Introduction to Non-Genetic Darwinism/Complexity Theory: Difference between revisions
wikademia>Graeme E. Smith m editing for complexity |
wikademia>Wikademia No edit summary |
||
| (13 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[File: GSI Mortarboard.jpg|right|[[Wikipedia:Picture]]]] | |||
{{experimental}} | |||
{{lesson}} | |||
= Complexity Theory = | = Complexity Theory = | ||
Although Complexity Theory is usually an advanced topic in computer science, recently it has become important to understand just why things are organized the way they are. As such it impinges on Physics, and may change the way we look at self-organization. | |||
{{?}} | |||
==AIMS== | |||
# To introduce the idea of complexity as a way of storing energy | |||
# To introduce A New Kind of Science, and the Class 4 Automata | |||
# To introduce the idea of emergence as precipitation of order | |||
# To link emergence with the Energy/Entropy Balance | |||
# To show how Darwinism is just a special case of emergence | |||
# To promote the idea that other forms of emergence often echo Darwinism | |||
=== The Energy Theory of Complexity === | |||
Einstein stated the basic law of conversion of mass into energy as E=MC<sup>2</sup> What this means is that matter is a special form of energy. The Energy theory of Complexity takes things one step further, and says that all forms of complexity are really just forms of energy that are protected from entropic reduction by the high dimensionality of space. | |||
When energy is high enough, it is chaotic, but as Entropy increases, energy is drained away and some of it gets caught in the dimensional structure of space precipitating out into forms of order. | |||
As energy continues to drain, the energy needed to maintain a particular structure of space, sometimes gets drained away, and releases the energy that was stored in that spatial structure back into the environment increasing the local energy levels temporarily, and reducing the order to smaller more stable energy/spatial structures. Thus the same level of Entropy at different levels of energy can either form new order, or reduce order to simpler structures. | |||
When energy is increased in a system, first the energy causes larger structures to form, and then it makes the space more chaotic as the energy/entropy balance increases. If energy keeps increasing, Entropy begins increasing to compensate, and order begins to precipitate out again. | |||
When energy is decreased in a system, first the energy flows away from spatial structures, weakening them until they break apart into smaller spatial structures, releasing energy, which if released in enough quantity makes the system more chaotic, until entropy again begins to precipitate out order at a smaller spatial structure. | |||
===''A New Kind of Science''=== | ===''A New Kind of Science''=== | ||
| Line 7: | Line 31: | ||
====Cellular Automata and the Discovery of Oscillating Order/Chaos systems==== | ====Cellular Automata and the Discovery of Oscillating Order/Chaos systems==== | ||
The idea that Order and Chaos alternate in an incremental system, flies in the face of our understanding of Entropy as a breaking down of complexity, | The idea that Order and Chaos alternate in an incremental system, flies in the face of our understanding of Entropy as a breaking down of complexity, and fits our energy/entropy balance model. However, to counter our reluctance to accept this concept, we must notice that the order of our universe is strangely inconsistent, and that the second law on which we base our understanding of Entropy, is limited to systems that start and stop at an equilibrium state, and doesn't adequately describe the state where energy is being increased or decreased within the system. If we can accept that assertion, then we need to look no closer than to our periodic table to see that order is not always consistent. | ||
You would think that the atomic weight of an atom would go up in regular increments, but as you get further and further into the periodic table, the increments get further and further apart, and the order seems to break down into large gaps where elements that were once predicted, were not found. Some of this can be explained by radioactive decay but in some cases the gaps are there simply because the elements were never created. Perhaps order is not as simple as we would like to think. | You would think that the atomic weight of an atom would go up in regular increments, but as you get further and further into the periodic table, the increments get further and further apart, and the order seems to break down into large gaps where elements that were once predicted, were not found. Some of this can be explained by radioactive decay but in some cases the gaps are there simply because the elements were never created. Perhaps order is not as simple as we would like to think. | ||
| Line 25: | Line 49: | ||
====The Power Curve and the precipitation of order==== | ====The Power Curve and the precipitation of order==== | ||
