Tudor IT Process Assessment: Difference between revisions
←Created page with 'Tudor IT Process Assessment (TIPA®) is a process assessment framework developed by the Public Research Centre Henri Tudor based in Luxembou...' |
m WP:CHECKWIKI error fix for #93. External link with double http:// Do general fixes if a problem exists. - using AWB (10469) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Tudor IT Process Assessment (TIPA®) is a process assessment framework developed by the [[CRP Henri Tudor|Public Research Centre Henri Tudor ]] based in Luxembourg. TIPA is an open framework for the assessment of IT processes released first in 2003. The TIPA framework offers a structured solution to determine [[process capability]] for processes aligned with recognized best practices. TIPA also supports process improvement by providing a gap analysis and proposing improvement recommendations <ref>http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa</ref> | '''Tudor IT Process Assessment''' (TIPA®) is a process assessment framework developed by the [[CRP Henri Tudor|Public Research Centre Henri Tudor]] based in Luxembourg. TIPA is an open framework for the assessment of IT processes released first in 2003. The TIPA framework offers a structured solution to determine [[process capability]] for processes aligned with recognized best practices. TIPA also supports process improvement by providing a gap analysis and proposing improvement recommendations.<ref>http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa</ref> | ||
[[File:The TIPA framework structure.PNG|thumb|The TIPA framework combines domain-specific process models with the generic TIPA Process Assessment Method. | upright=2]] | [[File:The TIPA framework structure.PNG|thumb|The TIPA framework combines domain-specific process models with the generic TIPA Process Assessment Method. | upright=2]] | ||
The TIPA framework uses the generic approach for process assessment published by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) in [[ISO/IEC 15504]]<ref name=15504_2>[http://www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=37458 ISO_IEC 15504-2]</ref> – Process Assessment (soon to become ISO/IEC 33000). The ISO/IEC 15504-2 requirements on performing assessments are structured and documented in the TIPA Assessment Process. Additional guidance, contextual advice and return of experience complete the TIPA Process Assessment Method and support the usability of the TIPA framework. The TIPA Process Assessment Method can be used to assess TIPA Process Models for different fields of activity. | The TIPA framework uses the generic approach for process assessment published by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) in [[ISO/IEC 15504]]<ref name=15504_2>[http://www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=37458 ISO_IEC 15504-2]</ref> – Process Assessment (soon to become ISO/IEC 33000). The ISO/IEC 15504-2 requirements on performing assessments are structured and documented in the TIPA Assessment Process. Additional guidance, contextual advice and return of experience complete the TIPA Process Assessment Method and support the usability of the TIPA framework. The TIPA Process Assessment Method can be used to assess TIPA Process Models for different fields of activity. | ||
The TIPA framework is supported by an exhaustive toolbox that provides templates and tools for every single step of the assessment process. It can be customized to any domain of application. | The TIPA framework is supported by an exhaustive toolbox that provides templates and tools for every single step of the assessment process. It can be customized to any domain of application. | ||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
Interviews are used to understand the way the process is performed and a process maturity rating scale is used to control the gap between the frame of reference and the domain. | Interviews are used to understand the way the process is performed and a process maturity rating scale is used to control the gap between the frame of reference and the domain. | ||
An assessment project starts with a clear goal statement to define the scope of the project. The project involves a series of roles who take part in the assessment. The assessment project is organized in 6 phases. It is supported by several tools (templates and spreadsheets) provided in the TIPA Toolbox<ref name=toolbox>[http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa/tipa-toolbox/ The TIPA toolbox]</ref> | An assessment project starts with a clear goal statement to define the scope of the project. The project involves a series of roles who take part in the assessment. The assessment project is organized in 6 phases. It is supported by several tools (templates and spreadsheets) provided in the TIPA Toolbox.<ref name=toolbox>[http://www.tipaonline.org/en/tipa/tipa-toolbox/ The TIPA toolbox]</ref> | ||
