Introduction to Non-Genetic Darwinism/Complexity Theory: Difference between revisions

wikademia>Graeme E. Smith
m create complexity theory split
 
wikademia>Graeme E. Smith
m editing for complexity
Line 1: Line 1:
= Complexity Theory ====''A New Kind of Science''===
= Complexity Theory =
 
===''A New Kind of Science''===


Without getting too deep into his "Principle of Computational Equivalency" Stephen Wolfram's book, <ref> A New Kind of Science, Stephen Wolfram, Wolfram Media, 2002 ISBN 157955088, 9781579550080</ref>''A New Kind of Science''offers insights that are especially interesting to this discussion, In that it mentions Cellular Automata experiments of Class 4 complexity, that indicate that order and chaos might alternate in an incremental system.
Without getting too deep into his "Principle of Computational Equivalency" Stephen Wolfram's book, <ref> A New Kind of Science, Stephen Wolfram, Wolfram Media, 2002 ISBN 157955088, 9781579550080</ref>''A New Kind of Science''offers insights that are especially interesting to this discussion, In that it mentions Cellular Automata experiments of Class 4 complexity, that indicate that order and chaos might alternate in an incremental system.
Line 5: Line 7:
====Cellular Automata and the Discovery of Oscillating Order/Chaos systems====
====Cellular Automata and the Discovery of Oscillating Order/Chaos systems====


The idea that Order and Chaos alternate in an incremental system, flies in the face of our understanding of Entropy, however, to counter our reluctance to accept this concept, we must notice that the order of our universe is strangely inconsistent, and that the second law on which we base our understanding of Entropy, is limited to an equilibrium state, and doesn't adequately describe the state where energy is being increased within the system. If we can accept that assertion, then we need to look no closer than to our periodic table to see that order is not always consistent.
The idea that Order and Chaos alternate in an incremental system, flies in the face of our understanding of Entropy as a breaking down of complexity, however, to counter our reluctance to accept this concept, we must notice that the order of our universe is strangely inconsistent, and that the second law on which we base our understanding of Entropy, is limited to an equilibrium state, and doesn't adequately describe the state where energy is being increased within the system. If we can accept that assertion, then we need to look no closer than to our periodic table to see that order is not always consistent.


You would think that the atomic weight of an atom would go up in regular increments, but as you get further and further into the periodic table, the increments get further and further apart, and the order seems to break down into large gaps where elements that were once predicted, were not found.
You would think that the atomic weight of an atom would go up in regular increments, but as you get further and further into the periodic table, the increments get further and further apart, and the order seems to break down into large gaps where elements that were once predicted, were not found. Some of this can be explained by radioactive decay but in some cases the gaps are there simply because the elements were never created. Perhaps order is not as simple as we would like to think.
some of this can be explained by radioactive decay but in some cases the gaps are there simply because the elements were never created. Perhaps order is not as simple as we would like to think.


If order is not as simple as we would like to think, then perhaps Entropy is not as simple as we would like to think especially in that area where we assume that the natural cooling effect of entropy is to break things down into simpler components. In fact, Cellular automata that have a decremental input pattern also have a tendency to break up into alternating order and chaos patterns. The fact that you can generate order in a system that is cooling, seems counter intuitive with our former understanding of entropy.
If order is not as simple as we would like to think, then perhaps Entropy is not as simple as we would like to think especially in that area where we assume that the natural cooling effect of entropy is to break things down into simpler components. In fact, Cellular automata that have a decremental input pattern also have a tendency to break up into alternating order and chaos patterns. The fact that you can generate order in a system that is cooling, seems counter intuitive with our former understanding of entropy.
Line 25: Line 26:


If this theory is correct, then we would expect the power curve to have longer and longer plateaus as the amount of entropy increases, and it takes more and more energy to create the dynamism that causes the next band of chaos to form. Further we would expect that our universe would be made up of elements that had molecular weights that fell further and further apart on the periodic table, and that we would have aggregation of galaxies that is more prevalent than was originally thought.
If this theory is correct, then we would expect the power curve to have longer and longer plateaus as the amount of entropy increases, and it takes more and more energy to create the dynamism that causes the next band of chaos to form. Further we would expect that our universe would be made up of elements that had molecular weights that fell further and further apart on the periodic table, and that we would have aggregation of galaxies that is more prevalent than was originally thought.
There is one major problem with this theory, and that is that it flies in the face of the first law of thermodynamics that energy can be neither created nor destroyed. If energy can't be created, where is all this energy needed to create the new plateaus coming from?
 
There is one major problem with this theory, and that is that it flies in the face of the first law of thermodynamics that energy can be neither created nor destroyed. If energy can't be created, where is all this energy needed to create the new plateaus on the power curve coming from?


