Jump to content

Open design dish washer: Difference between revisions

From IdeaWazaWiki
Update and expand: bulk auto-dosing design, parts, sources (keeps original text)
Lumo (talk | contribs)
Explain how open designs support manufacturing and repair businesses
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
An '''open design dishwasher''' is a machine whose plans, parts list, and control software are published so other people can study, build, repair, and improve it. The design proposed here uses a refillable bottle to dispense dishwasher detergent automatically. The bottle docks with the machine during a wash cycle and can be removed to dispense detergent by hand.
Dishwashing is a recurring household chore. A durable washer with replaceable parts could reduce the work involved and help households use less water, energy, and detergent. These goals connect the project to [[Solving problems in living|solving problems in living]] and to the idea of a [[Post-scarcity economy|post-scarcity economy]].
__NOTOC__
__NOTOC__
dishes need to be washed.
put them in the dish-washer... turn it on... add soap...
what about automatic soap dispensing?
what if.. bottle... plugged in... or could be used freely?
An open design dishwasher, as discussed on this wiki, is a machine whose plans, parts list, and control software are published so that other people can study, repair, copy, and improve it. The seed idea above is simple: wash the dishes in a machine, and dose soap automatically from a bottle that can stay plugged into the machine or be taken off and used freely. That idea serves abundance and a [[Post-scarcity economy|post-scarcity economy]], because a repairable washer that uses less water, less energy, and less wasted detergent turns a daily chore into a smaller claim on scarce resources. It also serves [[Solving problems in living|solving problems in living]]: dishwashing is unpaid work that many households repeat every day, and a machine that doses cleanly, lasts, and can be fixed returns some of that time. In a modest sense this is also futurism: documented, standard machines rather than disposable boxes that only their makers can refill or repair.
== How a dishwasher works: subsystems and parts ==
== How a dishwasher works: subsystems and parts ==
A dishwasher fills, heats, sprays, and drains a modest amount of water, then dries the dishes. The main subsystems are:<ref name="kitchenaid">KitchenAid. "[https://www.kitchenaid.com/pinch-of-help/major-appliances/how-does-a-dishwasher-work.html How does a dishwasher work?]"</ref><!-- Last checked: November 2026 -->
A dishwasher fills, heats, sprays, and drains a modest amount of water, then dries the dishes. The main subsystems are:<ref name="kitchenaid">KitchenAid. "[https://www.kitchenaid.com/pinch-of-help/major-appliances/how-does-a-dishwasher-work.html How does a dishwasher work?]"</ref><!-- Last checked: November 2026 -->
Line 33: Line 23:
Beko's AutoDose machines dispense detergent and rinse aid from reservoirs the user fills, lasting up to a month.<ref name="beko">Beko. "[https://www.beko.co.uk/lifestyle/what-are-autodose-dishwashers What is a AutoDose Connected Dishwasher?]"</ref> A related manual, DIN59420, reports typical dose guidance of 20, 25, and 30 milliliters for light, moderate, and heavy soiling, and warns that very thick gels may not be suitable for automatic dosing.<ref name="bekomanual">Beko. "[https://storage.beko.co.uk/bekoupload/manuals/DIN59420.pdf DIN59420 Dishwasher User's Manual]."</ref> A Bosch manual for a conventional dispenser says that 20 ml to 25 ml is sufficient for normal soiling.<ref name="bosch">Bosch. "[https://media3.bosch-home.com/Documents/9001861459_C.pdf Information for Use, SMS6ZCI85M]," section 12.4.</ref> Bosch i-DOS is for washing machines, not dishwashers, and typical Bosch dishwashers use DosageAssist, a tablet tray. A refillable tank is better than a sealed disk for user choice, but it is still not a standard bottle that can be unplugged and used at the sink. An [[Open design|open design]] would keep automatic dosing and leave the bottle, the pump, and the detergent choice in the user's hands.
Beko's AutoDose machines dispense detergent and rinse aid from reservoirs the user fills, lasting up to a month.<ref name="beko">Beko. "[https://www.beko.co.uk/lifestyle/what-are-autodose-dishwashers What is a AutoDose Connected Dishwasher?]"</ref> A related manual, DIN59420, reports typical dose guidance of 20, 25, and 30 milliliters for light, moderate, and heavy soiling, and warns that very thick gels may not be suitable for automatic dosing.<ref name="bekomanual">Beko. "[https://storage.beko.co.uk/bekoupload/manuals/DIN59420.pdf DIN59420 Dishwasher User's Manual]."</ref> A Bosch manual for a conventional dispenser says that 20 ml to 25 ml is sufficient for normal soiling.<ref name="bosch">Bosch. "[https://media3.bosch-home.com/Documents/9001861459_C.pdf Information for Use, SMS6ZCI85M]," section 12.4.</ref> Bosch i-DOS is for washing machines, not dishwashers, and typical Bosch dishwashers use DosageAssist, a tablet tray. A refillable tank is better than a sealed disk for user choice, but it is still not a standard bottle that can be unplugged and used at the sink. An [[Open design|open design]] would keep automatic dosing and leave the bottle, the pump, and the detergent choice in the user's hands.


