Group work: Difference between revisions
wikademia>Eme m Created page with 'You can start to organize group collaboration here. ==See also== * Groups' |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Group work''' is work performed by two or more people who cooperate toward a shared objective, project, task, or problem. Group work can occur in education, research, business, community organizations, government, families, volunteer organizations, online communities, and many other areas of life. | |||
==See also== | Group work can allow people to combine knowledge, skills, experience, perspectives, labor, and other resources. A group may be able to accomplish things that would be difficult or impossible for one person to accomplish alone. At the same time, working in a group can introduce problems involving communication, coordination, conflict, unequal participation, unclear responsibilities, and decision-making. | ||
Learning how to work effectively with other people can therefore be useful for [[learning]], [[teaching]], [[research]], [[problem solving]], and addressing [[problems in living]]. You can start to organize group collaboration here. | |||
== Characteristics of group work == | |||
Groups can vary considerably in size, structure, purpose, and duration. | |||
Some groups are temporary. A group of students might work together for one week on an assignment. Other groups can last for years or decades. | |||
Groups may be: | |||
* Formal or informal | |||
* Hierarchical or relatively non-hierarchical | |||
* Voluntary or required | |||
* Paid or unpaid | |||
* Competitive or cooperative | |||
* Local or geographically distributed | |||
* Temporary or permanent | |||
* Organized around a specific project or a broader mission | |||
A research team, family, sports team, workplace department, nonprofit board, open-source software project, and study group are all examples of groups, but they may operate very differently. | |||
Understanding the purpose and structure of a group can make it easier to determine what methods of group work are appropriate. | |||
== Benefits of group work == | |||
Group work can provide several potential benefits. | |||
A group can divide a large task into smaller tasks. Different members can specialize in areas where they have greater knowledge or ability. | |||
Groups can also provide multiple perspectives. One person may identify a problem that another person overlooked. Someone with technical knowledge may understand one part of a problem, while someone with practical experience may understand another part. | |||
Potential benefits of group work include: | |||
* Combining different skills and areas of knowledge | |||
* Dividing complicated projects into manageable tasks | |||
* Increasing the amount of work that can be completed | |||
* Exposing participants to different perspectives | |||
* Providing opportunities to learn from other people | |||
* Generating additional ideas | |||
* Providing feedback on ideas and plans | |||
* Creating social support and accountability | |||
* Allowing people to solve problems collectively | |||
* Teaching communication and leadership skills | |||
The existence of a group does not automatically produce these benefits. Poorly organized group work can sometimes accomplish less than effective individual work. | |||
== Problems that can occur in groups == | |||
Groups can develop their own [[problems in living]]. | |||
One common problem is unequal participation. Some people may perform considerably more work than others. This can occur intentionally or unintentionally. | |||
[[w:Social loafing|Social loafing]] refers to a tendency for some people to put less effort into a task when working as part of a group than they would when working individually. | |||
Other problems can include: | |||
* Poor communication | |||
* Unclear responsibilities | |||
* Unclear goals | |||
* Unproductive meetings | |||
* Personality conflicts | |||
* Competition between members | |||
* Unequal access to information | |||
* Excessive bureaucracy | |||
* Failure to make decisions | |||
* Decisions being made without sufficient discussion | |||
* Domination of discussion by one or a few members | |||
* Lack of accountability | |||
* Duplication of work | |||
* Failure to document important decisions | |||
* Failure to recognize or use the abilities of group members | |||
Groups can also become too focused on maintaining agreement. | |||
[[w:Groupthink|Groupthink]] describes situations where pressures toward agreement or cohesion can interfere with critical evaluation of alternatives. Encouraging disagreement, questions, and independent thinking can sometimes improve decision-making. | |||
== Roles and responsibilities == | |||
Effective group work often requires some division of responsibility. | |||
A group may have a formal leader, coordinator, facilitator, secretary, researcher, technical specialist, or other defined roles. Smaller groups may function without formal titles. | |||
Regardless of titles, it can be helpful to answer basic questions such as: | |||
* What is the group trying to accomplish? | |||
* Who is responsible for each task? | |||
* When should each task be completed? | |||
* Who has authority to make particular decisions? | |||
* How will disagreements be handled? | |||
* Where will information and decisions be documented? | |||
* How will the group determine whether its work was successful? | |||
Roles do not always need to be permanent. Leadership can change depending on the task. | |||
For example, someone with technical expertise might lead one part of a project while another person leads research, organization, communication, or implementation. | |||
== Communication == | |||
Communication is an important component of group work. | |||
Members need enough information to understand what other people are doing and how their own work fits into the larger project. | |||
Communication can occur through meetings, conversations, email, chat systems, wikis, shared documents, project management software, issue trackers, and other methods. | |||
More communication is not necessarily better communication. | |||
A group that holds several unnecessary meetings each week may communicate frequently while accomplishing little. Another group may communicate primarily through well-organized written documentation and accomplish considerably more. | |||
Useful communication generally provides the information needed for people to act. | |||
Written records can be especially useful for long-term projects because memories differ and people can interpret the same conversation differently. | |||
== Decision-making == | |||
Groups can make decisions in many ways. | |||
Methods can include: | |||
* Consensus | |||