== History == | == History == | ||
In 2002, the first cases of adoption of ITIL were observed on the Luxembourg market. At the same period, the ISO/IEC TR 15504 Process Assessment standard series was upgraded towards the creation of a generic standard for process assessment, enabling the assessment processes in any kind of domain. CRP Henri Tudor being an active member of the ISO working group in charge of that transformation within [[ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 7]], the idea was born to apply and experiment this new generic assessment framework to both software and IT operation processes. | In 2002, the first cases of adoption of ITIL were observed on the Luxembourg market. At the same period, the ISO/IEC TR 15504 Process Assessment standard series was upgraded towards the creation of a generic standard for process assessment, enabling the assessment processes in any kind of domain. CRP Henri Tudor being an active member of the ISO working group in charge of that transformation within [[ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 7]], the idea was born to apply and experiment this new generic assessment framework to both software and IT operation processes. | ||
This led to the definition of the AIDA (Assessment and Improvement integrateD Approach) research & development project, defined in 2003, aiming at applying a common method for the definition and assessment of processes for both the software development and IT operations sides. The project resulted in the creation of a structured process assessment method for [[IT Service Management]] based on [[ITIL]]. That method was fully compatible with the method described in ISO/IEC 15504 originally designed to assess software development processes. | This led to the definition of the AIDA (Assessment and Improvement integrateD Approach) research & development project, defined in 2003, aiming at applying a common method for the definition and assessment of processes for both the software development and IT operations sides. The project resulted in the creation of a structured process assessment method for [[IT Service Management]] based on [[ITIL]]. That method was fully compatible with the method described in ISO/IEC 15504 originally designed to assess software development processes. | ||
The first Process Reference and Process Assessment models for ITIL v2 were developed and experimented during the years 2004-2005 in partnership with ITIL experts. More experimentation took place the following years locally in Luxembourg and several other regions of the world. | The first Process Reference and Process Assessment models for ITIL v2 were developed and experimented during the years 2004-2005 in partnership with ITIL experts. More experimentation took place the following years locally in Luxembourg and several other regions of the world. | ||
In 2009 AIDA was rebranded as TIPA (Tudor IT Process Assessment) and this brand officially registered<ref>TIPA® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Centre de Recherche Public Henri Tudor.</ref> | In 2009 AIDA was rebranded as TIPA (Tudor IT Process Assessment) and this brand officially registered.<ref>TIPA® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Centre de Recherche Public Henri Tudor.</ref> | ||
The complete method was published in the book “ITSM Process Assessment Supporting ITIL“, released in 2009. | The complete method was published in the book “ITSM Process Assessment Supporting ITIL“, released in 2009. | ||
A major upgrade of TIPA for ITIL took place in 2013 to align the framework with ITIL 2011. That upgrade has also been the opportunity to improve the overall quality of the framework based on the 8 years of experience by Tudor and historical users of the method. | A major upgrade of TIPA for ITIL took place in 2013 to align the framework with ITIL 2011. That upgrade has also been the opportunity to improve the overall quality of the framework based on the 8 years of experience by Tudor and historical users of the method. | ||
The last upgrade was done in March 2014 to introduce classes of assessment aligned with the requirements of the upcoming ISO/IEC 3300x<ref>[ | The last upgrade was done in March 2014 to introduce classes of assessment aligned with the requirements of the upcoming ISO/IEC 3300x<ref>[http://www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=54176/ ISO_IEC 33002]</ref> series planned to replace ISO/IEC 15504 by the end of 2014. | ||
== Applications == | == Applications == | ||
| Line 46: | Line 46: | ||
