Archive:Temporary Committee on the ECHELON Interception System: Difference between revisions

m 37 revisions imported: Import with full history
 
(34 intermediate revisions by 13 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The '''Temporary Committee on ECHELON''' was a [[Committees of the European Parliament|Committee of the European Parliament]] that was set up to investigate the global surveillance network [[ECHELON]].<ref>{{cite web|last=Ruuda|first=Marit|title=Echelon committee suspicions grow|url=http://euobserver.com/news/2337|publisher=[[EUobserver]]|accessdate=27 January 2014|date=16 May 2001}}</ref>  
<!-- Please do not remove or change this AfD message until the discussion has been closed. -->
{{Article for deletion/dated|page=Temporary Committee on the ECHELON Interception System|timestamp=20261101132357|year=2026|month=November|day=1|substed=yes|help=off|outcome=merging|target=ECHELON}}
<!-- Once discussion is closed, please place on talk page: {{Old AfD multi|page=Temporary Committee on the ECHELON Interception System|date=1 November 2026|result='''keep'''}} -->
<!-- End of AfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point -->
The '''Temporary Committee on the ECHELON Interception System''' was a [[Committees of the European Parliament|Committee of the European Parliament]] that was set up in 2000 to investigate the global surveillance network [[ECHELON]]. The committee issued its final report in 2001.<ref>{{cite web|last=Ruuda|first=Marit|title=Echelon committee suspicions grow|url=http://euobserver.com/news/2337|publisher=[[EUobserver]]|accessdate=27 January 2014|date=16 May 2001}}</ref>


== Findings ==
== Background ==
{{expand section|date=January 2014}}
On 15 June 2000, the [[Conference of Presidents of the European Parliament]] proposed setting up a temporary committee on the ECHELON interception system. The goal of the committee was to confirm the existence of ECHELON and to assess the compatibility of such a system with European law.<ref>{{cite web|title=Setting up a temporary committee on the ECHELON interception system|url=http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=MOTION&reference=B5-2000-0593&language=EN|publisher=[[European Parliament]]|accessdate=27 January 2014|date=29 June 2000}}</ref>


In 2001, the commitee concluded that the [[ECHELON]] surveillance system "almost certainly" existed, but it also acknowledged that beyond stepping up diplomatic pressure on the [[Five Eyes]] to abide by privacy laws, there is not much that the [[European Union]] could do to evade their surveillance.<ref>{{cite web|last=Leyden|first=John|title=Europe should tackle home-grown Echelons, says MEP|url=http://www.theregister.co.uk/Print/2001/07/06/europe_should_tackle_homegrown_echelons/|publisher=[[The Register]]|accessdate=27 January 2014|date=6 July 2001}}</ref>
The committee was chaired by the Portuguese politician [[Carlos Coelho (politician)|Carlos Coelho]]. It began investigating the ECHELON system in late 2000.<ref>{{cite web|title=Echelon committee starts work|url=http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=PRESS&reference=NR-20000914-1&format=XML&language=EN#SECTION5|publisher=[[European Parliament]]|accessdate=27 January 2014|date=14 September 2000}}</ref>


The following is an excerpt taken from the final report of the committee:
== Final report ==


{{Collapse top|title=Excerpt of the final report of the commitee dated 11 July, 2001<ref name="EUechelon"/>
In 2001, the committee concluded that the ECHELON surveillance system "almost certainly" existed, but it also acknowledged that beyond stepping up diplomatic pressure on the [[Five Eyes]] to abide by privacy laws, there is not much that the [[European Union]] could do to evade their surveillance.<ref>{{cite web|last=Leyden|first=John|title=Europe should tackle home-grown Echelons, says MEP|url=https://www.theregister.co.uk/Print/2001/07/06/europe_should_tackle_homegrown_echelons/|publisher=[[The Register]]|accessdate=27 January 2014|date=6 July 2001}}</ref>
}}
'''Title: Report on the existence of a global system for the interception of private and commercial communications'''<ref name="EUechelon">{{cite web|title=Report on the existence of a global system for the interception of private and commercial communications (ECHELON interception system) (2001/2098(INI))|url=http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=REPORT&reference=A5-2001-0264&format=XML&language=EN|publisher=[[European Parliament]]|date=11 July 2001|accessdate=10 September 2013}}</ref>


'''Date: 11 July 2001'''<ref name="EUechelon"/>
In its final report, the committee noted the following two features of the ECHELON surveillance network that is described as "unusual":


''The system known as ‘ECHELON’ is an interception system which differs from other intelligence systems in that it possesses two features which make it quite unusual:''
{{quote|The first such feature attributed to it is the capacity to carry out quasi-total surveillance. Satellite receiver stations and spy satellites in particular are alleged to give it the ability to intercept any [[telephone]], [[fax]], [[Internet]] or [[e-mail]] message sent by any individual and thus to inspect its contents.