====Conservation of Order in an Incremental System====
====Conservation of Order in an Incremental System====
Line 34: Line 36:


As the Energy/Entropy balance shifts closer to the Entropic side, either through entropic cooling, or through energy flow from one system to another, The most energetic states tend to be more sensitive to further cooling. This seems related to the force that drives energy flow from one place to another. The higher the voltage of a wire, the more insulation is needed to keep the electricity from arcing over to another wire of lower potential. This is probably why radioactive isotopes break down faster than stable isotopes. Elements were formed in the high-energy states of the early universe, and as such, unless they are quite stable, they break down when molecules made of the same elements wont. This is probably because the molecule is already more entropic than the element itself.
As the Energy/Entropy balance shifts closer to the Entropic side, either through entropic cooling, or through energy flow from one system to another, The most energetic states tend to be more sensitive to further cooling. This seems related to the force that drives energy flow from one place to another. The higher the voltage of a wire, the more insulation is needed to keep the electricity from arcing over to another wire of lower potential. This is probably why radioactive isotopes break down faster than stable isotopes. Elements were formed in the high-energy states of the early universe, and as such, unless they are quite stable, they break down when molecules made of the same elements wont. This is probably because the molecule is already more entropic than the element itself.
===Towards a new formulation of the 2nd Law===
Perhaps we need to rethink the 2nd law, or perhaps we simply need to rethink how we deal with Entropy and what we expect it to do. Probably both, since the second law is based on the classical definition of entropy. If we described the terms of the 2nd law in terms of the Energy/Entropy balance instead of on equilibrium of forces, it might be more accurate. On the other hand, it might work as it is, if we redefine equilibrium as a state of balance between energy and entropy.


==Evolution, as the emergence of order in an incremental Biological system==
==Evolution, as the emergence of order in an incremental Biological system==


I once joked, that I exist simply as an opportunity to increase the partial pressure of long-chain molecules in the Universe. If we see complexity as simply a method of cooling the Universe by sequestering energy in entropic arrangements, then, perhaps a more radical interpretation is possible, Life exists, simply to sequester more energy, than is possible with normal entropic mechanisms. It is perhaps less stable than the combination of two chemicals into a molecule, but more stable than fire. If this is true, then at the heart of Evolution we might find the same mechanism as was first used to create the elements, and then the molecules on which biology is based.
I once joked, that I exist simply as an opportunity to increase the partial pressure of long-chain molecules in the Universe. If we see complexity as simply a method of cooling the Universe by sequestering energy in entropic arrangements, then, perhaps a more radical interpretation is possible, Life exists, simply to sequester more energy, than is possible with normal entropic mechanisms. It is perhaps less stable than the combination of two chemicals into a molecule, but more stable than fire. If this is true, then at the heart of Evolution we might find the same mechanism as was first used to create the elements, and then the molecules on which biology is based.
===Open System versus Incremental/Decremental System: Which is the better description?===
If it is the Energy/Entropy balance that is important, not the source of the energy, then the concept of an open system is really only important in that there is a source of energy outside the system. What is important is that in an Incremental or Decremental system, the meaning of Entropy as breaking down complex elements into simple ones with a release of energy, being dependent on the Energy/Entropy balance, is critical to whether complexity is increased or decreased within the system. Life must therefore increase the Energy/Entropy balance during growth.
====Decremental Systems within an Incremental System, Classical Entropy====
If the Universe is expanding and energy in the Universe is increasing, then, why does entropy continue to break down complex structures into simpler ones and release energy? The answer lies in the relative energy/entropy balance in the local area, rather than the Universal Energy/Entropy balance. Because Entropy is not uniformly spread across the Universe, but depends on the processes within the universe to be created, the net effect is that some areas of the universe get lower Energy/Entropy balances than others. Within these local confines, with higher entropy, it is possible for the Entropy to cause the breakdown of complexity despite the fact that a foot further over the Energy/Entropy balance is different.


====Chemistry, how Entropy actually helps combine chemicals====
====Chemistry, how Entropy actually helps combine chemicals====
Line 71: Line 61:


Assignment:
Assignment:
*Read up on the Big Bounce Theory, does it make sense?


*Look at the Periodic Table of Atoms if you can find one that has more than just the atomic number at the top of each element, and usually near the bottom you will find the atomic weight. Look at the intervals between weights, do they trend to take longer between each element? Are they consistent, or are there gaps? Why do you think this is?
*Look at the Periodic Table of Atoms if you can find one that has more than just the atomic number at the top of each element, and usually near the bottom you will find the atomic weight. Look at the intervals between weights, do they trend to take longer between each element? Are they consistent, or are there gaps? Why do you think this is?