Archive:Expert commentaries: Difference between revisions
wikademia>McCormack New page: This page describes a proposal for a new resource type on Wikiversity. == What is an expert commentary? == An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a Wikipedia article''''' by an exp... |
wikademia>McCormack No edit summary |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a Wikipedia article''''' by an expert in the area. | An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a Wikipedia article''''' by an expert in the area. | ||
== The need for expert commentaries == | |||
[[Wikiversity development]] | == Formal criteria for an expert commentary == | ||
# '''Title''': the expert commentary has the same title (on WV) as the equivalent page on Wikipedia. In the case of pre-existing resources on WV with the same name, a kind of disambiguation list should be created. In the case where a WP page has more than one expert commentary, the main WV equivalent page should be a list of the commentaries, and the commentaries should be out into subpages. | |||
[[Category:Wikiversity development]] | |||
Revision as of 10:21, 29 June 2008
This page describes a proposal for a new resource type on Wikiversity.
What is an expert commentary?
An expert commentary is a commentary on a Wikipedia article by an expert in the area.
The need for expert commentaries
Formal criteria for an expert commentary
- Title: the expert commentary has the same title (on WV) as the equivalent page on Wikipedia. In the case of pre-existing resources on WV with the same name, a kind of disambiguation list should be created. In the case where a WP page has more than one expert commentary, the main WV equivalent page should be a list of the commentaries, and the commentaries should be out into subpages.