Why some prices rise while other prices fall: Difference between revisions
m Waza moved page Why goods get cheaper while housing and care do not to Why housing and care prices rise while goods prices fall: Reword page title |
Reword title and heading |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
= Why | = Why Housing, Health Care, and Education Prices Rise While the Prices of Many Goods Fall = | ||
Rent, medical bills, child care, and tuition keep rising, while phones and televisions keep | Rent, medical bills, child care, and tuition keep rising, while phones and televisions keep falling in price. This page explains why and what would have to change. It serves two purposes. It helps readers understand scarcity versus abundance, which is central to [[Post-scarcity economy|post-scarcity]] thinking, and it supports the practical work of solving [[Problems in living|problems in living]], because housing, care, and education are the costs that press hardest on ordinary households. | ||
''This page is general information, not medical, legal, or financial advice.'' | ''This page is general information, not medical, legal, or financial advice.'' | ||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
== Education: where technology might help == | == Education: where technology might help == | ||
Robert Archibald and David Feldman of William and Mary compared higher education costs with the prices of many other goods and services from 1929 to 1995. College costs followed the path of other services that depend on highly educated labor, and the authors judged the cost disease to be the dominant long-run driver. Enlarging classes or hiring | Robert Archibald and David Feldman of William and Mary compared higher education costs with the prices of many other goods and services from 1929 to 1995. College costs followed the path of other services that depend on highly educated labor, and the authors judged the cost disease to be the dominant long-run driver. Enlarging classes or hiring lower-paid staff is often seen as a loss of quality. | ||
Software tutoring is the most discussed remedy. In a 2025 randomized trial with 194 Harvard physics students, a carefully designed AI tutor produced larger learning gains than an active-learning class, in less time. The authors cautioned that the result depended on expert-written prompts, introductory material, and months of platform development. In another 2025 trial with nearly 1,000 high school math students in Turkey, an unrestricted chatbot raised practice scores but lowered later exam scores by 17 percent. A version with teacher-designed hints only restored exam results to the level of the control group. Automation can help, but the evidence is mixed and design matters. | Software tutoring is the most discussed remedy. In a 2025 randomized trial with 194 Harvard physics students, a carefully designed AI tutor produced larger learning gains than an active-learning class, in less time. The authors cautioned that the result depended on expert-written prompts, introductory material, and months of platform development. In another 2025 trial with nearly 1,000 high school math students in Turkey, an unrestricted chatbot raised practice scores but lowered later exam scores by 17 percent. A version with teacher-designed hints only restored exam results to the level of the control group. Automation can help, but the evidence is mixed and design matters. | ||
| Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
== What would have to change == | == What would have to change == | ||
Abundance here means moving costly categories toward the side where technology | Abundance here means moving costly categories toward the side where technology lowers prices. That could mean more housing built under simpler rules, services redesigned so one skilled person can help more people without losing quality, and lower health spending through prevention and slower aging, if that proves possible. | ||
== Limits of this explanation == | == Limits of this explanation == | ||
| Line 60: | Line 60: | ||
'''Discussion questions''' | '''Discussion questions''' | ||
* Which costs in your life have risen faster than your pay, and which have fallen? | * Which costs in your life have risen faster than your pay, and which have fallen? | ||
* Can a service that cannot be made faster still become | * Can a service that cannot be made faster still become less expensive? | ||
'''Essay ideas''' | '''Essay ideas''' | ||