Calming signals: Difference between revisions

Basic article on calming signals
 
Cleanup: remove deletion notice and missing templates
 
(149 intermediate revisions by 67 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Calming Signals''' is a term coined by Turid Rugaas to describe the signals used by dogs to communicate with each other. According to Rugaas there are at least 30 Calming Signals. What signals dog use depends on the dog. They may use a subset of these signals. The signals are however universal and all dogs understand all signals even if they don't use them. Dogs are known to use these signals with humans too.  
[[File:Dog body language licking nose (no food) drooped ears (cropped).jpg|thumb|A dog displaying the lip/nose licking behavior.]]
'''Calming signals''' is a term conceived by [[Norwegians|Norwegian]] [[Dog training|dog trainer]] and canine [[Ethology|ethologist]] [[Turid Rugaas]] to describe the patterns of behavior in environments that cause heightened stress and when conveying their desires or intentions.<ref name=":2">{{cite web|last1=Rugaas|first1=Turid|title=Calming Signals - The Art of Survival|url=http://en.turid-rugaas.no/calming-signals---the-art-of-survival.html}}</ref><ref name=":3">{{cite book|last1=Rugaas|first1=Turid|url=https://archive.org/details/ontalkingtermswi0000ruga|title=On Talking Terms with Dogs: Calming Signals|date=2006|publisher=Dogwise Pub.|isbn=1929242360|edition=2nd|location=Wenatchee, Wash.|url-access=registration}}</ref> The term has been used interchangeably with "appeasement signals."<ref name=":4">{{Cite journal |last=Overall |first=Karen |date=2017 |title=Appeasement, calming signals, and information capture: how do our subjects tell us what matters to them? |journal=[[Journal of Veterinary Behavior]] |volume=19 |pages=v-viii |doi=10.1016/j.jveb.2017.04.001 |via=[[Elsevier Science Direct]]}}</ref><ref name=":1">{{Cite journal |last1=Mariti |first1=Chiara |last2=Falaschi |first2=Caterina |last3=Zilocchi |first3=Marcella |last4=Fatjó |first4=Jaume |last5=Sighieri |first5=Claudio |last6=Ogi |first6=Asahi |last7=Gazzano |first7=Angelo |date=2017 |title=Analysis of the intraspecific visual communication in the domestic dog (Canis familiaris): A pilot study on the case of calming signals |url=https://www.researchgate.net/publication/311978520 |journal=[[Journal of Veterinary Behavior]] |volume=18 |pages=49–55 |doi=10.1016/j.jveb.2016.12.009 |via=[[Elsevier]] |s2cid=151850637|hdl=11568/835281 |hdl-access=free }}</ref> Calming signals, or appeasement signals, are communicative cues used by dogs to de-escalate aggressive encounters or to prevent the development of aggressive encounters completely.<ref>{{Cite journal|last1=Mariti|first1=C.|last2=Falaschi|first2=C.|last3=Zilocchi|first3=M.|last4=Carlone|first4=B.|last5=Gazzano|first5=A.|date=November 2014|title=Analysis of calming signals in domestic dogs: Are they signals and are they calming?|url=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1558787814001348|journal=Journal of Veterinary Behavior|language=en|volume=9|issue=6|pages=e1–e2|doi=10.1016/j.jveb.2014.09.008|url-access=subscription}}</ref> Calming signals are performed by one dog (the sender) and directed towards one or more individual(s) (the recipient(s)), which could be dogs or individuals of other species, such as humans.<ref name=":1" /> When calming signals are ignored, a dog may display warning signals of aggression, and this has the potential to escalate to outright conflict between individuals.<ref name=":5">{{Cite journal|last1=Firnkes|first1=Angelika|last2=Bartels|first2=Angela|last3=Bidoli|first3=Emilie|last4=Erhard|first4=Michael|date=2017-05-01|title=Appeasement signals used by dogs during dog–human communication|url=https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1558787816302490|journal=Journal of Veterinary Behavior|language=en|volume=19|pages=35–44|doi=10.1016/j.jveb.2016.12.012|s2cid=151351008|issn=1558-7878|url-access=subscription}}</ref>