== Design sketch: automatic dispensing from a bottle that can also be used freely ==
== Design sketch for a removable detergent bottle ==
The sketch below answers the brainstorm questions: automatic soap dispensing, and a bottle that can stay plugged in or be used freely.
The design uses separate bottles for detergent and rinse aid. A conventional door cup provides a backup for manual dosing.


* '''A standard bottle, not a special cartridge.''' Detergent and rinse aid each sit in an ordinary, closable bottle. A published adapter matches a documented, common bottle thread. The same bottle can stay docked (plugged in) or be unscrewed and used at a sink (used freely).
* '''A standard refillable bottle.''' A published adapter fits a common bottle thread. Someone using the dishwasher can disconnect the bottle, close it with its own cap, and use it at the sink.
* '''A peristaltic pump for each chemistry.''' A small peristaltic pump draws liquid from the bottle and injects a measured dose at the right step of the program.
* '''A peristaltic pump for each chemistry.''' A small peristaltic pump draws liquid from the bottle and injects a measured dose at the right step of the program.
* '''Dose by program, soil, and water hardness.''' A base dose follows the selected program. A turbidity sensor or a hardness setting can raise or lower that dose.
* '''Dose by program, soil, and water hardness.''' A base dose follows the selected program. A turbidity sensor or a hardness setting can raise or lower that dose.
Line 46: Line 36:
== Repairability, standard parts, and open hardware ==
== Repairability, standard parts, and open hardware ==
Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022 requires, from 1 March 2021, that listed parts such as motors, pumps, heaters, valves, filters, circuit boards, sensors, and software be available to professional repairers for at least seven years after the last unit of a model is placed on the market. Door hinges and seals, spray arms, drain filters, and racks must be available to professional repairers and end-users for at least ten years, replaceable with commonly available tools, and delivered within 15 working days.<ref name="eu2022">European Union. "[https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32019R2022 Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022] of 1 October 2019 laying down ecodesign requirements for household dishwashers."</ref> An open design should treat that legal floor as a starting point and keep the parts list public, in the same [[Right to repair as a path to durable abundance|right to repair]] sense used on this wiki. An open controller on a microcontroller can sequence the valves, heater, and pumps, with published schematics and firmware. [[3D printing|3D-printed]] spray arms or racks are a reasonable experiment, but hot, alkaline water is hard on many common print plastics. A complete, published open hardware dishwasher was not found. Open Source Ecology has a short "Iconic Dishwasher" page, which is not a complete, reusable design.<ref name="ose">Open Source Ecology. "[https://wiki.opensourceecology.org/wiki/Iconic_Dishwasher Iconic Dishwasher]."</ref>
Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022 requires, from 1 March 2021, that listed parts such as motors, pumps, heaters, valves, filters, circuit boards, sensors, and software be available to professional repairers for at least seven years after the last unit of a model is placed on the market. Door hinges and seals, spray arms, drain filters, and racks must be available to professional repairers and end-users for at least ten years, replaceable with commonly available tools, and delivered within 15 working days.<ref name="eu2022">European Union. "[https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32019R2022 Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022] of 1 October 2019 laying down ecodesign requirements for household dishwashers."</ref> An open design should treat that legal floor as a starting point and keep the parts list public, in the same [[Right to repair as a path to durable abundance|right to repair]] sense used on this wiki. An open controller on a microcontroller can sequence the valves, heater, and pumps, with published schematics and firmware. [[3D printing|3D-printed]] spray arms or racks are a reasonable experiment, but hot, alkaline water is hard on many common print plastics. A complete, published open hardware dishwasher was not found. Open Source Ecology has a short "Iconic Dishwasher" page, which is not a complete, reusable design.<ref name="ose">Open Source Ecology. "[https://wiki.opensourceecology.org/wiki/Iconic_Dishwasher Iconic Dishwasher]."</ref>
== How shared designs could support manufacturing and repair businesses ==
An open design becomes easier to reuse when people can download the drawings in an editable format, check which revision they have, and see which parts are interchangeable. For the detergent dock, a release could include the bottle thread, seal dimensions and tolerances, the parts list, and the results of leak and dosing tests. A license that permits modification, manufacture, and sale would let other teams improve the design and sell compatible parts.<ref>Open Source Hardware Association. [https://oshwa.org/resources/open-source-hardware-definition/ Open Source Hardware Definition].</ref>
If the original pump goes out of stock, an [[Artificial intelligence|AI]] agent could compare supplier catalogs against the documented flow rate, voltage, and fittings, then flag candidates for bench testing. A factory could use the same dimensions and tolerances to make and inspect replacement adapters. This is one way shared specifications could reduce duplicated work across design, production, and repair.<ref>National Institute of Standards and Technology. [https://www.nist.gov/programs-projects/extended-digital-thread Extended Digital Thread].</ref>
A replacement bottle and seal kit would be a smaller first product than a complete dishwasher. A repair shop could ask which parts customers actually need, get a quote for a small batch, and test it against the specified dock before offering it for sale. The cost per sellable kit would include parts, assembly, packaging, and an allowance for returns and support. A shop could also earn revenue from diagnosis and installation.
The household benefit can be measured in repair cost, time out of service, and total cost per wash over the life of the machine. A widely available seal can keep a washer working for years. If many products become easier to make and repair, those savings can accumulate. How widely households benefit also depends on the supply of materials and energy, factory capacity, and access to affordable parts and repairs.


