Archive:Project fork: Difference between revisions

wikademia>David Gerard
you're really not going to end up here accidentally
wikademia>David Gerard
→Free software: examples of relationships
Line 7: Line 7:
==Free software==
==Free software==


In free software, forks often result from a [[schism]] over different goals or personality clashes. In a fork, both parties assume nearly identical code bases but typically only the larger group, or that containing the original [[software architecture|architect]], will retain the full original name and its associated user community.  Thus there is a reputation penalty associated with forking.  
In free software, forks often result from a [[schism]] over different goals or personality clashes. In a fork, both parties assume nearly identical code bases but typically only the larger group, or that containing the original [[software architecture|architect]], will retain the full original name and its associated user community.  Thus there is a reputation penalty associated with forking. The relationship between the different teams can be cordial (''e.g.'' [[Ubuntu Linux]] and [[Debian]]), very bitter ([[XOrg Server]] and [[XFree86]]) or none to speak of (most branching [[Linux distribution]]s).


Forks are considered an expression of the freedom made available by free software, but a weakness since they duplicate development efforts and can confuse users over which forked package to use.  Developers have the option to collaborate and pool resources with free software, but it is not ensured by [[free software licenses]], only by a commitment to cooperation. That said, many developers will make the effort to put changes into all relevant forks, ''e.g.'' amongst the [[BSD]]s.
Forks are considered an expression of the freedom made available by free software, but a weakness since they duplicate development efforts and can confuse users over which forked package to use.  Developers have the option to collaborate and pool resources with free software, but it is not ensured by [[free software licenses]], only by a commitment to cooperation. That said, many developers will make the effort to put changes into all relevant forks, ''e.g.'' amongst the [[BSD]]s.


''[[The Cathedral and the Bazaar]]'' stated in 1997 [http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/homesteading/ar01s03.html] that ''"The most important characteristic of a fork is that it spawns competing projects that cannot later exchange code, splitting the potential developer community."'' However, this is not common present usage.
''[[The Cathedral and the Bazaar]]'' stated in 1997 [http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/homesteading/ar01s03.html] that ''"The most important characteristic of a fork is that it spawns competing projects that cannot later exchange code, splitting the potential developer community."'' However, this is not common present usage.
The relationship between the different teams can be cordial or very bitter.  For instance, when the author of the [[LMule]] file-sharing program for Linux was uninterested in porting it to other systems, the [[xMule]] team started a fork to do so. Disagreements among the developers led to xMule itself being forked into [[aMule]], and the tension between the developers persisted.


In some cases, a fork can merge back into the original project or replace it. The [[EGCS|Experimental/Enhanced GNU Compiler System]] was a fork from [[GNU Compiler Collection|GCC]] which proved more vital than the original project and was eventually "blessed" as the official GCC project. Some have attempted to invoke this effect deliberately, ''e.g.'' [[Mozilla Firefox]] was an unofficial project within [[Mozilla]] that soon replaced the [[Mozilla Suite]] as the focus of development.
In some cases, a fork can merge back into the original project or replace it. The [[EGCS|Experimental/Enhanced GNU Compiler System]] was a fork from [[GNU Compiler Collection|GCC]] which proved more vital than the original project and was eventually "blessed" as the official GCC project. Some have attempted to invoke this effect deliberately, ''e.g.'' [[Mozilla Firefox]] was an unofficial project within [[Mozilla]] that soon replaced the [[Mozilla Suite]] as the focus of development.