<ref name=service_transition>{{cite book|author=Stuart Rance|title=ITIL Service Transition|publisher=The Stationery Office|year=2011|isbn=978-0113313068}}</ref> | <ref name=service_transition>{{cite book|author=Stuart Rance|title=ITIL Service Transition|publisher=The Stationery Office|year=2011|isbn=978-0113313068}}</ref> | ||
<ref name=service_operation>{{cite book|author=Randy A. Steinberg|title=ITIL Service Operation|publisher=The Stationery Office|year=2011|isbn=978-0113313075}}</ref> | <ref name=service_operation>{{cite book|author=Randy A. Steinberg|title=ITIL Service Operation|publisher=The Stationery Office|year=2011|isbn=978-0113313075}}</ref> | ||
<ref name=csi>{{cite book|author=Vernon Lloyd|title=ITIL Continual Service Improvement|publisher=The Stationery Office|year=2011|isbn=978-0113313082}}</ref> | .<ref name=csi>{{cite book|author=Vernon Lloyd|title=ITIL Continual Service Improvement|publisher=The Stationery Office|year=2011|isbn=978-0113313082}}</ref> | ||
=== ISO/IEC 15504 === | === ISO/IEC 15504 === | ||
| Line 75: | Line 75: | ||
=== 6 phases === | === 6 phases === | ||
[[File:The TIPA Assessment Process.PNG|thumb|An assessment is structured as a project, each phase being a prerequisite for the next one. Some activities may be optional for Class 3 assessments. | upright=2]] | [[File:The TIPA Assessment Process.PNG|thumb|An assessment is structured as a project, each phase being a prerequisite for the next one. Some activities may be optional for Class 3 assessments. | upright=2]] | ||
{{pad|2em}}'''Definition phase''' | {{pad|2em}}'''Definition phase''' | ||
During the definition phase, the main objectives are to define the scope of the assessment, to identify the key actors, to agree on a service offer and to agree on the assessment scope agreement. | During the definition phase, the main objectives are to define the scope of the assessment, to identify the key actors, to agree on a service offer and to agree on the assessment scope agreement. | ||
{{pad|2em}}'''Preparation phase''' | {{pad|2em}}'''Preparation phase''' | ||
In this phase, the objective is to discover the organizational context, and then to do an assessment planning and define the organization (by preparing the Assessment team, the supporting documents used during the assessment and the people who will be interviewed). | In this phase, the objective is to discover the organizational context, and then to do an assessment planning and define the organization (by preparing the Assessment team, the supporting documents used during the assessment and the people who will be interviewed). | ||
{{pad|2em}}'''Assessment phase''' | {{pad|2em}}'''Assessment phase''' | ||
| Line 101: | Line 101: | ||
The assessment project can then be closed. | The assessment project can then be closed. | ||
=== Roles === | === Roles === | ||
| Line 111: | Line 109: | ||
{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Lead Assessor''': he is accountable for the compliance of the method delivered and for the assessment results. He is the project manager of the assessment project. A TIPA assessment cannot be done without a Lead Assessor. | {{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Lead Assessor''': he is accountable for the compliance of the method delivered and for the assessment results. He is the project manager of the assessment project. A TIPA assessment cannot be done without a Lead Assessor. | ||
=== The TIPA classes of assessment === | === The TIPA classes of assessment === | ||
Like in the Standard CMMI® Appraisal Method for Process Improvement ([[SCAMPI]]), there are three different classes of assessment in TIPA. | Like in the Standard CMMI® Appraisal Method for Process Improvement ([[SCAMPI]]), there are three different classes of assessment in TIPA. | ||
A TIPA assessment can be performed using Class 1, 2 or 3 depending on the level of confidence required on the assessment results, and on the amount of resources available to perform that assessment. TIPA Class 1 requires more resources than TIPA Class 2 and TIPA Class 2 requires more resource than TIPA Class 3. | A TIPA assessment can be performed using Class 1, 2 or 3 depending on the level of confidence required on the assessment results, and on the amount of resources available to perform that assessment. TIPA Class 1 requires more resources than TIPA Class 2 and TIPA Class 2 requires more resource than TIPA Class 3. | ||
{{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Class 1''' is the most reliable class, it allow to have a very high level of objectivity, rigor and confidence in the assessment result thanks to a large collection of evidence, more than the two other classes. | {{pad|2em}}'''TIPA Class 1''' is the most reliable class, it allow to have a very high level of objectivity, rigor and confidence in the assessment result thanks to a large collection of evidence, more than the two other classes. | ||