== An illustrative calculation ==
== An illustrative calculation ==

Latest revision as of 22:24, 22 November 2026

An open design dishwasher is a machine whose plans, parts list, and control software are published so other people can study, build, repair, and improve it. The design proposed here uses a refillable bottle to dispense dishwasher detergent automatically. The bottle docks with the machine during a wash cycle and can be removed to dispense detergent by hand.

Dishwashing is a recurring household chore. A durable washer with replaceable parts could reduce the work involved and help households use less water, energy, and detergent. These goals connect the project to solving problems in living and to the idea of a post-scarcity economy.

How a dishwasher works: subsystems and parts

A dishwasher fills, heats, sprays, and drains a modest amount of water, then dries the dishes. The main subsystems are:[1]

  • Inlet valve and fill control. A valve lets water into the tub. A float or level sensor stops the fill.
  • Heater. An element in the sump, or a through-flow heater, raises the water temperature.
  • Circulation pump and spray arms. A pump pushes water through rotating arms under the racks, and sometimes a third arm above.
  • Filter, sump, and drain pump. Food residue collects in a filter. After a wash or rinse step, a pump sends dirty water out through a hose.
  • Sensors and controller. Temperature sensors and a door interlock are typical. Many machines also use a turbidity sensor. Bosch describes its AquaSensor as using light beams to judge how dirty the load is and to set the water used.[2]
  • Detergent and rinse-aid path. A conventional machine uses a cup in the door. In the open design below, a pump doses from a refillable bottle, and the cup is kept as a fallback.

Water, energy, and unpaid labor

In a University of Bonn study published in 2004, Rainer Stamminger reported that 113 people from seven regions of Europe washed the same 12 place-setting load by hand. Water use ranged from 14 to 447 liters, with a mean of 103 liters. The energy figure, counted only as the heat content of the water, had a mean of 2.5 kilowatt-hours. Two dishwashers then on the market used 15 to 22 liters of water and 1.0 to 2.0 kilowatt-hours of electricity for the same load.[3] Under the ENERGY STAR Version 7 criteria that took effect on 19 July 2023, a standard residential dishwasher may use at most 3.2 US gallons of water per cycle and 240 kilowatt-hours of energy per year, measured with 215 cycles per year.[4] A well-designed open machine should treat those limits as a design target.