* Majority voting | |||
* Supermajority voting | |||
* Decisions by an elected leader | |||
* Decisions by a project owner | |||
* Delegation to people with relevant expertise | |||
* Informal agreement | |||
Different methods can be appropriate for different situations. | |||
Requiring unanimous agreement for every small decision can make a project difficult to operate. Allowing one person to make every decision can prevent other members from contributing useful knowledge. | |||
Groups can therefore benefit from deciding in advance how different types of decisions will be made. | |||
== Conflict and disagreement == | |||
Disagreement is not necessarily a failure of group work. | |||
People can reasonably disagree about goals, evidence, priorities, strategies, values, or interpretations. | |||
Some disagreement can improve the quality of research and decision-making by forcing a group to examine assumptions and alternatives. | |||
Conflict becomes less useful when disagreement about ideas becomes hostility between people or when disagreements are allowed to prevent necessary work indefinitely. | |||
Useful approaches can include: | |||
* Clearly identifying the actual point of disagreement | |||
* Separating factual questions from disagreements about values | |||
* Looking for additional evidence | |||
* Testing competing approaches when practical | |||
* Allowing minority opinions to be documented | |||
* Establishing procedures for making decisions when agreement cannot be reached | |||
* Returning attention to the purpose of the group | |||
== Group work in learning and education == | |||
Group work is frequently used in education. | |||
Students may work together on research projects, experiments, presentations, discussions, study activities, or problem-solving exercises. | |||
Group work can allow students to learn from one another. Explaining a concept to another person can also help someone determine whether they understand it themselves. | |||
However, group assignments can become less useful when one or two students complete most of the work while everyone receives the same evaluation. | |||
Educators can experiment with methods such as individual responsibilities within a group project, peer evaluation, rotating roles, individual reflections, or separate assessments of individual and group performance. | |||
Research can help determine which forms of group learning work well under particular circumstances. | |||
== Group work in research == | |||
Modern research often involves groups. | |||
A research project may require people with different knowledge in statistics, laboratory techniques, programming, literature review, subject matter expertise, writing, data collection, or project management. | |||
Large scientific projects may involve hundreds or thousands of researchers. | |||
Collaborative research also creates questions involving authorship, credit, data ownership, replication, documentation, funding, and responsibility for errors. | |||
Clear expectations can help prevent disputes later. | |||
== Improving group work == | |||
Groups can treat their own functioning as something that can be studied and improved. | |||
A simple process might involve: | |||
# Define the purpose of the group. | |||
# Identify the work that needs to be completed. | |||
# Divide responsibilities clearly. | |||
# Establish appropriate methods of communication. | |||
# Establish how decisions will be made. | |||
# Perform the work. | |||
# Document important information. | |||
# Evaluate the results. | |||
# Identify what worked and what did not work. | |||
# Modify the process and repeat as necessary. | |||
This resembles other forms of [[problem solving]]. | |||
A group does not need to operate perfectly in order to be useful. It needs to be capable of recognizing problems and improving how it works. | |||
== Discussion questions, essay ideas, and learning related AI prompt ideas == | |||
* What characteristics make group work more effective? | |||
* When is individual work preferable to group work? | |||
* What is an appropriate size for a working group? | |||
* How can groups reduce social loafing? | |||
* How can a group encourage disagreement without creating unnecessary interpersonal conflict? | |||
* How should credit be distributed when members contribute different amounts or different types of work? | |||
* Should every member of a group have an equal vote? | |||
* What types of decisions are best made by consensus? | |||
* When should a group delegate a decision to someone with specialized expertise? | |||
* How can groups determine whether meetings are useful? | |||
* How does remote group work differ from working together in person? | |||
* How can wikis be used to organize group knowledge? | |||
* What are examples of successful large-scale group projects? | |||
* How can group work be applied to solving [[problems in living]]? | |||
* Ask an AI system to design three different structures for a five-person research group and compare the advantages and disadvantages of each. | |||
* Ask an AI system to examine a hypothetical dysfunctional group and identify possible changes to communication, responsibilities, and decision-making. | |||
* Design an experiment that compares individual problem solving with group problem solving. | |||
* Compare cooperative, competitive, hierarchical, and decentralized forms of group organization. | |||
== Wikipedia readings == | |||
* [[w:Group dynamics|Group dynamics]] | |||
* [[w:Teamwork|Teamwork]] | |||
* [[w:Cooperative learning|Cooperative learning]] | |||
* [[w:Collaborative learning|Collaborative learning]] | |||
* [[w:Group decision-making|Group decision-making]] | |||
* [[w:Groupthink|Groupthink]] | |||
* [[w:Social loafing|Social loafing]] | |||
* [[w:Leadership|Leadership]] | |||
* [[w:Conflict resolution|Conflict resolution]] | |||
* [[w:Consensus decision-making|Consensus decision-making]] | |||
* [[w:Collective intelligence|Collective intelligence]] | |||
== See also == | |||
* [[Collaboration]] | |||
* [[Cooperation]] | |||
* [[Communication]] | |||
* [[Leadership]] | |||
* [[Learning]] | |||
* [[Teaching]] | |||
* [[Research]] | |||
* [[Problem solving]] | |||
* [[Problems in living]] | |||
* [[Social psychology]] | |||
* [[Organizational psychology]] | |||
* [[Group dynamics]] | |||
* [[Project management]] | |||
* [[Decision making]] | |||
* [[Conflict resolution]] | |||
* [[Collective intelligence]] | |||
* [[Community]] | |||
* [[Organizations]] | |||
* [[Groups]] | * [[Groups]] | ||
[[Category:Group work]] | |||
[[Category:Learning]] | |||
[[Category:Teaching]] | |||
[[Category:Research]] | |||
[[Category:Social psychology]] | |||
[[Category:Problem solving]] | |||
[[Category:Collaboration]] | |||