If this theory is correct, then we would expect the power curve to have longer and longer plateaus as the amount of entropy increases, and it takes more and more energy to create the dynamism that causes the next band of chaos to form. Further we would expect that our universe would be made up of elements that had molecular weights that fell further and further apart on the periodic table, and that we would have aggregation of galaxies that is more prevalent than was originally thought. | If this theory is correct, then we would expect the power curve to have longer and longer plateaus as the amount of entropy increases, and it takes more and more energy to create the dynamism that causes the next band of chaos to form. Further we would expect that our universe would be made up of elements that had atomic or molecular weights that fell further and further apart on the periodic table, and that we would have aggregation of galaxies that is more prevalent than was originally thought. | ||
There is one major problem with this theory, and that is that it flies in the face of the first law of thermodynamics that energy can be neither created nor destroyed. If energy can't be created, where is all this energy needed to create the new plateaus on the power curve coming from? | There is one major problem with this theory, and that is that it flies in the face of the first law of thermodynamics that energy can be neither created nor destroyed. If energy can't be created, where is all this energy needed to create the new plateaus on the power curve coming from? | ||
| Line 31: | Line 55: | ||
====Conservation of Order in an Incremental System==== | ====Conservation of Order in an Incremental System==== | ||
If | If the energy theory of complexity is correct, then in an incremental system, smaller structures will form first, and energy will combine those structures until it gets high enough to become chaotic. After a while Entropy will begin to catch up with energy again, and larger structures will form. The Energy/Entropy balance will result in a power curve where precipitation of order happens at gradually increasing energy levels, and as a result the complexity of the elements the system is made up of will increase, but earlier forms of complexity will be conserved as long as they did not break down into smaller components | ||
====Conservation of Order in a Decrementing System==== | ====Conservation of Order in a Decrementing System==== | ||
| Line 39: | Line 63: | ||
==Evolution, as the emergence of order in an incremental Biological system== | ==Evolution, as the emergence of order in an incremental Biological system== | ||
I once joked, that I exist simply as an opportunity to increase the partial pressure of long-chain molecules in the Universe. If we see complexity as simply a method of cooling the Universe by sequestering energy in | I once joked, that I exist simply as an opportunity to increase the partial pressure of long-chain molecules in the Universe. If we see complexity as simply a method of cooling the Universe by sequestering energy in complex arrangements, then, perhaps a more radical interpretation is possible, Life exists, simply to sequester more energy, than is possible with normal entropic mechanisms. It is perhaps less stable than the combination of two chemicals into a molecule, but more stable than fire. If this is true, then at the heart of Evolution we might find the same mechanism as was first used to create the elements, and then the molecules on which biology is based. | ||
====Chemistry, how Entropy actually helps combine chemicals==== | ====Chemistry, how Entropy actually helps combine chemicals==== | ||
| Line 45: | Line 69: | ||
It takes time for an Atomic Bond to form. When two chemicals are first mixed together, it takes longer for them to combine, than once they have started combining. Energetic systems are more uncertain at the Atomic level, than cooler systems, and the result is that the energy of the atoms banging off each other may be too great for Atomic Bonds to form. This means that while it is good to have a hot temperature when you are breaking atomic bonds and separating reagents, it is good to have a cooler temperature when you are combining them, or letting them precipitate out as crystals. | It takes time for an Atomic Bond to form. When two chemicals are first mixed together, it takes longer for them to combine, than once they have started combining. Energetic systems are more uncertain at the Atomic level, than cooler systems, and the result is that the energy of the atoms banging off each other may be too great for Atomic Bonds to form. This means that while it is good to have a hot temperature when you are breaking atomic bonds and separating reagents, it is good to have a cooler temperature when you are combining them, or letting them precipitate out as crystals. | ||
No two chemicals will combine, if the result is a higher Energy/Entropy balance. And if the Energy/Entropy balance is too low, the result will either freeze or break into smaller parts. but when the Energy/Entropy balance is correct, chemicals combine better, than at other times. As a result it is often necessary to combine chemicals at a particular temperature for best combination. | No two chemicals will combine, if the result is a higher Energy/Entropy balance. Unless the ambient temperature of the solution is high enough to contribute the extra energy. And if the Energy/Entropy balance is too low, the result will either freeze or break into smaller parts. but when the Energy/Entropy balance is correct, chemicals combine better, than at other times. As a result it is often necessary to combine chemicals at a particular temperature for best combination. | ||
