Tudor IT Process Assessment: Difference between revisions

mNo edit summary
Cleanup: remove deletion notice and missing templates
 
(15 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{short description|Process assessment framework}}
'''Tudor IT Process Assessment''' ('''TIPA''') is a methodological framework for process assessment. Its first version was published in 2003 by the [[CRP Henri Tudor|Public Research Centre Henri Tudor]] based in Luxembourg. TIPA is now a registered trademark of the [[Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology]] (LIST). TIPA offers a structured approach to determine [[process capability]] compared to recognized best practices. TIPA also supports process improvement by providing a gap analysis and proposing improvement recommendations.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa|title=Assess and Improve Your IT Processes with the TIPA Framework}}</ref>
{{multiple issues|
{{COI|date=July 2015}}
{{advert|date=July 2015}}
{{notability|date=July 2015}}
}}
 
'''Tudor IT Process Assessment''' ('''TIPA''') is a methodological framework for process assessment. Its first version was published in 2003 by the [[CRP Henri Tudor|Public Research Centre Henri Tudor]] based in Luxembourg. TIPA is now a registered trademark of the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST). TIPA offers a structured approach to determine [[process capability]] compared to recognized best practices. TIPA also supports process improvement by providing a gap analysis and proposing improvement recommendations.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa|title=Assess and Improve Your IT Processes with the TIPA Framework}}</ref>


[[File:The TIPA framework structure.PNG|thumb|TIPA combines domain-specific process models with the generic TIPA Process Assessment Method.|upright=2]]
[[File:The TIPA framework structure.PNG|thumb|TIPA combines domain-specific process models with the generic TIPA Process Assessment Method.|upright=2]]


TIPA uses the generic approach for process assessment published by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) in [[ISO/IEC 15504]]<ref>[http://www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=37458 ISO_IEC 15504-2]</ref> – Process Assessment (now ISO/IEC 33000). The ISO/IEC 15504-2 requirements on performing assessments are structured and documented in the TIPA Assessment Process. Additional guidance, contextual advice and return of experience complete the TIPA Process Assessment Method and support the usability of the TIPA framework. The TIPA Process Assessment Method (TIPA) can be used to assess processes from any field of activity.
TIPA uses the generic approach for process assessment published by the [[International Organization for Standardization]] (ISO) and the [[International Electrotechnical Commission]] (IEC) in [[ISO/IEC 15504]]<ref>[http://www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=37458 ISO_IEC 15504-2]</ref> – Process Assessment (now ISO/IEC 33000). The ISO/IEC 15504-2 requirements on performing assessments are structured and documented in the TIPA Assessment Process. Additional guidance, contextual advice and return of experience complete the TIPA Process Assessment Method and support the usability of the TIPA framework. The TIPA Process Assessment Method (TIPA) can be used to assess processes from any field of activity.


The TIPA framework is supported by an exhaustive toolbox that provides templates and tools for every single step of the assessment process. It can be customized to any application domain.
The TIPA framework is supported by an exhaustive toolbox that provides templates and tools for every single step of the assessment process. It can be customized to any application domain.
Line 19: Line 12:
The [[gap analysis]] helps identify [[SWOT analysis|SWOTs]], get a clear picture of the current state and identify improvement recommendations.
The [[gap analysis]] helps identify [[SWOT analysis|SWOTs]], get a clear picture of the current state and identify improvement recommendations.


Interviews with process actors are used to understand the way the process is performed and a process maturity rating scale is used to measure the gap between the frame of reference and the field reality.
Interviews with process actors are used to understand how process is performed and a process maturity rating scale is used to measure the gap between the frame of reference and the field reality.
An assessment project starts with a clear goal statement to define the scope of the project. The project involves a series of roles who take part in the assessment. The project is organized in 6 phases. It is supported by several tools (templates and spreadsheets) provided in the TIPA Toolbox.<ref>[http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa/tipa-toolbox/ The TIPA toolbox]</ref>
An assessment project starts with a clear goal statement to define the scope of the project. The project involves a series of roles who take part in the assessment. The project is organized in 6 phases. It is supported by several tools (templates and spreadsheets) provided in the TIPA Toolbox.<ref>[http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa/tipa-toolbox/ The TIPA toolbox]</ref>


