Archive:Introduction to US History/Justification: Difference between revisions
wikademia>Jolie No edit summary |
wikademia>Jolie |
||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
from my point of view, this books biggest errors are bizarre inclusions of material and a biased point of view (one aim of all textbooks is to be neutral and not PICK sides in scientific debates). For now, What I want to do is catalogue irregularities. If the author is found we can go through them point by point. Future attempts to reconcile differences would be served by this as well. --[[User:Jolie|Jolie]] 12:54, 21 October 2008 (UTC) | from my point of view, this books biggest errors are bizarre inclusions of material and a biased point of view (one aim of all textbooks is to be neutral and not PICK sides in scientific debates). For now, What I want to do is catalogue irregularities. If the author is found we can go through them point by point. Future attempts to reconcile differences would be served by this as well. --[[User:Jolie|Jolie]] 12:54, 21 October 2008 (UTC) | ||
:I have created a note on the 'community bulletin board' explaining our action to the WB community. I have also created a copy of that information on the talk page of my userpage. If we cannot find representation with such a public proclamation, we must evaluate what that means. | |||
:I do hope though that the author, or someone will come along to represent that work. Perhaps we could craft a compromise? I have no problems building off of others people's knowledge- that is in a sense the very essence of what wikimedia attempts to do. ok, enough for now I am working on mayan history. I'm impressed, doing a textbook is nothing compared to the splendor of THEIR accomplishments.--[[User:Jolie|Jolie]] 14:41, 21 October 2008 (UTC) | |||
Migration of N America | Migration of N America | ||