Archive:Homeopathy edit war: Difference between revisions

wikademia>JWSchmidt
early edits and conflict
wikademia>JWSchmidt
→Partisanship: another representative quote for the other "side"
Line 39: Line 39:
*'''Where are they now?'''
*'''Where are they now?'''
"I became less active a couple of years ago, a group of tag team editors discovered they could pin a false accusation of POV pushing and "undue weight" on me and got me banned from the Intelligent Design article. Ironically, the result is that the article condemns ID instead of being neutral. Note: I don't want the article to endorse ID - to be neutral on a controversial topic, a Wikipedia article should neither endorse nor condemn any viewpoint." ([http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Ed_Poor&oldid=291017396 see])
"I became less active a couple of years ago, a group of tag team editors discovered they could pin a false accusation of POV pushing and "undue weight" on me and got me banned from the Intelligent Design article. Ironically, the result is that the article condemns ID instead of being neutral. Note: I don't want the article to endorse ID - to be neutral on a controversial topic, a Wikipedia article should neither endorse nor condemn any viewpoint." ([http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Ed_Poor&oldid=291017396 see])
"I am not a proponent of homeopathy, so I can't really give a fair treatment to this article, but it seems that this will not be an NPOV article, but instead critics of homeopathy will always get the last word in any discussion of the issues involved. I was attempting to make a feeble last gasp effort at introducing some balance to this article, but it is clearly a failed effort since Wikipedia is not a project committed to balance or NPOV."