Doorman fallacy: Difference between revisions

Linked "Robert M. Wachter" to his page, described his title as on that page
No edit summary
 
(6 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Error of reducing human roles to basic functions}}
The '''doorman fallacy''' is a [[Category mistake|category error]] in which a complex human role is reduced to a function, leading to the assumption that it can be replaced with a cost-effective automated substitute without loss of value, with decision-makers failing to understand the indirect, intangible, non-visible value they provide.<ref>{{cite news |last1=Lipnickas |first1=Gediminas |date=3 November 2025 |title=The ‘doorman fallacy’: why careless adoption of AI backfires so easily |url=https://theconversation.com/the-doorman-fallacy-why-careless-adoption-of-ai-backfires-so-easily-268380 |access-date=20 June 2026 |work=The Conversation}}</ref>
The '''doorman fallacy''' is a [[Category mistake|category error]] in which a complex human role is reduced to a function, leading to the assumption that it can be replaced with a cost-effective automated substitute without loss of value, with decision-makers failing to understand the indirect, intangible, non-visible value they provide.<ref>{{cite news |last1=Lipnickas |first1=Gediminas |date=3 November 2025 |title=The ‘doorman fallacy’: why careless adoption of AI backfires so easily |url=https://theconversation.com/the-doorman-fallacy-why-careless-adoption-of-ai-backfires-so-easily-268380 |access-date=20 June 2026 |work=The Conversation}}</ref>


Line 5: Line 4:


== Origin ==
== Origin ==
The term "doorman fallacy" was coined and popularized by [[Rory Sutherland (advertising executive)|Rory Sutherland]] in his 2019 book ''Alchemy''. ''The Surprising Power of Ideas That Don’t Make Sense.<ref name="alchemy">{{Cite book |last=Sutherland |first=Rory |title=Alchemy : the surprising power of ideas that don't make sense |date=2019 |isbn=978-0-7535-5137-0 |location=London |oclc=1091689287}}</ref>''
The term "doorman fallacy" was coined and popularized by [[Rory Sutherland (advertising executive)|Rory Sutherland]] in his 2019 book ''Alchemy:'' ''The Surprising Power of Ideas That Don’t Make Sense.<ref name="alchemy">{{Cite book |last=Sutherland |first=Rory |title=Alchemy : the surprising power of ideas that don't make sense |date=2019 |isbn=978-0-7535-5137-0 |location=London |oclc=1091689287}}</ref>''


The term "[[Doorman (profession)|doorman]]" refers to the role of a hotel doorman, which is mistakenly assumed to be solely for opening doors. The hotel replaces the doorman with an automated door system as a cost-saving measure. However, they fail to realize the indirect functions such as the following:  
The term "[[Doorman (profession)|doorman]]" refers to the role of a hotel doorman, which is mistakenly assumed to be solely for opening doors. The hotel replaces the doorman with an automated door system as a cost-saving measure. However, they fail to realize the indirect functions such as the following: