Instance dungeon: Difference between revisions

Redo lead in summary style; organized discussion of problems and solutions; The Realm (1996) had them
+2 refs, more criticism
Line 5: Line 5:
The problem can be stated as follows: every player wants to be "The Hero", slay "The Monster", rescue "The Princess", and obtain "The Magic Sword". When there are thousands of players all playing the same game, clearly not everyone can be the hero. The problem of everyone wanting to kill the same monster and gain the best treasure became obvious in the game ''[[EverQuest]]'', where several groups of players would compete and sometimes harass each other in the same dungeon, in order to get to the monsters dropping valuable items. The creation of instances largely solves this set of problems, leaving only travelling to and from the dungeon as a potential risk in [[player versus player]] environments.
The problem can be stated as follows: every player wants to be "The Hero", slay "The Monster", rescue "The Princess", and obtain "The Magic Sword". When there are thousands of players all playing the same game, clearly not everyone can be the hero. The problem of everyone wanting to kill the same monster and gain the best treasure became obvious in the game ''[[EverQuest]]'', where several groups of players would compete and sometimes harass each other in the same dungeon, in order to get to the monsters dropping valuable items. The creation of instances largely solves this set of problems, leaving only travelling to and from the dungeon as a potential risk in [[player versus player]] environments.


Stated another way, instances can be used to reduce the competition over resources within the game.  Excessive competition in these spaces leads to several undesirable behaviors such as [[kill stealing]], [[spawn camping]], and [[ninja looting]] as players do whatever they can to acquire the limited rewards.  Instancing preserves the gaming experience, since some gaming scenarios do not work if the player is continually surrounded by other players, as in a multiplayer setting. Instance dungeons may contain stronger than usual mobs and rare, sought-after equipment. They also may include level restrictions and/or restrict the number of players allowed in each instance to balance gameplay.  Several games use instancing to scale the [[mob (computer gaming)|mobs]] to the players' levels, and/or the number of players present.
Stated another way, instances can be used to reduce the competition over resources within the game.<ref name="McQuaid">{{cite web |url=http://www.gamergod.com/article.php?article_id=2933 |title=Instancing in Online Gaming |author=[[Brad McQuaid]] |date=29 November 2005 |publisher=GamerGod |accessdate=8 August 2010 |archiveurl=http://web.archive.org/web/20060324110936/http://www.gamergod.com/article.php?article_id=2933 |archivedate=24 March 2006}}</ref> Excessive competition in these spaces leads to several undesirable behaviors such as [[kill stealing]], [[spawn camping]], and [[ninja looting]] as players do whatever they can to acquire the limited rewards.  Instancing preserves the gaming experience, since some gaming scenarios do not work if the player is continually surrounded by other players, as in a multiplayer setting. Instance dungeons may contain stronger than usual mobs and rare, sought-after equipment. They also may include level restrictions and/or restrict the number of players allowed in each instance to balance gameplay.  Several games use instancing to scale the [[mob (computer gaming)|mobs]] to the players' levels, and/or the number of players present.


==Technical considerations==
==Technical considerations==
Line 11: Line 11:


==Criticism==
==Criticism==
Despite its advantages, instancing in MMORPGs has been criticized. For example, one reviewer described the extensive use of instancing in ''[[Age of Conan]]'' as "[destroying] the sense of expansiveness an MMORPG should have".<ref name="Ryan">{{cite journal|last=Ryan|first=Leon|title=Age of Conan: Hyborian Adventures|journal=GameAxis Unwired|year=2008|month=July|pages=35|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=weoDAAAAMBAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false|accessdate=8 August 2010}}</ref>
Despite its advantages, instancing in MMOGs has been criticized. [[Brad McQuaid]], lead designer of ''[[EverQuest]]'' and ''[[Vanguard: Saga of Heroes]]'' (both of which did not feature instancing at launch), wrote an essay in 2005 arguing that instances can negatively affect the game's community, [[virtual economy]], [[churn rate]], and other factors.<ref name="McQuaid" />  In response to this article, [[Raph Koster]] added that instancing should be limited to situations in which the creation of a "pocket zone" makes sense within the context of the [[fictional universe]] &mdash; such as the [[holodeck]] in the [[Star Trek franchise]].<ref name="Koster">{{cite web |url=http://www.raphkoster.com/2005/11/30/from-instancing-to-worldy-games/ |title=From instancing to worldy games |author=[[Raph Koster]] |date=30 November 2005 |accessdate=8 August 2010}}</ref>  One reviewer described the extensive use of instancing in ''[[Age of Conan]]'' as "[destroying] the sense of expansiveness an MMORPG should have".<ref name="Ryan">{{cite journal|last=Ryan|first=Leon|title=Age of Conan: Hyborian Adventures|journal=GameAxis Unwired|year=2008|month=July|pages=35|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=weoDAAAAMBAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false|accessdate=8 August 2010}}</ref>


==Usage==
==Usage==