Peer to peer wiki system: Difference between revisions

→P2Pedia: fixed spelling error
wikademia>Wikademia
 
(25 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{ntnes}}
This page is meant to be as a first draft of a system, which provides articles (from Wikipedia) in peer-to-peer networks.
This page is meant to be as a first draft of a system, which provides articles (from Wikipedia) in peer-to-peer networks.


Line 20: Line 21:


- situation:
- situation:
Existing p2p-networks identifier a file by a content based hash-code and most of them are searchable through filename (including extension), but not by content. Some software([http://www.shareaza.com Shareaza], [http://mark0.net/soft-trid-e.html Trid],...?) is able to identify a binary format and/or extract file-embedded metadata (ID3 tags, movie lenght, etc.) index the metadata and search for the metadata.
Existing p2p-networks identifier a file by a content based hash-code and most of them are searchable through filename (including extension), but not by content. Some software ([http://shareaza.sourceforge.net/ Shareaza], [http://mark0.net/soft-trid-e.html Trid],...?) is able to identify a binary format and/or extract file-embedded metadata (ID3 tags, movie length, etc.) index the metadata and search for the metadata.


- needs:
===Needs===
- wikiidentifier(en, de, meta)
* wikiidentifier (en, de, meta)
- title
* title
- version/date
* version/date
- keywords, categories
* keywords, categories


== Information used to identifier an actual article ==
== Information used to identifier an actual article ==
Line 37: Line 38:


== Links ==
== Links ==
 
* maybe have to be modified
- maybe have to be modified
* have to contain identifier for articles(see above)
- have to contain identifier for articles(see above)
* there is the need to reserve a keyspace for any and all articles.
 
** One article-->one keyspace
- there is the need to reserve a keyspace for any and all articles.
** One article revision --> one key (sequential?) in the keyspace
    One article-->one keyspace
    One article revision --> one key (sequential?) in the keyspace


== Existing P2P Wiki Projects ==
== Existing P2P Wiki Projects ==


[http://oc-co.org/ Bouillon] purports to be a P2P-oriented Wiki, implemented over [[w:Jabber]].  There's no single global version of any page—each user's agent retrieves and assembles pieces of a page from user's friends, friends-of-a-friend, etc.
[http://oc-co.org/ Bouillon] purports to be a P2P-oriented Wiki, implemented over [[Wikipedia:Jabber|Jabber]] (<small>wp</small>).  There's no single global version of any page&mdash;each user's agent retrieves and assembles pieces of a page from user's friends, friends-of-a-friend, etc.
 
== Networks ==
 
=== [[en:eDonkey|eDonkey]] [[en:eMule|eMule]]===
PROs
* Bigger network population
* Long availability
 
CONs
* It can not host many files using the server infrastructure
* It could require a dedicated server to index the articles available
 
 
=== [Kademlia]]===
 
* DHT
 
=== [[en:Freenet|Freenet]] ===
 
- slow (should be somewhat faster in 0.7)
 
- anonymous
 
- hostile environment capable (with darknet)
 
- naming is easy - SSK@pubkey,cryptokey,extra/wikipedia/edition#/articleName-language
 
- linking is likewise easy (relative links within the SSK)
 
- good match to web-style stuff like this
 
- 0.8 may have tor-style internal servers which could be used for editing
 
=== [[en:Gnutella2|Gnutella 2]] ===
PROs
* fast
* good keyword searches
* good metadata searches
* list of available articles is updated immediatly
 
CONs
* QHT is limited to 1 million entries (20 bits);
* QHT bigger than 24 bits are improbable, for now;
* this probably needs a dedicated QHT (1 entry per article file) as QHT need to be filled no more than 5-10%
 
=== [[en:BitTorrent|BitTorrent]] ===
 
PROs
* fast for big files
 
CONs
* probably not so fast for small ones e.g. articles?
* what exactly is distributed-tracker bittorrent capable of?
** DHT need to insert in the network one key/article at time, so inserting too many articles is problematic for a fleeting client


== Distributed revision control systems ==
== Distributed revision control systems ==
I think p2pedia should work as p2p distributed revision control systems.
I think p2pedia should work as p2p distributed revision control systems.


[http://www.gnu.org/software/gnu-arch/ Gnu Arch]
* [http://www.gnu.org/software/gnu-arch/ Gnu Arch]
 
* [http://www.nongnu.org/arx/ Arx]
[http://www.nongnu.org/arx/ Arx]
* [http://abridgegame.org/darcs/ Darcs]
 
* [http://git.or.cz/ Git]
[http://abridgegame.org/darcs/ Darcs]
* [http://www.venge.net/monotone/  Monotone]
 
* [http://www.selenic.com/mercurial/wiki/index.cgi/Mercurial Mercurial]
[http://git.or.cz/ Git]


[http://www.venge.net/monotone/  Monotone]
==See also==
* [[Wikademia:Decentralizing Wikipedia and its sister projects]]
* [[TomLord on distributed wikis]]
* [[Versioning and distributed data]]


[http://www.selenic.com/mercurial/wiki/index.cgi/Mercurial Mercurial]
==External links==
* ''[http://www.gossamer-threads.com/lists/wiki/foundation/121420 Possibility of a git-based fully distributed Wikipedia]
* [http://wiki.laptop.org/go/MikMik OLPC:MikMik] - A distributed wiki editor
* March 2007 ''[http://www.globule.org/publi/DWECWH_webist2007.html A Decentralized Wiki Engine for Collaborative Wikipedia Hosting]


[[Category:Proposals]]
[[Category:Proposals]]