====The Energy Death of the Universe is Running Late==== | ====The Energy Death of the Universe is Running Late==== | ||
| Line 53: | Line 77: | ||
===Darwinism as a description of the principle by which order emerges and is conserved=== | ===Darwinism as a description of the principle by which order emerges and is conserved=== | ||
It is my contention, that Darwinism is more than just the definition of a biological and genetic tendency to form species, it is a biological and genetic example of a more basic principle, the principle of Self-Organization or Self-Ordering, and that that principle, can be seen wherever the Energy/Entropy balance approaches the balance range needed for the precipitation of order out of chaos. | It is my contention, that Darwinism is more than just the definition of a biological and genetic tendency to form species, it is a biological and genetic example of a more basic principle, the principle of Self-Organization or Self-Ordering, and that that principle, can be seen wherever the Energy/Entropy balance approaches the balance range needed for the precipitation of order out of chaos. Life promotes an energy/entropy balance that in turn promotes the precipitation of order out of chaos, but doesn't allow the energy levels to drop low enough to promote breaking apart into smaller structures. | ||
====Can Darwinism be applied to systems other than biological systems?==== | ====Can Darwinism be applied to systems other than biological systems?==== | ||
If this last statement is true, then Undoubtedly, YES, Darwinism can be applied to other systems that are non-biological in nature. | If this last statement is true, then Undoubtedly, YES, Darwinism can be applied to other systems that are non-biological in nature. Because it is in effect a system that promotes the precipitation of order out of chaos, and as long as there is enough energy for chaos to exist, other forms of precipitation that do not involve biology will also exist. | ||
==== The Edge of Chaos ==== | |||
Recently some scientists have noted that Evolution seems to promote the stabilization of systems that balance almost halfway between order and chaos. Called the Edge of Chaos, this theory suggests that there might be an equilibrium state that balances energy and entropy. If so we can assume that the equilibrium will respond to new energy by oscillating back and forth between chaotic and ordered states. Evolution might therefore merely be an expression of the power curve that follows from the existence of such an equilibrium state in an incremental universe. | |||
Assignment: | Assignment: | ||
*If the energy of the universe increases, does Entropy increase or decrease? and The Energy/Entropy balance? | |||
*If entropy increases in the Universe and energy is constant, does the Energy/Entropy Balance increase or decrease? | |||
*Look at the Periodic Table of Atoms if you can find one that has more than just the atomic number at the top of each element, and usually near the bottom you will find the atomic weight. Look at the intervals between weights, do they trend to take longer between each element? Are they consistent, or are there gaps? Why do you think this is? | *Look at the Periodic Table of Atoms if you can find one that has more than just the atomic number at the top of each element, and usually near the bottom you will find the atomic weight. Look at the intervals between weights, do they trend to take longer between each element? Are they consistent, or are there gaps? Why do you think this is? | ||
| Line 66: | Line 98: | ||
*Consider putting two chemicals into a solution, and getting a third chemical back out, do you think that the chemicals magically combined or did they need some self-organization to combine? Is Energy/Entropy balance, a reasonable explanation? | *Consider putting two chemicals into a solution, and getting a third chemical back out, do you think that the chemicals magically combined or did they need some self-organization to combine? Is Energy/Entropy balance, a reasonable explanation? | ||
*Now that you have heard an explanation of why non-genetic Darwinism might exist, do you think that it does exist, or not? Write an essay on this question. | *Now that you have heard an explanation of why non-genetic Darwinism might exist, in an energy complexity theory Universe do you think that it does exist, or not? Write an essay on this question. | ||
*Consider the Edge of Chaos theory, and the concept of an energy/entropy equilibrium. What would the effect of that equilibrium be on the second law of thermodynamics? Would this make life an exception to the rule, or simply an extension of the rule? | |||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
<< [[Introduction to Non-Genetic Darwinism/ | << [[Introduction to Non-Genetic Darwinism/Physics of Self-Organization|'''<big>Back</big>''']] >> << [[Introduction to Non-Genetic Darwinism/Immune System Darwinism|'''<big>Next</big>''']] >> | ||
[[Category:Non-Genetic Darwinism]] | [[Category:Non-Genetic Darwinism]] | ||