'''When dogs use calming signals'''
The [[Domestication of the dog|domestication of dogs]] by humans has significantly altered the behavioral patterns observed in ancestral species, such as the [[wolf]] (''C. lupis'').<ref name=":1" /> Dogs have developed changes in body language, as well as changes in auditory and olfactory displays over the course of some 30,000 years, and many of these modified behavioral patterns, or calming signals, can differ in meaning depending on the intended signal receiver's species.<ref name=":02">{{Cite journal|last1=Siniscalchi|first1=Marcello|last2=d’Ingeo|first2=Serenella|last3=Minunno|first3=Michele|last4=Quaranta|first4=Angelo|date=2018-07-31|title=Communication in Dogs|journal=Animals|language=en|volume=8|issue=8|pages=131|doi=10.3390/ani8080131|issn=2076-2615|pmc=6116041|pmid=30065156|doi-access=free}}</ref> Calming signals can be released by an individual voluntarily, or they can be an involuntary response to environmental stimuli as a result of stress-induced changes to body chemistry, such as the release of an odor from the body when anxious.<ref name=":02" />
According to Rugaas, the following is a list of some typical situations that dogs are naturally uncomfortable with and try to communicate their discomfort with calming signals.


• A person bending over him
== History ==
• direct, prolonged eye contact
In the past, studies on [[social behavior]] in wolves have been used to provide insight on social behavior patterns in domesticated dogs.<ref name=":1" /> Although the [[Dog|domesticated dog]] (''C. familiaris'') share a common ancestor with the wolves and may present certain similarities, distinct differences in morphology and in the environment in which the two species evolved can cause the transpiration of inaccurate conclusions about communication behavior patterns in domesticated dogs when applying knowledge gained by the study of wolves.<ref name=":1" /> Thus, the grouping of ancestral and descendant species is not found to be an appropriate method for studying calming signals in domesticated species of dogs.<ref name=":1" />
• a person’s face too close to his own face (eg, kissing on the nose)
• when someone sounds angry
• when there’s yelling and quarreling in the family
• when someone is walking directly at the dog
• when the dog is excited with happiness and anticipation (for instance by the door when you are about to go for a walk)
• when you ask the dog to do something he doesn’t feel like doing
• when your training sessions are too long and the dog gets tired
• when he is confused
• when a person hugs him
• when he feels trapped


'''List of Calming Signals'''
The threshold for aggressive behavior in domestic dogs varies from that of wolves.<ref name=":1" /> Most domestic dog [[breed]]s are less likely to engage in aggressive behavior than their ancestral counterparts, and are therefore more likely to display calming signals to defuse conflict.<ref name=":1" /> In dog breeds that differ greatly from wolf morphology, like [[pug]]s, some visual signals will be absent or highly modified as they no longer have the physical capacity or means to convey these signals.<ref name=":1" /> [[Neoteny]] can also account for the loss of certain visual signals in domestic dogs and the retention of novel signals over subsequent generations.<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":5" />
1. Licking/tongue flicks
Licking is a signal that is used often, especially by black dogs, dogs with a lot of hair around their faces, and others who’s facial expressions for some reason are more difficult to see than those of dogs with lighter colors, visible eyes and long noses.


Sometimes it’s nothing more than a very quick lick, the tip of the tongue is barely visible outside the mouth, and only for a short second. But other dogs see it, understand it and respond to it.  
== Types of Calming Signals ==
Dogs use visual, auditory, and olfactory indicators to communicate with both conspecifics and other species, such as humans.<ref name=":02" /> The majority and most well-studied calming signals are visual, and are sometimes accompanied by auditory cues (i.e. a sharp whine accompanying a yawn).<ref name=":1" />


2. Sniffing the ground
=== Examples of Visual Calming Signals ===
You will see this a lot in groups of dogs, when you and your dog are out walking and someone is coming towards you, in places where there’s a lot going on, in noisy places, or when seeing objects that the dog isn’t sure of and finds intimidating, etc.
Examples of behaviors classified as calming signals:<ref name=":2" /><ref name=":3" /><ref name=":1" />


Sniffing the ground may look anything like moving the nose swiftly down toward the ground and back up again, to sticking the nose to the ground and sniffing persistently for several minutes.
* Head turning
* Softening of the eyes
* Turning away
* Lip and/or nose licking
* Freezing of the body
* Slow body movements
* Displaying a play bow
* Sitting
* Lying down
* Yawning
* Sniffing the ground
* Walking in a curve
* Wagging the tail in a low position
* Reducing body size
* Licking the recipient's mouth
* Blinking
* Smacking of the lips
* Lifting a paw


3. Turning away/turning of the head
The behavioral patterns listed above have the potential to be used as calming signals, but are only classified as such in the appropriate context.<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":5" /> For example, a dog lying down when resting would not be considered a calming signal, but a dog lying down when approached by another dog would be considered a calming signal. Thus, calming signals are context-dependent behavioral responses to a dog's environment.<ref name=":5" />
The dog can turn his head slightly to one side, turn the head completely over to the side, or turn completely around so that the back and tail is facing whoever the dog is calming. This is one of the signals you may see most of the time in dogs.