Automatic dosing already exists, with a lock-in risk

Commercial kitchens already pump detergent and rinse aid from bulk containers. Brightwell Dispensers describes its Quantura 200 as a two-product peristaltic pump system that delivers rinse aid and detergent to commercial dishwashing machines from chemical containers, with the peristaltic tube treated as a wear part.[5]

Some home machines now dose automatically, but several well-known systems use a proprietary cartridge. Miele's AutoDos system, introduced on the G 7000 range in 2018, uses a PowerDisk cartridge in the inner door. The disk turns during the program and releases Miele's own powder granulate. In the Normal 60 degrees C program, one disk lasts 20 cycles, and the same machines still have a conventional dispenser for tablets or powder.[6] The automatic path is tied to a special cartridge and granulate: if that format is withdrawn, it is what fails.

Beko's AutoDose machines dispense detergent and rinse aid from reservoirs the user fills, lasting up to a month.[7] A related manual, DIN59420, reports typical dose guidance of 20, 25, and 30 milliliters for light, moderate, and heavy soiling, and warns that very thick gels may not be suitable for automatic dosing.[8] A Bosch manual for a conventional dispenser says that 20 ml to 25 ml is sufficient for normal soiling.[9] Bosch i-DOS is for washing machines, not dishwashers, and typical Bosch dishwashers use DosageAssist, a tablet tray. A refillable tank is better than a sealed disk for user choice, but it is still not a standard bottle that can be unplugged and used at the sink. An open design would keep automatic dosing and leave the bottle, the pump, and the detergent choice in the user's hands.

Design sketch for a removable detergent bottle

The design uses separate bottles for detergent and rinse aid. A conventional door cup provides a backup for manual dosing.

  • A standard refillable bottle. A published adapter fits a common bottle thread. Someone using the dishwasher can disconnect the bottle, close it with its own cap, and use it at the sink.
  • A peristaltic pump for each chemistry. A small peristaltic pump draws liquid from the bottle and injects a measured dose at the right step of the program.
  • Dose by program, soil, and water hardness. A base dose follows the selected program. A turbidity sensor or a hardness setting can raise or lower that dose.
  • Open detergent choice, with clear limits. Any dishwasher-safe liquid or gel can go in the bottle, subject to viscosity notes. Hand dishwashing liquid is not a substitute, because it foams too much. Powder and tablets remain available through a conventional door cup.
  • Level sensing and a secured dock. A level sensor or sight window should warn before the bottle runs dry. The dock should latch closed, catch drips, and be child-resistant.

Gel can clog or thicken in the tube, air leaks can cause under-dosing, pump tubing wears, and a poorly seated adapter can leak. Very thick gels and powder belong in the fallback cup unless a different feeder is designed. Publish the plans, schematics, firmware, and a bill of materials. Prefer standard, replaceable pumps, valves, and fittings. Make wear parts replaceable with commonly available tools, and build in overflow protection, a door interlock, and a child-resistant compartment.

Repairability, standard parts, and open hardware

Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022 requires, from 1 March 2021, that listed parts such as motors, pumps, heaters, valves, filters, circuit boards, sensors, and software be available to professional repairers for at least seven years after the last unit of a model is placed on the market. Door hinges and seals, spray arms, drain filters, and racks must be available to professional repairers and end-users for at least ten years, replaceable with commonly available tools, and delivered within 15 working days.[10] An open design should treat that legal floor as a starting point and keep the parts list public, in the same right to repair sense used on this wiki. An open controller on a microcontroller can sequence the valves, heater, and pumps, with published schematics and firmware. 3D-printed spray arms or racks are a reasonable experiment, but hot, alkaline water is hard on many common print plastics. A complete, published open hardware dishwasher was not found. Open Source Ecology has a short "Iconic Dishwasher" page, which is not a complete, reusable design.[11]

