How to write a psychiatric advance directive: Difference between revisions
New article: how to write a psychiatric advance directive |
add strong disclaimer and limits section; soften protection claims |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A '''psychiatric advance directive''' (PAD) is a legal document in which a person, while well, records how they want to be treated during a future mental health crisis and, if they wish, names someone to speak for them when they cannot.<ref name="nrchome">[https://nrc-pad.org/ National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives, home page]</ref> This page is a practical guide to writing one. It covers what a PAD | A '''psychiatric advance directive''' (PAD) is a legal document in which a person, while well, records how they want to be treated during a future mental health crisis and, if they wish, names someone to speak for them when they cannot.<ref name="nrchome">[https://nrc-pad.org/ National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives, home page]</ref> This page is a practical guide to writing one. It covers what a PAD may do, the important limits on what it cannot do, what the research shows, how to draft each section, how to choose an agent, how to make the document findable in a crisis, and how the law works in one example state. It is written for people who have been through a crisis before, for people who support them, and for students of [[Psychiatry|psychiatry]], [[Law|law]], and [[Medical ethics|medical ethics]]. | ||
'' | <div style="border:2px solid #b8860b; padding:10px"> | ||
'''Important notice.''' | |||
* This is general educational information, not legal or medical advice. | |||
* Laws vary by state and change over time. | |||
* A psychiatric advance directive may be overridden and does not guarantee protection against involuntary commitment or forced treatment. | |||
* Consult a lawyer or a legal advocacy organization (such as the state protection and advocacy agency) before relying on one. | |||
</div> | |||
== The problem a psychiatric advance directive solves == | == The problem a psychiatric advance directive solves == | ||
| Line 7: | Line 13: | ||
During a severe crisis, a person may be judged unable to make treatment decisions. At that point, other people decide which hospital, which medication, which dose, and who gets told. Those decisions are often made quickly by staff who have never met the person and do not know their history: which drug caused a bad reaction, which approach calms them down, who should feed the cat, or which relative should not be called. | During a severe crisis, a person may be judged unable to make treatment decisions. At that point, other people decide which hospital, which medication, which dose, and who gets told. Those decisions are often made quickly by staff who have never met the person and do not know their history: which drug caused a bad reaction, which approach calms them down, who should feed the cat, or which relative should not be called. | ||
A PAD moves some of that knowledge and some of that choice back to the person. It is written in a calm period, when the person can think through their own history, and it is used later, when they may not be able to explain it. For readers interested in [[Problems in living|problems in living]] and the critique of [[Outlaw involuntary treatment|involuntary treatment]], a PAD is one of the few tools | A PAD moves some of that knowledge and some of that choice back to the person. It is written in a calm period, when the person can think through their own history, and it is used later, when they may not be able to explain it. For readers interested in [[Problems in living|problems in living]] and the critique of [[Outlaw involuntary treatment|involuntary treatment]], a PAD is one of the few tools available inside the current system today, although, as the limits section below explains, it offers only partial and conditional protection. Psychiatrist Thomas Szasz proposed a related idea in 1982, which he called a psychiatric will, as a way for a person to refuse in advance psychiatric interventions they did not want.<ref name="szasz">Szasz, T. S. (1982). The psychiatric will: A new mechanism for protecting persons against psychosis and psychiatry. ''American Psychologist'', 37(7), 762 to 770. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.37.7.762</ref> See [[Szaszian studies|Szaszian studies]] for more on his work. | ||
== What the research shows == | == What the research shows == | ||
| Line 19: | Line 25: | ||
