Archive:Expert commentaries: Difference between revisions

wikademia>Erkan Yilmaz
+links
wikademia>McCormack
Line 5: Line 5:
== What is an expert commentary? ==
== What is an expert commentary? ==


An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a [[w:Main page|Wikipedia]] article''''' (or a part thereof) by an expert in the area.  
An expert commentary is a commentary '''''on a [[w:Main page|Wikipedia]] article''''' (or a part thereof) by an expert in the area. It is a piece of writing with an article-level standard and style.


===The context of an expert commentary ===
===The context of an expert commentary ===
Line 17: Line 17:
=== What kind of content does an expert commentary have? ===
=== What kind of content does an expert commentary have? ===


The word "commentary" is intended to cover a very wide field of meaning. It may be a summary, expansion, interpretation, addition or any other text which an expert, fuelled by detailed knowledge of an area, feels impelled to add to a Wikipedia article.
The word "commentary" is intended to cover a very wide field of meaning. It may be a summary, expansion, interpretation, addition or any other text which an expert, fuelled by detailed knowledge of an area, feels impelled to add to a Wikipedia article. NB: Wikipedians already have their ''talk'' pages for ''discussions'' of articles, so a commentary is not a discussion. It is a more formal and coherent kind of contribution.


== The need for expert commentaries ==
== The need for expert commentaries ==