavyweights, and so it pains Brazilians that world leaders could confuse their country with Bolivia, as [[Ronald Reagan]] once did, or dismiss a nation so large – it has 180 million people – as "not a serious country", as [[Charles de Gaulle]] did.<ref>[https://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/31/weekinreview/31roht.html?ex=1256965200&en=37262794038df2bd&ei=5088&partner=rssnyt If Brazil Wants to Scare the World, It's Succeeding]". ''[[The New York Times]]''. Visited in 16-11-2007.</ref>
| author = Larry Rohter
| source =  
}}


== Origins ==
== Origins ==


The idea that the Brazilian people are inferior to others or "[[Degeneration theory|degenerate]]" is not novel and dates back to the 19th century, when French nobleman [[Arthur de Gobineau]] visited [[Rio de Janeiro]] in 1845 and described [[Carioca|the city's residents]] as "unbelievably ugly monkeys".<ref>{{Cite web|title=The discomfort of not being white (O desconforto de não ser branco), in portuguese|url=http://www.bvgf.fgf.org.br/portugues/critica/artigos_imprensa/desconforto.htm|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20060822225033/http://www.bvgf.fgf.org.br/portugues/critica/artigos_imprensa/desconforto.htm|archive-date=22 August 2006|url-status=live}}</ref>
In the 1920s and 1930, many currents of thought clashed concerning the origin of the supposed inferiority. Some, such as [[Nina Rodrigues]], [[Oliveira Viana]], and [[Monteiro Lobato]] proclaimed that [[miscegenation]] was the root of all evils and that the white race was superior to others.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Abreu |first=Diego Candido |date=2023 |title=O Complexo de vira-lata e a Solução Porto Rico: |url=https://periodicos.ufop.br/caletroscopio/article/view/6795 |journal=Caletroscópio |language=pt |volume=11 |issue=2 |pages=10–27 |doi=10.58967/caletroscopio.v11.n2.2023.6795 |issn=2318-4574|doi-access=free }}</ref>


In the 1920s and 1930, many currents of thought clashed concerning the origin of the supposed inferiority. Some, such as [[:pt:Nina Rodrigues|Nina Rodrigues]], [[Oliveira Viana]], and [[Monteiro Lobato]] proclaimed that [[miscegenation]] was the root of all evils and that the white race was superior to others.
Others, such as [[Roquette-Pinto]], claimed that the inferiority was a matter of [[ignorance]], rather than miscegenation.<ref>{{Cite web |title=Pensamento social brasileiro |url=https://www2.anhembi.br/publique/media/pensbra.doc |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140826114044/https://www2.anhembi.br/publique/media/pensbra.doc |archive-date=26 August 2014 |access-date=30 May 2026 |website=www2.anhembi.br |language=pt-BR|url-status=dead }}</ref>


Others, such as [[:pt:Roquette-Pinto|Roquette-Pinto]], claimed that the inferiority was a matter of [[ignorance]], rather than miscegenation.
In 1903, Lobato reveals himself to be profoundly pessimistic about the potential of the Brazilian people, by him thus defined:<blockquote>Brazil, son of inferior parents – destitute of these strongest characters that imprint an unmistakable stamp in certain individuals, such as it happens to the German, the English, grew up sadly – resulting in a worthless kind, incapable of continuing to self develop without the vivifying assistance of the blood of some original race.<ref>{{Cite book|last=Lobato|first=Monteiro|title=A todo transe|publisher=Brasiliense|year=1959|location=São Paulo}}</ref></blockquote>Aside from the [[Mestiço#Mestiço community in Brazil|mixed origin]], Brazilians supposedly would suffer from the fact they live in the tropics, where the "hot and humid climate would predispose inhabitants to [[Sloth (sin)|sloth]] and [[lust]]" (another thesis that was held dear at the time, [[geographical determinism]], alleged that the true civilizations can only develop in [[temperate climate]]s).{{citation needed |date=October 2026}}