When someone is approaching your dog from in front, he will probably turn away in one of these ways. When people or other dogs seem angry, aggressive or threatening, you may also see one of these variations of the signal. When you humans over a dog to stroke him, he may turn his head away from them. When the dog is taken by surprise or takes someone by surprise, he will turn away quickly. The same happens when someone is staring or acting in a threatening way. In most cases, this signal will make the other dog calm down.  
Not all calming signals have the same efficacy in de-escalating aggressive encounters or conveying a dog's intention and dogs preferentially display certain calming signals over others depending on external factors such as distance between the sender and the recipient of the signal, and familiarity of the recipient to the sender.<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":5" /> A dog is most likely to display a calming signal when it is directly interacting with another dog and when the dogs are separated by a small distance.<ref name=":1" /> Lip-licking is a calming signal whose use is noted to increase in frequency as the distance between the sender and the recipient decreases.<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":5" /> However, sniffing the ground and yawning, which are both considered calming signals, are most often displayed when the distance between the sender and the recipient increases.<ref name=":1" /> Calming signals that are most commonly displayed by dogs overall are freezing, licking of the nose, and turning of the body away from the source of the escalation (i.e. a dog baring its teeth or [[growling]]).<ref name=":1" />


4. Play bow
== Dog-Human Interactions ==
Going down with front legs in a bowing position can be an invitation to play if the dog is moving legs from side to side in a playful manner. Just as often, the dog is standing still while bowing and is using the signal to calm someone down. These signals often have double meanings and may be used in many different ways - often the invitation to play is a calming signal by itself because the dog is making a potentially dangerous situation less tense and diverts with something safe.
Domestic dogs display interspecific signaling, specifically towards humans.<ref name=":5" /><ref name=":02" /> Because domestic dogs co-inhabit the same environment as their owners/handlers, humans are their principle social partners,<ref name=":5" /> and there is a great level of interaction between the two.<ref name=":02" /> Licking of the lips and looking away are calming signal-categorized behaviors that are used by dogs in both [[Biological specificity|conspecific]] and heterospecific interactions, and in both instances are thought to be used to appease the recipient.<ref name=":5" /> Lip licking is also used as a greeting behavior to establish a peaceful basis for future interactions.<ref name=":5" /><ref>Giulia Pedretti, Chiara Canori et al.: ''[https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10071-023-01742-9 Appeasement function of displacement behaviours? Dogs’ behavioural displays exhibited towards threatening and neutral humans]''. In: ''Animal Cognition''. Vol. 26, 2023, page 942–952.</ref><ref>Chiara Mariti, Caterina Falaschi et al.: ''[https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1558787816302465?via%3Dihub Analysis of the intraspecific visual communication in the domestic dog (Canis familiaris): A pilot study on the case of calming signals]''. In: ''Journal of Veterinary Behavior''. Vol. 18, March–April 2017, Pages 49-55</ref><ref>Elisabeth Ann Walsh, Lieve Lucia Meers et al.: ''[https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0168159124000546 Human-dog communication: How body language and non-verbal cues are key to clarity in dog directed play, petting and hugging behaviour by humans]''. In: ''Applied Animal Behaviour Science''. Vol. 272, March 2024.</ref><ref>Franziska Kuhne, Johanna C. Hößer, Rainer Struwe: ''[https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0168159112002985 Effects of human–dog familiarity on dogs’ behavioural responses to petting]''. In: ''Applied Animal Behaviour Science''. Vol. 4, Issue 3–4, Dezember 2012, page 176–181.</ref><ref name="Csoltova">Erika Csoltova, Michaël Martineau et al.: ''[https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0031938417301403 Behavioral and physiological reactions in dogs to a veterinary examination: Owner-dog interactions improve canine well-being]''. In: ''Physiology & Behaviour''. Vol. 177, August 2017.</ref>


