Archive:Expert commentaries: Difference between revisions
wikademia>McCormack |
wikademia>McCormack |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
== The need for expert commentaries == | == The need for expert commentaries == | ||
Experts constantly add their uniquely useful expertise to articles on Wikipedia. Because Wikipedia does not allow '''forking''', any subsequent editor is obliged to spoil the expert contribution. The quality improvement of a Wikipedia article is not linear - it is bumpy. An expert may be followed by amateurs, fools and vandals of varying degrees, followed by an expert who disagrees with the first one. Generally quality tends to move upwards, but at the cost of the loss of many valuable contributions during a stormy process. | Experts constantly add their uniquely useful expertise to articles on Wikipedia. Because Wikipedia does not allow '''forking''', any subsequent editor is obliged to spoil the expert contribution. The quality improvement of a Wikipedia article is not linear - it is bumpy. An expert may be followed by amateurs, fools and vandals of varying degrees, followed by an expert who disagrees with the first one. Generally quality tends to move upwards, but at the cost of the loss of many valuable contributions during a stormy process. | ||
Experts also fall tend to foul of Wikipedia's strict interpretation of NPOV and policy against original research. Experts are, undoubtedly, qualified to make statements which adopt a point-of-view and which may be original. These statements are a form of knowledge which is educational, and which should be collected and shared with humanity. However such statements are usually re-written, watered down or deleted from Wikipedia for policy reasons. | Experts also fall tend to foul of Wikipedia's strict interpretation of NPOV and policy against original research. Experts are, undoubtedly, qualified to make statements which adopt a point-of-view and which may be original. These statements are a form of knowledge which is educational, and which should be collected and shared with humanity. However such statements are usually re-written, watered down or deleted from Wikipedia for policy reasons. | ||
== Why is Wikiversity the right place for this? == | == Why is Wikiversity the right place for this? == | ||