Archive:Introduction to US History/Justification: Difference between revisions

wikademia>Jade Knight
wikademia>Jolie
Line 9: Line 9:
--[[User:Jolie|Jolie]] 18:16, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
--[[User:Jolie|Jolie]] 18:16, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
**I don't know that such a claim, although evidently incorrect, is properly a "straw man".  It is more simply a "false claim", which is not necessarily the same thing.  More significantly:  Why not simply edit the current Wikibook to be more accurate?  [[user:Jade Knight|The Jade Knight]] <sup>[[User talk:Jade Knight|(d'viser)]]</sup> 07:23, 19 October 2008 (UTC)
**I don't know that such a claim, although evidently incorrect, is properly a "straw man".  It is more simply a "false claim", which is not necessarily the same thing.  More significantly:  Why not simply edit the current Wikibook to be more accurate?  [[user:Jade Knight|The Jade Knight]] <sup>[[User talk:Jade Knight|(d'viser)]]</sup> 07:23, 19 October 2008 (UTC)
**Well, Geo.plrd is quite significant to this discussion and hopefully will come here to discuss. I think HE might have problems with its organization and ability to meet AP US History content.
**But Here is THE question. if we start altering the textbook in a way that HE doesn't like, he Might feel we are VANDALS and take administrative action against us.  After all He wrote the book and was heavily against the bering strait theory and might NOT appreciate my edits.
All efforts to invite him into the discussion did not work.  It feels more natural (although much harder) to offer an "opposing book" when the book you are using seems heavily skewed and not objective. --[[User:Jolie|Jolie]] 12:47, 20 October 2008 (UTC)