Archive:Introduction to US History/Justification: Difference between revisions

wikademia>Jolie
wikademia>Jolie
Line 15: Line 15:
::::I think your efforts are to be applauded.  I simply like to encourage collaboration as much as possible.  Yes, it's possible that the author of the previous Wikibook might take issue with your edits (not as vandalism, but simply as "incorrect" in his opinion).  But if the book is abandoned, no one would take issue at all.  And there is always the possibility that the current author(s) would be willing to work with you to create a better, balanced book.  Would that not be worth attempting?  [[user:Jade Knight|The Jade Knight]] <sup>[[User talk:Jade Knight|(d'viser)]]</sup> 21:42, 20 October 2008 (UTC)
::::I think your efforts are to be applauded.  I simply like to encourage collaboration as much as possible.  Yes, it's possible that the author of the previous Wikibook might take issue with your edits (not as vandalism, but simply as "incorrect" in his opinion).  But if the book is abandoned, no one would take issue at all.  And there is always the possibility that the current author(s) would be willing to work with you to create a better, balanced book.  Would that not be worth attempting?  [[user:Jade Knight|The Jade Knight]] <sup>[[User talk:Jade Knight|(d'viser)]]</sup> 21:42, 20 October 2008 (UTC)
:::::Well as I see it, the US History wikibook has evolved into a euro centric general US history textbook. That is what the dynamic appears to be. I think it would be counterproductive to waltz in and attempt to shift the dynamic. Also, we are working on an AP textbook. The College Board has different ideas of topics than what you or I would include. [[User:Geo.plrd|Geo.plrd]] 05:23, 21 October 2008 (UTC)
:::::Well as I see it, the US History wikibook has evolved into a euro centric general US history textbook. That is what the dynamic appears to be. I think it would be counterproductive to waltz in and attempt to shift the dynamic. Also, we are working on an AP textbook. The College Board has different ideas of topics than what you or I would include. [[User:Geo.plrd|Geo.plrd]] 05:23, 21 October 2008 (UTC)
:::::I think Geo, that Jade has a point.  whatever the dynamic of the history book at WB, the author Clearly INTENDED to meet AP requirements, it's in the introduction.  moreover the book is 'featured' meaning its been reviewed and approved (in a limited way at least) with the WB community. This is one reason why I was less than certain that anything should have been started at WB.  
I think Geo, that Jade has a point.  whatever the dynamic of the history book at WB, the author Clearly INTENDED to meet AP requirements, it's in the introduction.  moreover the book is 'featured' meaning its been reviewed and approved (in a limited way at least) with the WB community. This is one reason why I was less than certain that anything should have been started at WB.  


Keep in mind, I am trying to reach the author. I will continue to do so.
Keep in mind, I am trying to reach the author. I will continue to do so.