In 1903, Lobato reveals himself to be profoundly pessimistic about the potential of the Brazilian people, by him thus defined:<blockquote>Brazil, son of inferior parents – destitute of these strongest characters that imprint an unmistakable stamp in certain individuals, such as it happens to the German, the English, grew up sadly – resulting in a worthless kind, incapable of continuing to self develop without the vivifying assistance of the blood of some original race.<ref>{{Cite book|last=Lobato|first=Monteiro|title=A todo transe|publisher=Brasiliense|year=1959|location=São Paulo}}</ref></blockquote>Aside from the [[Mestizo|mixed origin]], Brazilians supposedly also suffer from the fact they live in the tropics, where the hot and humid climate would predispose inhabitants to [[Sloth (deadly sin)|sloth]] and [[lust]] (another thesis that was held dear at the time, [[geographical determinism]], alleged that the true civilizations can only develop in [[temperate climate]]s).
Nevertheless, when Lobato published {{ill|Urupês (book)|lt=Urupes|pt|Urupês (livro)}} in 1918, portraying "{{ill|Jeca Tatu|pt}}", the Brazilian elite was starting to favor another explanation of the "backwardness" of the country. With the publication of a series of public health studies ordered by [[Oswaldo Cruz]], then-current poor sanitary conditions at the countryside take place as the main cause of the "lack of vigor" and the "indolence" of the Brazilians. [[Sanitary engineering|Sanitarism]] becomes the trend and Lobato himself engages in the effort of converting Brazil into a "big hospital", in the words of physician {{ill|Miguel da Silva Pereira|lt=Miguel Pereira|pt}}. This effort peaks in 1924, when Lobato publishes "a história do Jecatatuzinho" ("the story of little Jeca Tatu"), used as an advert for {{ill|Biotônico Fontoura|pt}}, a traditional nutritional supplement. In the story, after being healed "by science", Jeca Tatu, the titular character, becomes a model citizen and entrepreneur, capable even of surpassing the production of his prosperous neighbor – an [[Italian Brazilians|Italian immigrant]].


Nevertheless, when Lobato published [[:pt:Urupês (livro)|Urupês]] in 1918, portraying "[[:pt:Jeca Tatu|Jeca Tatu]]", the Brazilian elite was starting to favor another explanation of the "backwardness" of the country. With the publication of a series of public health studies ordered by [[Oswaldo Cruz]], then-current poor sanitary conditions at the countryside take place as the main cause of the "lack of vigor" and the "indolence" of the Brazilians. [[Sanitary engineering|Sanitarism]] becomes the trend and Lobato himself engages in the effort of converting Brazil into a "big hospital", in the words of physician [[:pt:Miguel da Silva Pereira|Miguel Pereira]]. This effort peaks in 1924, when Lobato publishes "a história do Jecatatuzinho" ("the story of little Jeca Tatu"), used as an advert for [[:pt:Biotônico Fontoura|Biotônico Fontoura]], a traditional nutritional supplement. In the story, after being healed "by science", Jeca Tatu, the titular character, becomes a model citizen and entrepreneur, capable even of surpassing the production of his prosperous neighbor – an [[Italian Brazilians|Italian immigrant]].
=== Analysis by Vicente Palermo ===
In {{Lang|es|La alegría y la pasión: Relatos brasileños y argentinos en perspectiva comparado}} (2015), Argentine political scientist and essayist [[Vicente Palermo]] notes an ambiguity between the Brazilian people's inferiority complex and the optimistic vision of the rulers and wealthier classes.<ref name=":0">{{Cite book |last=Palermo |first=Vicente |url=https://books.google.com.br/books?id=fUv_CgAAQBAJ&pg=PA39&lpg=PA39&dq=%22Darcy+Ribeiro%22;+%22Complexo+de+vira-lata%22&source=bl&ots=CJisz-jZlm&sig=OQLEjjytbFzqy9uPCUBB-glXPOM&hl=pt-BR&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiikff00NbZAhWIW5AKHWwgDLY4ChDoAQg5MAQ#v=onepage&q=%22Darcy%20Ribeiro%22;%20%22Complexo%20de%20vira-lata%22&f=false |title=La alegría y la pasión: Relatos brasileños y argentinos en perspectiva comparada |date=1 December 2015 |publisher=[[Katz Editores]] |isbn=978-84-15917-20-5 |language=es}}</ref>{{Reference page|page=38}} Citing the sociologist [[Florestan Fernandes]] in his analysis, the essayist affirms that the inferiority complex is fading, as a result of social plurality and the gradual decrease in the veiled prejudice that has always existed in Brazilian society.<ref name=":0" />{{Reference page|page=39}} He also cites the anthropologist and writer [[Darcy Ribeiro]], who attributed to Brazilian society "a cultural syncretism that values mixed-race origin".<ref name=":0" />{{Reference page|page=39}} Palermo also cites the journalist and filmmaker [[Arnaldo Jabor]].<ref name=":0" />{{Reference page|page=39}}