Stated preferences can shape ordinary care too. In a study of 123 people who listed medication preferences in a PAD, prescriptions moved toward the medications they had requested, and people who were prescribed at least one requested medication were much more likely to keep taking it at 12 months.<ref name="meds">Wilder, C. M., et al. (2010). [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3676902/ Medication preferences and adherence among individuals with severe mental illness and psychiatric advance directives]. ''Psychiatric Services'', 61(4), 380 to 385.</ref> | Stated preferences can shape ordinary care too. In a study of 123 people who listed medication preferences in a PAD, prescriptions moved toward the medications they had requested, and people who were prescribed at least one requested medication were much more likely to keep taking it at 12 months.<ref name="meds">Wilder, C. M., et al. (2010). [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3676902/ Medication preferences and adherence among individuals with severe mental illness and psychiatric advance directives]. ''Psychiatric Services'', 61(4), 380 to 385.</ref> | ||
The practical lesson is | These studies show associations and average effects in specific settings. They do not show that a PAD will prevent compulsory treatment for any individual person. The practical lesson is to write it with someone, and to write it so a clinician can use it. | ||
== Limits: what a psychiatric advance directive cannot do == | |||
A PAD records a person's wishes, but in many situations the law allows those wishes to be set aside. Readers should understand these limits before relying on one. | |||
* '''Civil commitment, emergencies, and court-ordered treatment.''' The National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives explains that state PAD laws commonly list circumstances in which clinicians may decline to follow a directive, and its state pages describe each state's rules.<ref name="nrcstates" /> In Oregon, for example, the statute allows treatment contrary to a declaration if the person is civilly committed and treatment is authorized under the commitment law, if the person is committed or transferred to a state hospital or similar facility under certain criminal or fitness to proceed provisions, or in an emergency endangering life or health.<ref name="ors720">[https://www.oregonlegislature.gov/bills_laws/ors/ors127.html Oregon Revised Statutes 127.720, Circumstances in which physician or provider may disregard declaration]</ref> | |||
* '''A PAD does not block commitment itself.''' Oregon law states that a declaration does not limit any authority under the civil commitment statutes (ORS 426.005 to 426.390) to take a person into custody, or to admit, retain, or treat a person in a health care facility.<ref name="ors720" /> | |||
* '''Professional judgment and withdrawal.''' In Oregon, a provider acting under a declaration must follow it "to the fullest extent possible, consistent with reasonable medical practice, the availability of treatments requested and applicable law," and a provider who is unwilling to follow it may withdraw from providing treatment.<ref name="ors717">[https://www.oregonlegislature.gov/bills_laws/ors/ors127.html Oregon Revised Statutes 127.717, Declaration to be made part of medical record; physician or provider to comply with declaration]</ref> The national resource center's summary also notes that a provider may refuse to follow a declaration that is inconsistent with professional judgment.<ref name="orfaq" /> | |||
* '''Uneven use in practice.''' A directive helps only if someone finds and reads it. In a two-year study of 106 outpatients who had completed directives, researchers examined 90 crisis events in which a directive was accessed. In those events, care was consistent with the directive's instructions in an average of 67 percent of relevant areas. Instructions about hospital choice, seclusion and restraint, and contacting a surrogate were followed less consistently, and the most common reason given for overriding instructions was clinical need.<ref name="srebnik">Srebnik, D. S., and Russo, J. (2007). [https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17766559/ Consistency of psychiatric crisis care with advance directive instructions]. ''Psychiatric Services'', 58(9), 1157 to 1163.</ref> | |||
For these reasons, a PAD is best understood as a way to communicate and document preferences, not as a guarantee against involuntary commitment or forced treatment. | |||
== Types of advance statements == | == Types of advance statements == | ||
| Line 31: | Line 48: | ||
== Step 1: Find the rules and forms for your state == | == Step 1: Find the rules and forms for your state == | ||