| Line 187: | Line 182: | ||
Somehow, CMMI-SVC can be considered as the nearest competitor of TIPA, but differences remain. Indeed, CMMI-SVC targets assessment of services in general whereas TIPA for ITIL concentrates its efforts on IT services. CMMI supports both process capability and organisational maturity. | Somehow, CMMI-SVC can be considered as the nearest competitor of TIPA, but differences remain. Indeed, CMMI-SVC targets assessment of services in general whereas TIPA for ITIL concentrates its efforts on IT services. CMMI supports both process capability and organisational maturity. | ||
'''[[COBIT]]''' | '''[[COBIT]]''' | ||
Control Objectives for Information and Related Technology (COBIT) is a framework created by Information Systems Audit and Control Association (ISACA) for information technology (IT) management and IT governance. COBIT provides a set of recommended best practices for governance and control process of information systems and technology with the essence of aligning IT with business. It allows managers to bridge the gap between control requirements, technical issues and business risks. | Control Objectives for Information and Related Technology (COBIT) is a framework created by Information Systems Audit and Control Association (ISACA) for information technology (IT) management and IT governance. COBIT provides a set of recommended best practices for governance and control process of information systems and technology with the essence of aligning IT with business. It allows managers to bridge the gap between control requirements, technical issues and business risks. | ||
Similarly to TIPA, COBIT 5 embraces the ISO/IEC 15504 philosophy for assessing its processes. | Similarly to TIPA, COBIT 5 embraces the ISO/IEC 15504 philosophy for assessing its processes. | ||
'''[[ISO/IEC 20000]]''' | '''[[ISO/IEC 20000]]''' | ||
ISO/IEC 20000 is the international standard that allows companies to demonstrate their excellence in IT management. The standard ensures companies can achieve evidence-based benchmarks (through certification). | ISO/IEC 20000 is the international standard that allows companies to demonstrate their excellence in IT management. The standard ensures companies can achieve evidence-based benchmarks (through certification). | ||
| Line 201: | Line 196: | ||
ISO/IEC 33000 is a revision of [[ISO/IEC 15504]], it should be effective at the beginning 2015. | ISO/IEC 33000 is a revision of [[ISO/IEC 15504]], it should be effective at the beginning 2015. | ||
The recent works on TIPA, including the introduction of the classes of assessment are aligned with the works conducted at the ISO on the ISO/IEC 33000 series. TIPA is fully aligned with the future ISO/IEC . | The recent works on TIPA, including the introduction of the classes of assessment are aligned with the works conducted at the ISO on the ISO/IEC 33000 series. TIPA is fully aligned with the future ISO/IEC . | ||
== Partnership == | == Partnership == | ||
TIPA was developed by Public Research Centre Henri Tudor thanks to the support of several partners amongst which: | TIPA was developed by Public Research Centre Henri Tudor thanks to the support of several partners amongst which: | ||
*Van Haren Publishing<ref>[http://www.vanharen.net/ Van Haren Publishing]</ref> | *Van Haren Publishing,<ref>[http://www.vanharen.net/ Van Haren Publishing]</ref> publisher on best practices, methods and standard. They are the publisher of the TIPA handbook “ITSM Process Assessment supporting ITIL”. | ||
*ITPreneurs<ref>[https://www.itpreneurs.com/ ITpreneurs]</ref> | *ITPreneurs,<ref>[https://www.itpreneurs.com/ ITpreneurs]</ref> provider of IT best practices trainings. They are the official training provider for TIPA for ITIL. | ||
== Limitations == | == Limitations == | ||
| Line 221: | Line 216: | ||
|title=Itsm Process Assessment Supporting Itil - Using Tipa to Assess and Improve Your Processes With Iso 15504 and Prepare for Iso 20000 Certification. | |title=Itsm Process Assessment Supporting Itil - Using Tipa to Assess and Improve Your Processes With Iso 15504 and Prepare for Iso 20000 Certification. | ||
|format=PDF or hardcopy | |format=PDF or hardcopy | ||
|work=TIPA Handbook (First edition, December 2009, ISBN | |work=TIPA Handbook (First edition, December 2009, ISBN 9789087535643) | ||
|publisher=Van Haren Publishing | |publisher=Van Haren Publishing | ||
|accessdate= | |accessdate=1 January 2010 | ||
}} | }} | ||
*{{cite web | *{{cite web | ||
| Line 242: | Line 237: | ||
[[:Category:Capability assessment]] | [[:Category:Capability assessment]] | ||
[[:Category:Standards]] | [[:Category:Standards]] | ||
[[:Category:Process assessment ]] | [[:Category:Process assessment]] | ||
[[:Category:IT service management]] | [[:Category:IT service management]] | ||