When two dogs approach each other too abruptly, you will often see a play bow. This is one of the signals that are easy to see, especially because they remain standing in the bow position for a few seconds so that you have plenty of time to observe it.
<Gallery class="center centered" widths="180" heights="140" perrow="4">
Dog 06-back (cropped).jpg|Turning the head aside, <br>looking away.
Paisible (cropped).jpg|Yawning during the sensation <br>of an unnatural touch.
Nannydog01 (cropped).jpg|Licking the nose during an unwelcome embrace.
Ketzel in her stylish headgear (cropped).jpg|Licking the nose wearing an [[Elizabethan collar]].<ref>Yustina Shenoda, Miael P. Ward et al.: ''[https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2615/10/2/333 “The Cone of Shame”: Welfare Implications of Elizabethan Collar Use on Dogs and Cats as Reported by their Owners ]''. In: ''Animals''. Vol. 10, Issue 2. February 2020.</ref>
</Gallery>


5. Walking slowly
Understanding canine calming signals is crucial to experiencing positive interactions with dogs.<ref name=":6">{{Cite journal |last1=Eretová |first1=Petra |last2=Chaloupková |first2=Helena |last3=Hefferová |first3=Marcela |last4=Jozífková |first4=Eva |date=2020-01-13 |title=Can Children of Different Ages Recognize Dog Communication Signals in Different Situations? |journal=[[International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health]] |language=en |volume=17 |issue=2 |pages=506 |doi=10.3390/ijerph17020506 |issn=1660-4601 |pmc=7014456 |pmid=31941151 |doi-access=free}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last1=Hall |first1=Sophie S. |last2=Brown |first2=Beverley J. |last3=Mills |first3=Daniel S. |date=2019-09-26 |title=Developing and Assessing the Validity of a Scale to Assess Pet Dog Quality of Life: Lincoln P-QoL |journal=[[Frontiers in Veterinary Science]] |volume=6 |article-number=326 |doi=10.3389/fvets.2019.00326 |issn=2297-1769 |pmc=6775215 |pmid=31616681 |doi-access=free}}</ref> Children under the age of six are least likely to correctly interpret auditory and visual calming signals displayed by dogs and, in the US, younger children have a greater probability of becoming victims of a [[Dog bite|dog attack]].<ref name=":6" /> In cases where children cannot appropriately interpret and respond to calming signals, the dog-human interaction is likely to escalate, and the dog may exhibit aggressive behaviors, such as [[biting]].<ref name=":6" /> Hugging can feel confusing and threatening to dogs. Therefore it is a common cause of dog bites in the face of young children.<ref>Ilana Reisner: ''[https://todaysveterinarypractice.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2016/09/T1301C05.pdf Dog as a second Language]''. In: ''Today's Veterinary Practice''. Januar/Februar 2013.</ref>
High speed can be upsetting to many dogs, and they might want to go in to try and stop the one who is running. This is partly a hunting behavior and is triggered by the sight of a running human or dog. If the one running is coming straight at the dog, it involves a threat and a defense mechanism sets in. A dog that is insecure tends to move slowly. If you wish to make a dog feel safer, then you can move slower.  


== Conspecific Interactions ==
Calming signals are often used by dogs post-conflict to diffuse aggressive behaviors and to regain a peaceful [[social environment]].<ref name=":7">{{Cite journal|last1=Cools|first1=Annemieke K.A.|last2=Van Hout|first2=Alain J.-M.|last3=Nelissen|first3=Mark H. J.|date=2008-01-08|title=Canine Reconciliation and Third-Party-Initiated Postconflict Affiliation: Do Peacemaking Social Mechanisms in Dogs Rival Those of Higher Primates?: Canine Reconciliation and Third-Party-Initiated Postconflict Affiliation|url=https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1439-0310.2007.01443.x|journal=Ethology|language=en|volume=114|issue=1|pages=53–63|doi=10.1111/j.1439-0310.2007.01443.x|url-access=subscription}}</ref> Dogs have evolved peacemaking social mechanisms to alleviate, prevent, or resolve conflicts.<ref name=":7" /> Some of these behavior mechanisms are calming signals.<ref name=":2" /><ref name=":3" /><ref name=":1" /><ref name=":7" /> Social groups of dogs display two types of post-conflict calming signal behavior patterns: the two opponents of the conflict display the calming signals (reconciliation), or between a third-party member of the social group and one opponent (third-party initiated post-conflict affiliation).<ref name=":7" />