Almost all states allow some kind of health care advance directive that can cover at least some psychiatric treatment, and the National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives reports that 25 states have adopted laws specific to PADs.<ref name="nrcstates">[https://nrc-pad.org/states/ National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives, State by state information]</ref> Its state pages list each state's forms, witness rules, and the situations in which clinicians may decline to follow a directive. Start there, download the official form if your state has one, and read the override rules before you write anything. Those rules tell you which parts of your document | Almost all states allow some kind of health care advance directive that can cover at least some psychiatric treatment, and the National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives reports that 25 states have adopted laws specific to PADs.<ref name="nrcstates">[https://nrc-pad.org/states/ National Resource Center on Psychiatric Advance Directives, State by state information]</ref> Its state pages list each state's forms, witness rules, and the situations in which clinicians may decline to follow a directive. Start there, download the official form if your state has one, and read the override rules before you write anything. Those rules tell you which parts of your document are most likely to carry weight, and in which situations the document may be set aside. | ||
== Step 2: Describe your own crisis pattern == | == Step 2: Describe your own crisis pattern == | ||
| Line 56: | Line 73: | ||
== Step 4: Cover your life outside the hospital == | == Step 4: Cover your life outside the hospital == | ||
A crisis can cost a person their housing, job, or pet. List who should be told and who should not, who looks after children or animals, how rent and bills get paid, whom to call at work, and where spare keys are. Practical instructions like these | A crisis can cost a person their housing, job, or pet. List who should be told and who should not, who looks after children or animals, how rent and bills get paid, whom to call at work, and where spare keys are. Practical instructions like these may help prevent a short hospital stay from turning into a lasting financial setback. | ||
== Step 5: Choose your agent carefully == | == Step 5: Choose your agent carefully == | ||
| Line 78: | Line 95: | ||
* Two adult witnesses who know the person must sign and certify that the person appeared of sound mind and was not under pressure. The agent, relatives, and employees of the person's health care provider cannot serve as witnesses. | * Two adult witnesses who know the person must sign and certify that the person appeared of sound mind and was not under pressure. The agent, relatives, and employees of the person's health care provider cannot serve as witnesses. | ||
* The declaration takes effect when two physicians find the person unable to make mental health decisions; no court order is needed. | * The declaration takes effect when two physicians find the person unable to make mental health decisions; no court order is needed. | ||
* Providers may decline to follow it if the person is civilly committed, in certain criminal or fitness proceedings, in an emergency, or when it conflicts with their professional judgment. | * Providers may decline to follow it if the person is civilly committed, in certain criminal or fitness proceedings, in an emergency, or when it conflicts with their professional judgment. The statute also states that a declaration does not limit the authority to take a person into custody or to admit, retain, or treat a person under the civil commitment laws.<ref name="ors720" /> | ||
* It is valid for three years, and stays in effect past that date if the person is incapable at the time it would expire. | * It is valid for three years, and stays in effect past that date if the person is incapable at the time it would expire. | ||
| Line 85: | Line 102: | ||
== Limits to keep in mind == | == Limits to keep in mind == | ||
A PAD is a | A PAD is a request, not a guarantee. See the limits section above for details. Most states allow clinicians to set it aside in emergencies or during involuntary commitment, and some allow them to decline on grounds of professional judgment. A document that refuses everything is the easiest to set aside. A document that offers reasoned alternatives may be easier for staff to follow, although no wording ensures that it will be followed. A PAD also does not replace a good working relationship with a prescriber, and it should be updated when your preferences change. | ||
== Getting help writing one == | == Getting help writing one == | ||
| Line 93: | Line 110: | ||
== Discussion questions, essay ideas, and learning related AI prompt ideas == | == Discussion questions, essay ideas, and learning related AI prompt ideas == | ||
* In what situations can a psychiatric advance directive be overridden in your state, and what does that suggest about its limits? | |||
* Why might a facilitated session raise completion rates from 3 percent to 61 percent, and what does that suggest about how other legal tools are designed? | * Why might a facilitated session raise completion rates from 3 percent to 61 percent, and what does that suggest about how other legal tools are designed? | ||
* Write an essay comparing a psychiatric advance directive with Thomas Szasz's proposed psychiatric will. | * Write an essay comparing a psychiatric advance directive with Thomas Szasz's proposed psychiatric will. | ||