''The first such feature attributed to it is the capacity to carry out quasi-total surveillance. Satellite receiver stations and spy satellites in particular are alleged to give it the ability to intercept any [[telephone]], [[fax]], [[Internet]] or [[e-mail]] message sent by any individual and thus to inspect its contents.''
The second unusual feature of ECHELON is said to be that the system operates worldwide on the basis of cooperation proportionate to their capabilities among several states (the UK, the United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand), giving it an added value in comparison to national systems: the states participating in ECHELON ([[UKUSA Agreement|UKUSA states]]) can place their interception systems at each other’s disposal, share the cost and make joint use of the resulting information.<ref name="EUechelon">{{cite web|title=Report on the existence of a global system for the interception of private and commercial communications (ECHELON interception system) (2001/2098(INI))|url=http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=REPORT&reference=A5-2001-0264&format=XML&language=EN|publisher=[[European Parliament]]|date=11 July 2001|accessdate=10 September 2013}}</ref>}}


''The second unusual feature of ECHELON is said to be that the system operates worldwide on the basis of cooperation proportionate to their capabilities among several states (the [[UK]], the [[USA]], [[Canada]], [[Australia]] and [[New Zealand]]), giving it an added value in comparison to national systems: the states participating in ECHELON ([[UKUSA Agreement|UKUSA states]]) can place their interception systems at each other’s disposal, share the cost and make joint use of the resulting information. This type of international cooperation is essential in particular for the worldwide interception of satellite communications, since only in this way is it possible to ensure in international communications that both sides of a dialogue can be intercepted. It is clear that, in view of its size, a satellite receiver station cannot be established on the territory of a state without that state’s knowledge. Mutual agreement and proportionate cooperation among several states in different parts of the world is essential.''
However, due to opposition from major political parties, the report failed to attract much public attention. Carlos Coelho, a Portuguese politician who served as the committee's chairman, remarked that "everyone has chosen to forget this report and its conclusions".<ref>{{cite web|title=Echelon and the European Parliament|url=http://www.europarl.europa.eu/aboutparliament/en/00b51db9d2/Parliament-in-the-past.html|publisher=[[European Parliament]]|accessdate=27 January 2014}}</ref>


''Possible threats to privacy and to businesses posed by a system of the ECHELON type arise not only from the fact that is a particularly powerful monitoring system, but also that it operates in a largely legislation-free area. Systems for the interception of international communications are not usually targeted at residents of the home country. The person whose messages were intercepted would have no domestic legal protection, not being resident in the country concerned. Such a person would be completely at the mercy of the system. Parliamentary supervision would also be inadequate in this area, since the voters, who assume that interception ‘only’ affects people abroad, would not be particularly interested in it, and elected representatives chiefly follow the interests of their voters.''
== Controversy ==
 
The committee was first proposed by the [[European Green Party]]. However, the original plan was scrapped due to opposition from major political groups in the [[European Parliament]].<ref>{{cite web|last=Buuren|first=Jelle|title=European Parliament votes against inquiry committee on Echelon|url=http://www.heise.de/tp/artikel/6/6891/1.html|accessdate=27 January 2014|publisher=[[Heise Online]]|date=5 July 2000}}</ref> According to critics, the committee has been unable to fully investigate the ECHELON system.<ref>{{cite web|last=Buuren|first=Jelle|title=Greens: European Parliament is obstructing inquiry on Echelon|url=http://www.heise.de/tp/artikel/6/6844/1.html|publisher=[[Heise Online]]|date=9 June 2000}}</ref>
 
=== Premature cancellation of delegation trip ===
 
In May 2001, as the committee was finalizing its report on ECHELON, a delegation was sent to [[Washington, D.C.]] to investigate the surveillance network, with planned trips to meet U.S. officials from various government bodies including the following agencies and departments:
 
* U.S. [[Central Intelligence Agency]] (CIA)
* U.S. [[United States Department of Commerce|Department of Commerce]] (DOC)
* U.S. [[National Security Agency]] (NSA)


''That being so, it is hardly surprising that the hearings held in the [[US Congress]] concerning the activities of the [[NSA]] were confined to the question of whether US citizens were affected by it, with no real concern expressed regarding the existence of such a system in itself. It thus seems all the more important to investigate this issue at European level.''<ref name="EUechelon"/>
All meetings were cancelled by the U.S. government and the committee was forced to end its trip prematurely. According to a [[BBC]] correspondent, "the Americans deny the very existence of the network and, not surprisingly, cold-shouldered the EU delegation".<ref>{{cite web|last=Roxburgh|first=Angus|title=EU investigators 'snubbed' in US|url=https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/1325186.stm|publisher=[[BBC]]|access-date=28 January 2014|date=11 May 2001}}</ref>
{{Collapse bottom}}
{{clear}}


== Controversy ==
Several EU member states such as Britain and the Netherlands declined to contribute to the report and refused to co-operate with their parliaments to investigate the ECHELON system.<ref>{{cite web|last=Hemmer Pihl|first=Luise|title=Danish parliament denies existence of Echelon|url=http://euobserver.com/news/2430|publisher=[[EUobserver]]|accessdate=28 January 2014|date=28 May 2001}}</ref>


The committee was first proposed by the [[European Green Party]]. However, the original plan was scrapped due to opposition from major political groups in the [[European Parliament]].<ref>{{cite web|last=Buuren|first=Jelle|title=European Parliament votes against inquiry committee on Echelon|url=http://www.heise.de/tp/artikel/6/6891/1.html|accessdate=27 January 2014|publisher=[[Heise Online]]|date=5 July 2000}}</ref> According to critics, the committee has been unable to fully investigate the ECHELON system.<ref>{{cite web|last=Buuren|first=Jelle|title=Greens: European Parliament is obstructing inquiry on Echelon|url=http://www.heise.de/tp/artikel/6/6844/1.html|publisher=[[Heise Online]]|date=09 June 2000}}</ref>
== See also ==


== External links ==
* [[Temporary Committee on the alleged use of European countries by the CIA for the transport and illegal detention of prisoners]]


* [http://audiovisual.europarl.europa.eu/Package.aspx?id=9016 Temporary Committee on Echelon]
== References ==
{{reflist}}


==References ==
== External links ==
<references/>
* [http://audiovisual.europarl.europa.eu/Package.aspx?id=9016 Temporary Committee on the ECHELON Interception System]


[[Category:Committees of the European Parliament]]
[[Category:Committees of the European Parliament]]