How shared designs could support manufacturing and repair businesses

An open design becomes easier to reuse when people can download the drawings in an editable format, check which revision they have, and see which parts are interchangeable. For the detergent dock, a release could include the bottle thread, seal dimensions and tolerances, the parts list, and the results of leak and dosing tests. A license that permits modification, manufacture, and sale would let other teams improve the design and sell compatible parts.[12]

If the original pump goes out of stock, an AI agent could compare supplier catalogs against the documented flow rate, voltage, and fittings, then flag candidates for bench testing. A factory could use the same dimensions and tolerances to make and inspect replacement adapters. This is one way shared specifications could reduce duplicated work across design, production, and repair.[13]

A replacement bottle and seal kit would be a smaller first product than a complete dishwasher. A repair shop could ask which parts customers actually need, get a quote for a small batch, and test it against the specified dock before offering it for sale. The cost per sellable kit would include parts, assembly, packaging, and an allowance for returns and support. A shop could also earn revenue from diagnosis and installation.

The household benefit can be measured in repair cost, time out of service, and total cost per wash over the life of the machine. A widely available seal can keep a washer working for years. If many products become easier to make and repair, those savings can accumulate. How widely households benefit also depends on the supply of materials and energy, factory capacity, and access to affordable parts and repairs.

An illustrative calculation

The figures below are illustrative, not a forecast for a particular household.

A. Bottle refill, assumed 25 ml per cycle
   (Bosch: 20 ml to 25 ml for normal soiling;
    Beko: 25 ml for moderately soiled dishes)
   1 liter bottle = 40 doses
   At 215 cycles/year (ENERGY STAR assumption): about 68 days

B. Same 12 place-setting load (Stamminger, 2004)
   Hand wash, 113 people: mean 103 L (range 14 to 447 L)
   Two then-market dishwashers: 15 to 22 L
   If repeated 215 times/year (illustrative):
     Hand mean: 22,145 L/year
     Machine at 22 L: 4,730 L/year

C. ENERGY STAR limit, standard residential dishwasher
   At most 3.2 US gallons/cycle and 240 kWh/year
   At 215 cycles/year: at most 688 US gallons/year (about 2,600 L)

A careful basin wash can come out far below the 103 liter mean, and a running tap can come out far above it.

  • Compare a proprietary dosing cartridge with a refillable bottle that uses a published thread adapter. Who captures the ongoing revenue, and what happens when the cartridge is withdrawn from sale?
  • Using the Bonn study figures and the ENERGY STAR limits, under what habits would hand washing use less water than a machine?
  • Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022 requires some parts for seven years and others for ten. Is that long enough, and what should an open design promise beyond the legal minimum?
  • If 3D-printed spray arms are part of the design, how would you test them for heat, alkali, and fatigue before calling them a spare part?
  • Should an open dishwasher dose detergent by water hardness, by turbidity, by selected program, or by a combination?

See also

References

  1. ↑ KitchenAid. "How does a dishwasher work?"
  2. ↑ Bosch Home Appliances. "AquaSensor."
  3. ↑ Stamminger, Rainer. "Geschirrspulen in Europa." ernaehrung im fokus 4 (June 2004): 154-158. PDF: https://www.energieverbraucher.de/files/0/1/0/14384.pdf
  4. ↑ ENERGY STAR. "Dishwashers Key Product Criteria."
  5. ↑ Brightwell Dispensers Ltd. "Instruction Manual, Quantura 200 and Quantura 300," revision 2.0.
  6. ↑ Miele. "World premiere at IFA: The G 7000 autonomous dishwasher from Miele." Press release no. 076/2018, 29 August 2018.
  7. ↑ Beko. "What is a AutoDose Connected Dishwasher?"
  8. ↑ Beko. "DIN59420 Dishwasher User's Manual."
  9. ↑ Bosch. "Information for Use, SMS6ZCI85M," section 12.4.
  10. ↑ European Union. "Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2022 of 1 October 2019 laying down ecodesign requirements for household dishwashers."
  11. ↑ Open Source Ecology. "Iconic Dishwasher."
  12. ↑ Open Source Hardware Association. Open Source Hardware Definition.
  13. ↑ National Institute of Standards and Technology. Extended Digital Thread.