Archive:Expert commentaries: Difference between revisions

wikademia>Wikademia
m Text replace - 'Wikiversity' to 'Wikademia'
wikademia>Wikademia
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Image:WilliamBlackstone.jpg|thumb|right|250px|"The [[w:Commentaries on the Laws of England|Commentaries [on the Laws of England]]] were influential largely because they were in fact readable, and because they met a need. The work is as much an apologia for the legal system of the time as it is an explanation; even when the law was obscure, Blackstone sought to make it seem rational, just, and inevitable that things should be how they were."]]
[[Image:WilliamBlackstone.jpg|thumb|right|250px|"The [[Wikipedia:Commentaries on the Laws of England|Commentaries [on the Laws of England]]] were influential largely because they were in fact readable, and because they met a need. The work is as much an apologia for the legal system of the time as it is an explanation; even when the law was obscure, Blackstone sought to make it seem rational, just, and inevitable that things should be how they were."]]


This page describes a proposal for a new [[Help:resource types|resource type]] on Wikademia. Please join the [[Wikademia_talk:What_shall_we_do_with_Wikipedia%3F/Expert_commentaries|discussion of this proposal]].
This page describes a proposal for a new [[Help:resource types|resource type]] on Wikademia. Please join the [[Wikademia_talk:What_shall_we_do_with_Wikipedia%3F/Expert_commentaries|discussion of this proposal]].
Line 5: Line 5:
== What is an expert commentary? ==
== What is an expert commentary? ==


An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a [[w:Main page|Wikipedia]] article''''' (or a part thereof) by an expert in the area. It is a piece of writing with an article-level standard and style. It is placed on Wikademia primarily as a means of '''expert retention''', because Wikademia's style of resource development is more merciful to expert contributions than Wikipedia.
An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a [[Wikipedia:Main page|Wikipedia]] article''''' (or a part thereof) by an expert in the area. It is a piece of writing with an article-level standard and style. It is placed on Wikademia primarily as a means of '''expert retention''', because Wikademia's style of resource development is more merciful to expert contributions than Wikipedia.


===The context of an expert commentary ===
===The context of an expert commentary ===
Line 22: Line 22:
[[Image:Crepuscular rays fork.jpg|thumb|right|200px|Experts need [[Help:fork|forks]], because they usually disagree.]][[Image:View of the Aurlandsfjord, Aurlandsvangen and Flam from below the Prest Summit.jpg|thumb|right|200px|If you have been to the top of the mountain, you tend to see more - but from a particular point-of-view.]] Experts constantly add their uniquely useful expertise to articles on Wikipedia. Because Wikipedia does not allow '''[[Help:fork|forking]]''', any subsequent editor is obliged to spoil the expert contribution. The quality improvement of a Wikipedia article is not linear - it is bumpy. An expert may be followed by amateurs, fools and vandals of varying degrees, followed by an expert who disagrees with the first one. Generally quality tends to move upwards, but at the cost of the loss of many valuable contributions during a stormy process. While this process is ''good for Wikipedia'' and ''good for people using Wikipedia for reference'', it is an unpleasant and even degrading experience for experts.
[[Image:Crepuscular rays fork.jpg|thumb|right|200px|Experts need [[Help:fork|forks]], because they usually disagree.]][[Image:View of the Aurlandsfjord, Aurlandsvangen and Flam from below the Prest Summit.jpg|thumb|right|200px|If you have been to the top of the mountain, you tend to see more - but from a particular point-of-view.]] Experts constantly add their uniquely useful expertise to articles on Wikipedia. Because Wikipedia does not allow '''[[Help:fork|forking]]''', any subsequent editor is obliged to spoil the expert contribution. The quality improvement of a Wikipedia article is not linear - it is bumpy. An expert may be followed by amateurs, fools and vandals of varying degrees, followed by an expert who disagrees with the first one. Generally quality tends to move upwards, but at the cost of the loss of many valuable contributions during a stormy process. While this process is ''good for Wikipedia'' and ''good for people using Wikipedia for reference'', it is an unpleasant and even degrading experience for experts.


Experts also fall tend to foul of Wikipedia's strict interpretation of [[w:Wikipedia:Neutral point of view|NPOV]] and [[w:Wikipedia:No original research|policy against original research]]. Experts are, undoubtedly, qualified to make statements which adopt a point-of-view and which may be original. These statements are a form of knowledge which is educational, and which should be collected and shared with humanity. However such statements are usually re-written, watered down or deleted from Wikipedia for policy reasons.
Experts also fall tend to foul of Wikipedia's strict interpretation of [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Neutral point of view|NPOV]] and [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:No original research|policy against original research]]. Experts are, undoubtedly, qualified to make statements which adopt a point-of-view and which may be original. These statements are a form of knowledge which is educational, and which should be collected and shared with humanity. However such statements are usually re-written, watered down or deleted from Wikipedia for policy reasons.


Expert commentaries are not just something needed by the experts themselves, to satisfy their personal intellectual needs. There is also a wider human need here on the part of all of mankind. There needs to be a Wikimedia project which acts as a repository of wisdom in a wider sense than a mere encyclopedia.
Expert commentaries are not just something needed by the experts themselves, to satisfy their personal intellectual needs. There is also a wider human need here on the part of all of mankind. There needs to be a Wikimedia project which acts as a repository of wisdom in a wider sense than a mere encyclopedia.
Line 32: Line 32:


''See also:''
''See also:''
* [[w:Wikipedia:Expert retention|Expert retention: the lengthy and controversial debate on expert retention at Wikipedia]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Expert retention|Expert retention: the lengthy and controversial debate on expert retention at Wikipedia]]
* [[w:Wikipedia:Expert editors|Expert editors: advice to expert editors on Wikipedia]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Expert editors|Expert editors: advice to expert editors on Wikipedia]]
* [[w:Wikipedia:Expert rebellion|Expert rebellion: a shorter and more radical page]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Expert rebellion|Expert rebellion: a shorter and more radical page]]


== Formal criteria for an expert commentary ==
== Formal criteria for an expert commentary ==
Line 64: Line 64:
== Related material on Wikipedia ==
== Related material on Wikipedia ==


* [[w:Wikipedia:WikiProject]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:WikiProject]]
* [[w:Wikipedia:Expert retention]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Expert retention]]
* [[w:Wikipedia:Expert editors]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Expert editors]]
* [[w:Wikipedia:Expert rebellion]]
* [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia:Expert rebellion]]


== See also ==
== See also ==
Line 76: Line 76:
[[Category:Wikademia development]]
[[Category:Wikademia development]]
[[Category:Wikipedia studies]]
[[Category:Wikipedia studies]]
{{ntnes}}