Line 27: Line 20:
This led to the definition of the AIDA (Assessment and Improvement integrateD Approach) research & development project in 2003, aiming at applying a common method for the definition and assessment of processes for both the software development and IT operations sides. The project resulted in the creation of a structured process assessment method for [[IT Service Management]] based on [[ITIL]]. That method was fully compatible with the method described in ISO/IEC 15504 originally designed to assess software development processes.
This led to the definition of the AIDA (Assessment and Improvement integrateD Approach) research & development project in 2003, aiming at applying a common method for the definition and assessment of processes for both the software development and IT operations sides. The project resulted in the creation of a structured process assessment method for [[IT Service Management]] based on [[ITIL]]. That method was fully compatible with the method described in ISO/IEC 15504 originally designed to assess software development processes.


The first Process Assessment model for ITIL v2 was developed and experimented during the years 2004-2005 in partnership with ITIL experts. More experimentation took place the following years locally in Luxembourg and several other regions of the world.  
The first Process Assessment model for ITIL v2 was developed and experimented during the years 2004–2005 in partnership with ITIL experts. More experimentation took place in the following years locally in Luxembourg and several other regions of the world.  
In 2009 AIDA was rebranded as TIPA (Tudor IT Process Assessment) and this brand officially registered.<ref>TIPA® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Centre de Recherche Public Henri Tudor.</ref>  
In 2009 AIDA was rebranded as TIPA (Tudor IT Process Assessment) and this brand officially registered.<ref>TIPA® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Centre de Recherche Public Henri Tudor.</ref>  
The complete method was published in the book “ITSM Process Assessment Supporting ITIL“, released in 2009.
The complete method was published in the book “ITSM Process Assessment Supporting ITIL“, released in 2009.
Line 36: Line 29:


==Applications==
==Applications==
*To compare your processes with the state of the art  
* Comparing processes with the state of the art  
*To determine your process capability
* Determining process capability
*To compare your process capability with processes from other domains
* Comparing process capability with processes from other domains
*To identify process strengths, weaknesses, and areas of improvement
* Identifying process strengths, weaknesses, and areas of improvement
*To structure the improvement initiative and setup priorities
* Structuring the improvement initiative and setup priorities
*To monitor the progress and demonstrate the merits of improvement actions
* Monitoring the progress and demonstrate the merits of improvement actions
*To benchmark partners  
* Benchmarking partners  
*To benchmark with competitors
* Benchmarking with competitors
*To support provider selection according to business goals and customer requirements
* Supporting provider selection according to business goals and customer requirements


==TIPA for ITIL==
==TIPA for ITIL==
Line 51: Line 44:
===ISO/IEC 15504===
===ISO/IEC 15504===
[[File:The ISO IEC 15504 Capability Scale.PNG|thumb|Processes are defined by 9 attributes. The definition of the attributes helps understanding the process capability.|upright 1.5]]
[[File:The ISO IEC 15504 Capability Scale.PNG|thumb|Processes are defined by 9 attributes. The definition of the attributes helps understanding the process capability.|upright 1.5]]
TIPA is applying the assessment approach defined in [[ISO/IEC 15504]], which can be used:
TIPA is applying the assessment approach defined in ISO/IEC 15504, which can be used:
:: a) By or on behalf of an organization with the objective of understanding the state of its own processes for process improvement;
:: a) By or on behalf of an organization with the objective of understanding the state of its own processes for process improvement;
:: b) By or on behalf of an organization with the objective of determining the suitability of its own processes for a particular requirement or class of requirements;
:: b) By or on behalf of an organization with the objective of determining the suitability of its own processes for a particular requirement or class of requirements;
Line 61: Line 54:


===ITIL===
===ITIL===
ITIL is a set of best practices for IT service management (ITSM) that focus on aligning IT services with the needs of business. ITIL has structured these best practices as processes. TIPA for ITIL enables to assess these processes. But ISO/IEC 15504 process assessment is to be performed against a compliant process assessment model, which combines the description of the process in terms of process purpose and outcomes, with performance and capability indicators. The TIPA process assessment model for ITIL contains that structured description of the ITIL processes. It was developed applying requirements engineering techniques that support the quality characteristics expected from a compliant process model (traceability, comprehensiveness, usability, assessability).
ITIL is a set of best practices for IT service management (ITSM) that focus on aligning IT services with the needs of business. ITIL has structured these best practices as processes. TIPA for ITIL enables to assess these processes. But ISO/IEC 15504 process assessment is to be performed against a compliant process assessment model, which combines the description of the process in terms of process purpose and outcomes, with performance and capability indicators. The TIPA process assessment model for ITIL contains that structured description of the ITIL processes. It was developed applying [[requirements engineering]] techniques that support the quality characteristics expected from a compliant process model ([[traceability]], comprehensiveness, usability, assessability).


===TIPA specifics===
===TIPA specifics===
{{pad|2em}}- TIPA extends the set of requirements from ISO/IEC 15504 with the provision of a detailed documented assessment process
TIPA:
 
* Extends the set of requirements from ISO/IEC 15504 with the provision of a detailed documented assessment process.
{{pad|2em}}- TIPA focuses on interviews as main means for collecting evidence of process implementation and process capability.
* Focuses on interviews as main means for collecting evidence of process implementation and process capability.
 
* Highlights the need to perform a sound SWOT analysis as part of the assessment process for process improvement.
{{pad|2em}}- TIPA highlights the need to perform a sound SWOT analysis as part of the assessment process for process improvement.
* Is provided with an exhaustive toolbox that provides templates and tools for every single step of the assessment process. It can be customized to any application domain.
 
{{pad|2em}}- TIPA is provided with an exhaustive toolbox that provides templates and tools for every single step of the assessment process. It can be customized to any application domain.


==TIPA Components==
==TIPA Components==
Line 76: Line 67:
[[File:The TIPA Assessment Process.PNG|thumb|An assessment is structured as a project, each phase being a prerequisite for the next one. Some activities may be optional for Class 3 assessments.|upright=2]]
[[File:The TIPA Assessment Process.PNG|thumb|An assessment is structured as a project, each phase being a prerequisite for the next one. Some activities may be optional for Class 3 assessments.|upright=2]]


{{pad|2em}}'''Definition phase'''
====Definition phase====
During the definition phase, the main objectives are to define the scope of the assessment, to identify the key actors, to agree on a service offer and to agree on the assessment scope agreement.
During the definition phase, the main objectives are to define the scope of the assessment, to identify the key actors, to agree on a service offer and to agree on the assessment scope agreement.


{{pad|2em}}'''Preparation phase'''
====Preparation phase====
In this phase, the objective is to discover the organizational context, and then to do an assessment planning and define the organization (by preparing the Assessment team, the supporting documents used during the assessment and the people who will be interviewed).
In this phase, the objective is to discover the organizational context, and then to do an assessment planning and define the organization (by preparing the Assessment team, the supporting documents used during the assessment and the people who will be interviewed).


{{pad|2em}}'''Assessment phase'''
====Assessment phase====
The phase is the key of the process assessment, during which interviews are done and documents reviewed to enable process rating and process capability level determination.
The phase is the key of the process assessment, during which interviews are done and documents reviewed to enable process rating and process capability level determination.


{{pad|2em}}'''Analysis phase'''
====Analysis phase====
After the Assessment phase the collected information are analysed and a SWOT analysis is performed before making improvement recommendations
After the Assessment phase the collected information are analysed and a SWOT analysis is performed before making improvement recommendations


{{pad|2em}}'''Result presentation phase'''
====Result presentation phase====
The results are presented to the relevant stakeholders, and the detailed assessment report is rendered.
The results are presented to the relevant stakeholders, and the detailed assessment report is rendered.


{{pad|2em}}'''Assessment closure phase'''
====Assessment closure phase====
The assessment project can then be closed.
The assessment project can then be closed.