6. Freezing
Familiarity and distance between two individuals affects the frequency of use of calming signals and the types of calming signals used.<ref name=":1" /><ref name=":5" /> Calming signals are used between dogs to prevent the escalation of an agonistic encounter.<ref name=":4" /><ref name=":5" /> Intraspecific calming signals can be voluntary, such as licking the lips, or involuntary, such as the release of odors from glands during high-stress interactions.<ref name=":02" /> In both cases, the recipient receives the signal, understands its meaning, and acts on this information, often taking action to mitigate the stressful environment by changing their body language or demeanor.<ref name=":1" />
"Freezing" is when the dog stops abruptly and remains completely still, often looking out of the corner of his eye. This behavior is believed to have something to do with hunting behavior - when the prey is running, the dog attacks. Once the prey stops, the dog will stop too. We can often see this when dogs are chasing cats. This behavior, however, is used in several different situations. When you get angry and aggressive and appear threatening, the dog will often freeze and not move in order to help you calm down. Other times the dog may walk slowly, freeze, and then move slowly again. Very often a dog will stop and remain still when someone is approaching. Should your dog be in a conflict situation with a human or dog and is unable to escape, freezing may be one attempt to calm the other dog or person.


7. Sitting down
<Gallery class="center centered" widths="180" heights="140" perrow="4">
To sit down, or an even stronger signal, to sit down with the back turned towards someone - for instance the owner - has a very calming effect. It’s often seen when one dog wants to calm another dog who is approaching too quickly. Dogs may sit down with their backs turned against the owner when he or she sounds too strict or angry.
Dogs meeting (cropped).jpg|Brown dog: Softening eyes, ears back, reducing body size, lifting a paw.  
Doberdore and White Shepherd (cropped).jpg|Brown dog: <br>Ears back, sitting.
Dogs social behaviour 1.jpg|Golden dog: <br>freezing, showing his side.
Calming signals of dogs.jpg|Dominant male shows peaceful intentions by licking his nose.  
</Gallery>


8. Walking in a curve
Calming signals are not displayed in intraspecific interactions when the level of aggression or [[threat]] exceeds the aggression threshold of the sender.<ref name=":5" /> In these cases, dogs are more likely to rely on submissive behaviors than calming signals.<ref name=":4" /><ref name=":5" /> Calming signals are only useful to a dog when there is a great enough probability that the direction of the encounter can be changed to de-escalate aggression.<ref name=":5" />
This signal is frequently used as a calming signal, and it is the main reason why dogs may react so strongly towards meeting dogs when they are forced to approach head on. Their instincts tell them that it’s wrong to approach someone like that. Forcing dogs to approach each other head on can cause them to feel anxious and defensive, and can eventually result in aggressive behavior like barking and lunging at other dogs. Dogs, when given a chance, will walk in curves around each other. This is what they do when they meet off leash and are free to do things their own way.  


9. Other calming signals
== References ==
• Yawning (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yawn)
{{Reflist}}
• "Smiling", either by pulling the corners of the mouth up and back, or by showing the teeth as in a grin.
• Wagging the tail - should a dog show signs of anxiety, calming or anything that clearly has little to do with happiness, a wagging tail isn’t always an expression of happiness.
• Urinating, marking
• Making the face round and smooth with the ears close to the head in order to act like a puppy. (No one will harm a puppy, is what the dog believes)
• Some dogs act like puppies, jumping around and act silly, throwing sticks around, etc. if they discover a fearful dog nearby. This is intended to have a calming effect.


References
[[Category:Dog training]]
http://en.turid-rugaas.no/calming-signals---the-art-of-survival.html
[[Category:Ethology]]
http://www.amazon.com/On-Talking-Terms-With-Dogs/dp/1929242360
https://www.dogwise.com/ItemDetails.cfm?ID=dtb527
http://www.pet360.com/dog/behavior-and-training/calming-signals-in-dogs-and-how-we-can-use-them/_RUS-yjVgkmZlZZv0o9Jug?intcid=AR17
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lj7BWxC6iVs
http://chicagopetsitters.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/CalmingSignalsPoster.jpg