Geel family care and help without coercion
Seven Centuries of Taking In Strangers and What They Teach About Help Without Force
This article is educational. It is not medical, legal, or psychiatric advice, and it is not advice to stop or change any prescribed medication.
For more than seven centuries, families in the Belgian town of Geel have taken people labeled mad into their homes as lodgers. This article uses that history to look at problems in living through the moral and legal lens of the psychiatrist and critic Thomas Szasz. The thesis is simple: the most valuable part of what Geel offers, a room, a place at the table, and ordinary expectations, never required force, and the moments when Geel did use force show how hospitality turns into custody once a guest becomes a ward. Belonging is a resource that ordinary households can supply in abundance. Treating it as a scarce clinical product that must be delivered under compulsion is a choice, not a law of nature.
How a pilgrimage became a town tradition
The tradition began with pilgrims who came to the shrine of Saint Dymphna for a nine-day ritual meant to free people believed to be possessed. According to Geel Foster Family Care, the official program, the people of Geel considered it their duty to receive these pilgrims, and when the small sick room beside the church filled up, townspeople took them into their own homes. In the program's own words, care emerged "without grand theories or plans."
Henck van Bilsen, writing in the BJPsych Bulletin in 2016, stresses that this was an initiative of local peasants and townspeople, not of a churchman or a physician. The system grew to almost 4,000 boarders just before the Second World War, with people sent from Belgium, the Netherlands, France, England, Spain, and Russia.
Today it is much smaller. The official program reports about 120 boarders living with about 100 foster families. A 2024 Guardian photo report gives the same figure and says families receive a daily allowance of about 28 euros per boarder. Families may host up to three boarders, and many boarders have lived with the same household for more than twenty years. In 2023 UNESCO listed the practice as intangible cultural heritage.
What Szasz said about force and consent
Szasz argued in his 1960 essay "The Myth of Mental Illness" that brain diseases, such as syphilis of the brain, are real diseases that belong to neurology, while most of what is called mental illness is a judgment that a person's conduct deviates from psychosocial, ethical, or legal norms. He did not deny the suffering. He wrote that the troubles to which the label is attached are "real enough," and that what concerned him was the labels and "what we do about them." His name for the underlying difficulties was problems in living.
His later case against compulsion did not rest on whether psychiatric treatment works. In "The Case against Psychiatric Coercion" (The Independent Review, 1997) he wrote that he opposed involuntary psychiatric interventions "not because I believe that they are necessarily 'bad' for patients" but because he opposed using the coercive apparatus of the state to impose psychiatric relations on people against their will. He supported voluntary psychiatric relations on the same principle: the state should not interfere with agreements between consenting adults. He described civil commitment and the insanity defense as the twin foundations of institutional psychiatry. If a person called a patient breaks no law, he argued, that person has a right to liberty, and if the person breaks the law, the criminal justice system should judge and punish the act. His broader point was that psychiatric power corrupts the psychiatrists who use it, the people subjected to it, and the community that supports it.
That framework gives a clear test for Geel. The question is not whether foster care produces better outcomes than a ward. The question is whether the relationship rests on consent between equals before the law, or on the power of one party to hold the other.
What Geel got right
In 1821 the French asylum reformer Jean-Etienne Esquirol visited and, as Mike Jay recounts in Aeon, was astonished to see hundreds of boarders walking freely through the town and countryside. Families today are not told the diagnoses of their boarders and do not ask. A Hektoen International essay reports that the program's guiding phrase is "Not cure, but care," and that labeling boarders as sick is discouraged inside the home.
Boarders do the dishes, set the table, mow the lawn, shop, and feed animals, which van Bilsen describes as normal expectations and normal demands. From a Szaszian point of view, the striking feature is that what helps most here is not a medical procedure at all. It is a household that treats a person as a member with duties and standing, which is how people handle problems in living everywhere else.
The economics point the same way. Hektoen reports that the government cost is about 47 euros per boarder per day, about half of which goes to the family, and that inpatient care in Belgium would cost roughly six times as much. Spare rooms and shared meals already exist; a relationship can use them, while confinement must build and staff its own walls.
Where Geel used force
An honest account cannot stop there. Mike Jay reports that under the old church system, families were responsible for crimes committed by boarders, and some resorted to chaining and beating boarders who were violent or hard to control. Esquirol himself noted that boarders who committed excesses could have irons placed on their feet, according to a quotation reproduced by the historian Renzo Villa. Villa also records that in 1803 the prefect of the Dyle department arranged to transport the people held as mad in Brussels to Geel. Many boarders did not arrive as pilgrims. They were sent.