Line 97: Line 88:
The six phases are supervised by at one Lead Assessor and are implemented by one or several Assessor(s).
The six phases are supervised by at one Lead Assessor and are implemented by one or several Assessor(s).


{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Assessor''': he conducts the interviews and analyses the results to draw conclusions on the assessed process maturity.
'''TIPA Assessor''': he conducts the interviews and analyses the results to draw conclusions on the assessed process maturity.


{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Lead Assessor''': he is accountable for the compliance of the method delivered and for the assessment results. He is the project manager of the assessment project. A TIPA assessment cannot be done without a Lead Assessor.
'''TIPA Lead Assessor''': he is accountable for the compliance of the method delivered and for the assessment results. He is the project manager of the assessment project. A TIPA assessment cannot be done without a Lead Assessor.


===The TIPA classes of assessment===
===The TIPA classes of assessment===
Like in the Standard CMMI Appraisal Method for Process Improvement ([[SCAMPI]]), there are three different classes of assessment in TIPA.
Like in the Standard CMMI Appraisal Method for Process Improvement ([[SCAMPI]]), there are three different classes of assessment in TIPA. A TIPA assessment can be performed using Class 1, 2 or 3 depending on the level of confidence required on the assessment results, and on the amount of resources available to perform that assessment. TIPA Class 1 requires more resources than TIPA Class 2 and TIPA Class 2 requires more resource than TIPA Class 3.
A TIPA assessment can be performed using Class 1, 2 or 3 depending on the level of confidence required on the assessment results, and on the amount of resources available to perform that assessment. TIPA Class 1 requires more resources than TIPA Class 2 and TIPA Class 2 requires more resource than TIPA Class 3.


{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Class 1''' is the most reliable class, it allow having a very high level of objectivity, rigor and confidence in the assessment result thanks to a large collection of evidence, more than the two other classes.
'''TIPA Class 1''' is the most reliable class; it allows a high level of objectivity, rigor and confidence in the assessment result, thanks to a large collection of evidence, over and above the other two classes.


{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Class 2''' corresponds to the original TIPA assessment method; it is a good balance between required resources and the usability of the assessment results.
'''TIPA Class 2''' corresponds to the original TIPA assessment method; it is a good balance between required resources and the usability of the assessment results.


{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Class 3''' is the less exhaustive assessment method. It requires less resources, rating evidence and time than the two other classes, but also provides limited assessment results with minimal process analysis.
'''TIPA Class 3''' is the less exhaustive assessment method. It requires less resources, rating evidence and time than the two other classes, but also provides limited assessment results with minimal process analysis.


====Comparative table of assessment classes====
====Comparative table of assessment classes====
Line 117: Line 107:
|-
|-
! scope="row" | Management of the assessment project
! scope="row" | Management of the assessment project
| colspan="3" ; style="text-align:center;" | 1 certified TIPA Lead Assessor required  
| colspan="3" ; style="text-align:center;" | 1 certified TIPA Lead Assessor required
|-
|-
! scope="row" | Number of Assessors  
! scope="row" | Number of Assessors  
(per process)  
(per process)  
| 2 certified TIPA Assessors (one can be the project’s Lead Assessor) || 2 certified TIPA Assessors (one can be the project’s Lead Assessor) || 1 certified TIPA Assessor (who can be the project’s Lead Assessor)
| 2 certified TIPA Assessors (one can be the project's Lead Assessor) || 2 certified TIPA Assessors (one can be the project's Lead Assessor) || 1 certified TIPA Assessor (who can be the project's Lead Assessor)
|-
|-
! scope="row" | Independence of the Assessment Team  
! scope="row" | Independence of the Assessment Team  
| Assessment Team fully independent from the organization being assessed || Assessment Team with separation of responsibility from the personnel in the organization being assessed || No requirement on the independence of the Assessment Team
| Assessment Team fully independent from the organization being assessed || Assessment Team with separation of responsibility from the personnel in the organization being assessed || No requirement on the independence of the Assessment Team
|-
|-
! scope="row" | Minimum number of interviews (per process)  
! scope="row" | Minimum number of interviews (per process)  
Line 132: Line 121:
! scope="row" | Rating of interviews  
! scope="row" | Rating of interviews  
| 1 rating per interview || 1 rating per interview || 1 single rating allowed for all interviews
| 1 rating per interview || 1 rating per interview || 1 single rating allowed for all interviews
|-
|-
! scope="row" | Level of rigor  
! scope="row" | Level of rigor  
Line 151: Line 139:


===Tools===
===Tools===
The TIPA toolbox gathers methodological and office tools to support all phases of a TIPA assessment. All TIPA Certified Assessors can use this toolbox to perform their TIPA assessment.  
The TIPA toolbox gathers methodological and office tools to support all phases of a TIPA assessment. All TIPA Certified Assessors can use this toolbox to perform their TIPA assessment.
The TIPA toolbox contains:
The TIPA toolbox contains:
*The TIPA presentation templates
*The TIPA presentation templates
*The TIPA Process Assessment Model
*The TIPA Process Assessment Model
*The project management toolset
*The [[project management]] toolset
*Questionnaires
*Questionnaires
*The process rating toolset
*The process rating toolset
Line 161: Line 149:


==TIPA Certifications==
==TIPA Certifications==
The transfer of TIPA for ITIL on the market is supported by a training and certification program run in partnership between [[ITpreneurs]] (training provider) and the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (certification authority). Certifications available are: TIPA Assessor for ITIL and TIPA Lead Assessor.
The transfer of TIPA for ITIL on the market is supported by a training and certification program run in partnership between ITpreneurs (training provider) and the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (certification authority). Certifications available are: TIPA Assessor for ITIL and TIPA Lead Assessor.


==Links to others frameworks==
==Links to others frameworks==
Line 171: Line 159:


===[[ISO/IEC 33000]]===
===[[ISO/IEC 33000]]===
ISO/IEC 33000 is an evolution of ISO/IEC 15504 published at the end of February 2015.
ISO/IEC 33000 is an evolution of ISO/IEC 15504 published at the end of February 2015. The recent works on TIPA, including the introduction of the classes of assessment are aligned with the works conducted at ISO on the ISO/IEC 33000 series.
The recent works on TIPA, including the introduction of the classes of assessment are aligned with the works conducted at ISO on the ISO/IEC 33000 series.


==Partnership==
==Partnership==
Line 180: Line 167:


==Limitations==
==Limitations==
TIPA has renamed process capability as process maturity, which is confusing.
TIPA has renamed process capability as process maturity, which may cause confusion.


TIPA for ITIL does not allow making an assessment of organisational maturity. Moreover, no benchmarking data is available so far.
TIPA for ITIL does not allow making an assessment of organisational maturity. Moreover, no benchmarking data is available so far.{{citation needed|date=December 2023}}


==References==
==References==
Line 188: Line 175:


==Bibliography==
==Bibliography==
*{{cite book|date=December 2009|url=http://www.vanharen.net/9789087535643|title=Itsm Process Assessment Supporting Itil - Using Tipa to Assess and Improve Your Processes With Iso 15504 and Prepare for Iso 20000 Certification.|format=PDF or hardcopy|work=TIPA Handbook|edition=First|isbn=9789087535643|publisher=Van Haren Publishing|access-date=1 January 2010|url-status=dead|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140822040323/http://www.vanharen.net/9789087535643|archive-date=22 August 2014}}
*{{cite book|date=December 2009|url=http://www.vanharen.net/9789087535643|title=Itsm Process Assessment Supporting Itil - Using Tipa to Assess and Improve Your Processes With Iso 15504 and Prepare for Iso 20000 Certification.|format=PDF or hardcopy<!--|work=TIPA Handbook-->|edition=First|isbn=9789087535643|publisher=Van Haren Publishing|access-date=1 January 2010|url-status=dead|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140822040323/http://www.vanharen.net/9789087535643|archive-date=22 August 2014}}


==External links==
==External links==