==Criticism==
==Criticism==
{{Unreferenced section|date=June 2025}}


However, many Brazilian critics and writers have opposed this concept, arguing that the idea of ​​a "complex" often ignores the nuances of cultural and artistic appreciation. Among these critics, we can highlight names such as [[Adélia Prado]], [[Augusto de Campos]] and [[Hilda Hilst]]. Each, in their own way, presented arguments that challenge Nelson Rodrigues' view.
However, many Brazilian critics and writers have opposed this concept, arguing that the idea of a "complex" often ignores the nuances of cultural and artistic appreciation. Among these critics are names such as [[Adélia Prado]], [[Augusto de Campos]] and [[Hilda Hilst]]. Each, in their own way, presented arguments that challenge Nelson Rodrigues' view.
 
Reasons and Arguments Against the "Mongrel Complex"
 
*Subjectivity of Art: Many argue that artistic appreciation is subjective and that Brazilians, or any people, cannot be expected to value national art just because of their nationality. Taste is something personal, and aesthetic choices can and should be free from patriotic impositions.
 
*Value of Criticism: Criticism of national production should not be seen as a slight against Brazil, but as a fundamental role for any artist and for the evolution of art. Constructive criticism is essential for improvement, and diversity of opinions can lead to improvements and innovations.
 
*Relationship to Racism: Some critics argue that the concept of "mongrel complex" can have [[racist]] and elitist connotations, implying that criticism of national culture is a negative trait, divided between an "us" (patriots) and a "them" (critics). This simplistic view ignores the rich diversity and social, economic and historical contexts that shape culture and the reception of art in Brazil.
 
*Patriotism and Identity: There is a debate around the imposition of an uncritical patriotism, in which everyone is expected to value the cultural contributions of their country without question. Critics and writers argue that love of country should be reflective, not blind, and that cultural identity is complex and plural. The obligation to like something just because it is of national origin should not be seen as a value, but rather as a limitation.
 
*The Role of Globalization: In the era of [[globalization]], culture circulates more fluidly, and it is natural for artists and consumers to be attracted to productions from other places. This does not diminish national culture, but rather situates it in a broader context, where value is derived from many factors and not just nationality.


==See also==
==See also==
Line 52: Line 47:
* [[Cultural cringe]]
* [[Cultural cringe]]
* [[Culture of Brazil]]
* [[Culture of Brazil]]
* [[Malinchism]]
* [[Malinchism]] (Another nationalist derogatory term)
* [[Multiculturalism]]
* [[Multiculturalism]]
* [[Nationalism]]
* [[Nationalism]]
Line 68: Line 63:
[[Category:Nationalism]]
[[Category:Nationalism]]
[[Category:Far-right politics in Brazil]]
[[Category:Far-right politics in Brazil]]
[[Category:Anti-national sentiment toward self-nations]]
[[Category:Self-criticism]]