Around 1850 to 1852, Belgium placed the system under the state and under medical direction. Restraint and corporal punishment were banned, families received a modest payment, and a hospital was built in 1861. Jay notes that boarders now arrived as wards of the state. Van Bilsen describes an infirmary for boarders who became unmanageable, and transfer to a closed mental hospital when boarding out was judged inadvisable. Today the program is a division of a public psychiatric care center of the Flemish government, and new boarders are first formally admitted to that hospital.
This is the central lesson. Banning chains was a real moral improvement. Yet medical reform did not remove the underlying arrangement Szasz objected to. It moved the power to hold a person from the family to the state and renamed it treatment. The kindness of a host family and the legal power of a hospital sit side by side in the same system, and the first does not justify the second.
What other communities could borrow
The lesson worth copying is not the hospital. It is the household. A town, a credit union, a church, or a mutual aid network could pay ordinary families a fair allowance to host adults who choose to live with them, with a written agreement either side can end, and with no power to detain. The same logic sits behind unconditional cash for people without homes, community land trusts, and peer groups such as hearing voices groups: give people resources and relationships, and let them decide.
Szasz's test also separates real hospitality from imitations. A program that houses people only after a court order, or that can call a crisis team to remove a guest who refuses medication, has borrowed Geel's warmth while keeping the asylum's power. A program in which a guest can leave, a host can decline, and any crime is handled as a crime under ordinary law follows the voluntary model he defended.
Honest limits
- Most published accounts of Geel come from people sympathetic to it, including staff, and from journalists the hospital allowed in.
- Outcome figures from the Geel research of the 1960s and 1970s are cited secondhand in many sources, and this article does not rely on them. Under the Szaszian argument, better outcomes would not justify coercion anyway.
- Numbers differ between sources. Hektoen gives about 500 current boarders, while the official program and the Guardian give about 120. This article uses the official figure.
- The program shrank largely because fewer households have someone at home during the day, as the Guardian reports. Any copy would need to solve that problem.
Discussion questions, essay ideas, and learning related AI prompt ideas
- Why did banning chains in Geel around 1850 not end the question of whether boarders were held against their will?
- How would a foster household program look if every guest and every host could end the arrangement at any time and no one had power to detain anyone?
- Compare the Geel phrase Not cure, but care with Szasz's claim that most so-called mental illness names problems in living rather than diseases.
- What would it take for a credit union or nonprofit to fund hosting allowances for adults who choose shared family life?
- Explain why Szasz said his opposition to coercion did not depend on whether coercive treatment is good or bad for patients.
- Which spare resources in an ordinary town, such as rooms, meals, and work, could be treated as abundant rather than scarce when people need a place to belong?
See also
- Problems in living
- Psychiatric coercion and the human rights gap
- Abolishing the insanity defense
- Court-ordered outpatient psychiatry
- Soteria houses
- Hearing voices groups
Sources
- Geel Foster Family Care (Openbaar Psychiatrisch Zorgcentrum Geel), English home page. https://www.geelfostercare.be/
- van Bilsen, H. P. J. G. (2016). Lessons to be learned from the oldest community psychiatric service in the world: Geel in Belgium. BJPsych Bulletin, 40(4), 207-211. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4967781/
- Jay, M. (2014). Geel: where the mentally ill are welcomed home. Aeon. https://aeon.co/essays/geel-where-the-mentally-ill-are-welcomed-home
- Njiokiktjien, I. (2024, May 10). The Belgian town where families take in people with psychiatric conditions. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/may/10/geel-belgian-town-familes-foster-people-with-psychiatric-conditions
- Fischer, H. (2024). Geel, Belgium: 700 years of caring for mentally ill people. Hektoen International. https://hekint.org/2024/07/25/geel-belgium-700-years-of-caring-for-mentally-ill-people/
- Villa, R. Review of Geel, la citta dei matti. https://doi.org/10.4000/139ap
- UNESCO. Safeguarding foster care heritage in the merciful city of Geel. https://ich.unesco.org/en/BSP/safeguarding-foster-care-heritage-in-the-merciful-city-of-geel-a-community-based-care-model-00622
- Szasz, T. S. (1960). The myth of mental illness. American Psychologist, 15, 113-118. https://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Szasz/myth.htm
- Szasz, T. (1997). The case against psychiatric coercion. The Independent Review, 1(4), 485-498. https://www.independent.org/wp-content/uploads/tir/1997/04/tir_01_4_01_szasz.pdf